riewoldt or j brown

[Roos 07]

who would u rather?

 

[Kahuna]

Probably Riewoldt as he is less likely to get injured.

 

[dAmo.22]

but in terms of score wise, j.b can have a shit game and still score 80-100 and on a good day he can rack up 150-180

 

[Hodges]

Case in point - last weekend. Only kicked two goals but still scored 90-odd. Missed some kickable ones that would have given him 120+. Id probably go with Brown.

 

[dAmo.22]

Case in point - last weekend. Only kicked two goals but still scored 90-odd. Missed some kickable ones that would have given him 120+. Id probably go with Brown.

exactly my point good call there mate

 

[Dazman]

I've got a forward query, just thought I'd add it on to the end of this.

Who would you rather in forwards as an upgrade for Monfries. I can afford anyone but I'm looking at Brad Johnson, Gary Ablett or Nick Riewoldt.

I've been keen on BJ for ages but his SC scores aren't that impressive recently and I thought maybe he isn't playing the same role as last year and that might make a difference to his scores. Ablett's just come off a huge week and gets alot of the pill and Roo has fluctuated abit.

So who would win it for you guys?

 

[Captain Pump]

I've got a forward query, just thought I'd add it on to the end of this.

Who would you rather in forwards as an upgrade for Monfries. I can afford anyone but I'm looking at Brad Johnson, Gary Ablett or Nick Riewoldt.

I've been keen on BJ for ages but his SC scores aren't that impressive recently and I thought maybe he isn't playing the same role as last year and that might make a difference to his scores. Ablett's just come off a huge week and gets alot of the pill and Roo has fluctuated abit.

So who would win it for you guys?

Johnson if you can afford him now. Otherwise wait 2 weeks and get Reiwoldt when he is even cheaper. Preferably do both.

edit
This would be true for DT, not sure about SC.

 

[Dazman]

Johnson if you can afford him now. Otherwise wait 2 weeks and get Reiwoldt when he is even cheaper. Preferably do both.

edit
This would be true for DT, not sure about SC.

Worked out abit of a plan. I've got a fair bit of cash so I'll grab Ablett or Johnno now. Trade in Tim Boyle for Jesse Smith and then I'll be able to get the very cheap Riewoldt in for Nathan Ablett or Alwyn Davey.

 

[Ari]

Who would you rather in forwards as an upgrade for Monfries.

I actually traded Monfries out for Gehrig today..... and Lloyd out for Brown.

I know LLoyd is a good earner, but im not sure how he's going to go re this hammy plus I think Lucas will do most of the work from here on in the forward line.

Let's hope I've made the right choices in the above!!

 

[1eyedPie]

I actually traded Monfries out for Gehrig today.....

terrible trade,

Gehrig is up and down like a yo yo.

 

[Ari]

terrible trade,

Gehrig is up and down like a yo yo.

I know its risky... but Gus just isnt racking em up!!!