Recycled players

[Unwritten_Law]

With Thurley now gone you would think it is a sure thing that we pick up at least one delisted player, I can't see the club taking 5 fresh kids.

Tom Logan
Llane Spaanderman
Damian Cupido
Andrew Siegert
Will Slade
Michael Stevens
Ashley Watson
Steven Armstrong
Alex Gilmour

Is a quickly pieced together short list. Siegert would have to be the front runner from that group.

Who do we all favour?

 

[Sammy D]

Not Siegert. Didn't like the look of that knee brace.

To be honest I don't know a look about a lot of them. Been patient enough with Slade. How about giving a kid a second go?

 

[JUBJUB]

Tom Logan
Llane Spaanderman
Damian Cupido
Andrew Siegert
Will Slade
Michael Stevens
Ashley Watson
Steven Armstrong
Alex Gilmour

Pass on Cupido and Armstrong.
Nothing exciting about Stevens,so no.
Don't know much about Logan,Watson or Gilmour.
Slade might be a chance if he's fully fit and by the sounds of it Siegert would be a likely pick.
Is Spaanderman a ruckman ? If so,he could be a chance.

 

[LifeSpan-Void]

Spaanderman is 198cm/99kg, I would call him more a KPP than a bona fide ruckman. Has the same stats as Playfair.

 

[JUBJUB]

Spaanderman is 198cm/99kg, I would call him more a KPP than a bona fide ruckman. Has the same stats as Playfair.

Then we better not draft him.Poor Jack from Packenham Upper will have a heart attack.

 

[nananana catman]

With Thurley now gone you would think it is a sure thing that we pick up at least one delisted player, I can't see the club taking 5 fresh kids.

Tom Logan
Llane Spaanderman
Damian Cupido
Andrew Siegert
Will Slade
Michael Stevens
Ashley Watson
Steven Armstrong
Alex Gilmour

Is a quickly pieced together short list. Siegert would have to be the front runner from that group.

Who do we all favour?

Why the neccesity to draft a recycled when the one e lost wasnt exactly and experienced player anyway?

 

[pilkos_cats]

i say we take a punt on cupido, there is no dout that he has the talent to be a star and now it looks like where ever he goes it will be his last chance so maybe he will pull his finger out and nuckle down, you never no?

 

[carn_the_cattas]

i say we take a punt on cupido, there is no dout that he has the talent to be a star and now it looks like where ever he goes it will be his last chance so maybe he will pull his finger out and nuckle down, you never no?

Bomber got Mooney to loose his temper and become more committed, he should give Cupido a shot.
He would alow Steve Johnson, Gaz and Chappy more time in the midfield.

 

[pilkos_cats]

true but still like 2c chappy and steve in the foward line but if ablett goes in the middle all year i reacon nath ablett would kick 60 odd goals because garry would just look for his bro and give him perfect delivery

 

[scottydeewah]

I personally asked Cupido to come down to Geelong and he told me

"******** OFF THE CATS ARE A BUNCH OF ********ING GIRLS"

so maybe not.

 

[Unwritten_Law]

Why the neccesity to draft a recycled when the one e lost wasnt exactly and experienced player anyway?

1 year instead of 2 year deals. Important with the supposed strength of next year's draft we have as many picks as possible.

By the time you get to pick 60 there isn't going to be much left, so take an experienced player in the PSD, they provide depth for the season and if they don't turn it around say goodbye and thanks for your efforts in the VFL.

It is a little wasteful but thinking ahead who would you delist next season. McCarthy if they haven't offered him 2 years and errm Koula? Lonergan? Prismall? Gardiner? We have disposed of most of the players with no long term future this season.

 

[carn_the_cattas]

I personally asked Cupido to come down to Geelong and he told me

"******** OFF THE CATS ARE A BUNCH OF ********ING GIRLS"

so maybe not.

Serious? No wonder he was delisted....that arrogant son of a.....something something

 

[cats2rise]

With Thurley now gone you would think it is a sure thing that we pick up at least one delisted player, I can't see the club taking 5 fresh kids.

Tom Logan
Llane Spaanderman
Damian Cupido
Andrew Siegert
Will Slade
Michael Stevens
Ashley Watson
Steven Armstrong
Alex Gilmour

Is a quickly pieced together short list. Siegert would have to be the front runner from that group.

Who do we all favour?

Does anyone else have a fuller list than that?
Dylan Smith,
Camporeale,
ermmm...?!?