Riewoldt or Franklin

[Hawkmad]

Wanting to fill a permanent position in my forward line but can't decide on which of these 2 to choose.
My current forward line - C. Cornes,G. Ablett,B. Johnson,J. Brown, S. Lucas,B. Ebert & Alwyn Davey - Emerg. T. Hawkins & S. Cox.
Will be looking to trade Hawkins for either 1 of the above.

Sorry for the repeat question as I asked this in the supercoach thread & got 2 replies 1 for franklin & 1 for Riewoldt so still undecided.

 

[PAFCsince1870]

Riewoldt is a safer bet by a mile

Franklin has gone up a fair bit, whereas in SC especially Riewoldt has plummeted. The only way in value is up for Riewoldt, Franklin could go off the boil, who knows? For mine, you had to have Franklin from the start of the year, and personally I'm upgrading Hawkins to Riewoldt this week.

 

[Ari]

I have Franklin and am rather happy with him.

 

[jbomb3000]

I have Franklin and am rather happy with him.

Same here, but if i was to trade one of them in now i would probably go riewoldt.

 

[eugene_tomas]

ive got both but reiwoldt is clearly a nobrainer

 

[magpies03]

ive got both but reiwoldt is clearly a nobrainer

a what????lol

 

[The RPM]

You serious magpies03? it's an expression, it means Riewoldt is such an obvious choice one need not put any thought into the decision.

 

[WakeUpPies]

riewoldt even though i hate him

 

[reedy619]

the great reedy619 will make his decision.................. riewoldt

 

[hawka_fan]

How about Franklin to Riewolt? Worth it?

 

[flackjack]

How about Franklin to Riewolt? Worth it?

I personally wouldn't waste a trade on that, how many extra points would you get from Riewoldt over Franklin, not many i'd think. There's probably other areas you could improve on.

 

[jbomb3000]

How about Franklin to Riewolt? Worth it?

Not worth it IMO

 

[banana_bus]

is this another joke thread?

 

[Hawkmad]

is this another joke thread?

Please Explain?

I thought it was a reasonable question to ask I have got 1 position to fill & couldn't decide which 1 to take. So I am asking everyones opinion.

 

[banana_bus]

Please Explain?

I thought it was a reasonable question to ask I have got 1 position to fill & couldn't decide which 1 to take. So I am asking everyones opinion.

OK ill explain. In simple words for you too. Nick Riewoldt is one of the best DTers around. Buddy Franklin has had a good start to the season, and will have his occasional big scores, but will not be consistent.

Nick Riewoldt >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Lance Franklin.

By 35000 light years.

 

[Cartman121]

OK ill explain. In simple words for you too. Nick Riewoldt is one of the best DTers around. Buddy Franklin has had a good start to the season, and will have his occasional big scores, but will not be consistent.

Nick Riewoldt >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Lance Franklin.

By 35000 light years.

Lol exactly

 

[corks]

Lol exactly

Nick Riewoldt cant kick for shi t.. all he can do is take a mark. if he could kick would will coleman medals.. Franklin does both can kick and take a mark.

 

[sante]

Nick Riewoldt cant kick for shi t.. all he can do is take a mark. if he could kick would will coleman medals.. Franklin does both can kick and take a mark.

Consistently, Franklin hasn't showed it.

 

[JoondalupJ]

Wanting to fill a permanent position in my forward line but can't decide on which of these 2 to choose.
My current forward line - C. Cornes,G. Ablett,B. Johnson,J. Brown, S. Lucas,B. Ebert & Alwyn Davey - Emerg. T. Hawkins & S. Cox.
Will be looking to trade Hawkins for either 1 of the above.

Sorry for the repeat question as I asked this in the supercoach thread & got 2 replies 1 for franklin & 1 for Riewoldt so still undecided.

Franklin