Rookie Defender - Broughton or Grima?

[Flashhh]

Am looking to put one of these boys on my bench and earns some cash or play out the year as an emergency if I need.

Too serious lists Broughton as the number one option ahead of Grima but I'm not sold. Broughton has been in and out of the side while Grima will have Pratt to contend with when he returns.

Broughton or Grima?

 

[Hondo]

I voted Broughton but I'm not sold on either even though I planned to bring Broughton in this week to gather the extra cash I need for Ablett.

I plan to downgrade Suban however my issue is that Suban appears to be a lock in the side while Broughton was dropped last week.

Grima I don't know much about. I think there's risk with both of them.

 

[Flashhh]

Yes there is a hell of a lot of risk with both but they will only be replacing Petrenko who isn't playing anyway and I have Suban as emergency also so won't be the end of the world if they aren't a regular.

 

[peter_ford]

if broughton can stay on the ballpark; him over grima everyday of the week. i was actually relieve when he wasn't named last week. gave me a chance to bring in grimes and sidebottom.

 

[L_J_T]

Broughton will get more games now with Hayden breaking his leg in my opinion.

 

[Carlton Kid]

Bring in Broughton. He will get more games and have a higher average at the end of the year.