Round 2 Trades

[Blackhawk42]

Hey all! Fairly new to AFL and this is my first year doing supercoach. I rushed the hell out of my team and didn't have much time for research.. my team is below and any tips would be appreciated! Thanks from across the pond!

Duman to Brodie Smith. Then put Collins on your bench.
Then O'Brien to Matt Parker and put Toby Greene on your bench.
??? If you really want to do two trades this week those are possible suggestions.
Aside from that your team is solid with very justifiable selections!

 

[vast]

Hey all! Fairly new to AFL and this is my first year doing supercoach. I rushed the hell out of my team and didn't have much time for research.. my team is below and any tips would be appreciated! Thanks from across the pond!

Trade early and as much as possible if i dont u will fall too far behind then its pointless.

 

[ubeaut]

Thoughts on this trades kentys?

Dusty>Sheed
Greene>Whitfield

Trigger or hold?

Yay on 1st
Hold on 2nd.
1st gives u cash now and later.
2nd uses that cash prematurely. Give the punchable 1 a chance to redeem himself. If he fails, u still have the cash to upgrade and Shitfield's price won't be too much higher.

 

[Cold Sober]

Thoughts on this trades kentys?

Dusty>Sheed
Greene>Whitfield

Trigger or hold?

Toby Greene looked alright on the weekend. Whitfield is a MUST be maybe not at the expense of Greene.

I wouldn't do Dusty>Sheed. Small sample size thus far on Sheed. We know more about Dusty and his capacity to score high and consistently is proven.

 

[vast]

I'm just grateful that I'll only be burning 1 trade on Rocky this year since I started with him.

You could always bring him back after 3 weeks.....

 

[Blackhawk42]

Duman to Brodie Smith. Then put Collins on your bench.
Then O'Brien to Matt Parker and put Toby Greene on your bench.
??? If you really want to do two trades this week those are possible suggestions.
Aside from that your team is solid with very justifiable selections!

Edit: that would still leave a zero because of Balta. Other people's suggestions might be better

 

[Chrissybabes]

Thoughts on this trades kentys?

Dusty>Sheed
Greene>Whitfield

Trigger or hold?

Sheed is ultra tempting but i want to see another week first. Also trading out Dusty could be a regret down the line (Although he will be down this week with a tag)

I also have Greene but I'll be holding him, deserves another chance. He is also the spirit animal of my team "Toby's Toe Beans"

 

[Cold Sober]

Hello, As a novice I am thinking of trading down Grundy to Westhoff??? and using the extra cash to upgrade Collins to a Ridley or???
Is this too rash in one or either way?
Thoughts appreciated - Kellie

Hold Grundy. Westhoff just killed Melbourne because he was up against Frost and Oscar McDonald. I'd probably look good against those two. Grundy is a proven commodity and will benefit this year with the rule that allows players to take the ball out of a boundary throw in - without getting pinged.

 

[Cold Sober]

Greene to Worpel. Reckon he has more upside than Dahl, who i can see having a good first 4 or 5 games and then being mediocre for the rest of the season

Keep Greene above the other two. Dahl is not going to outscore Toby Greene, and Worpel is lucky to even be playing AFL.

 

[Cold Sober]

So Lil Libba had 28 Disp (13 contested) and 8 clearances (double any other doggie), and scored only 75
Yeah that shit just keeps sticking in my craw.
There's just something about him, looks so creepy and my grandma could run him down.

Already feels like having one of those little troll dolls sitting in my midfield ruining my entire team.

Libba won't ruin your team - he will enhance it, and you are getting him CHEAP! The kid is tough as nails and is a proven ball winner (just like his old man), stick with him and reap the benefits.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Wow.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Godammit Al. I want as much Rocky carnage as possible.

 

[Andrew Birch]

You could always bring him back after 3 weeks.....

I suppose I could but I'd need some sort of head injury where I lose all impulse control and critical thinking ability.

 

[Cold Sober]

Another average Heeny score this weekend combined with another solid Worpel score will result in that trade happening before price changes. I desperately need some extra cash to play around with.
Best part is that it will mean Heeny is super affordable for a little while and Darcy Knightly or Setterfield could be turned back into him once (if) his form reverses.
But in the mean time I'd have nearly $200k to spend somewhere which quite early on could be used to turn Sam Walsh or Brodie Smith into a premium mid or defender.
I actually see the positive in this scenario outweighing the negative of a 'wasted' trade if I plan to bring Heeny back again.

A lot of 'if's. Heeney is of absolute top shelf star quality, and has apparently had a super pre-season. Stick with him, don't even bother wasting a trade with the promise of getting him back in. Just be happy you were astute enough to select him in the first place.

 

[vast]

View attachment 643352

 

[vast]

I suppose I could but I'd need some sort of head injury where I lose all impulse control and critical thinking ability.

Lol uve been playing this insanity for 10 years. Dont pretend is thinking is logical.

 

[Cold Sober]

I suppose I could but I'd need some sort of head injury where I lose all impulse control and critical thinking ability.

No you don't. I speak from experience, its not a fun existence.

 

[WaynesWorld19]

 

[Seymour Skinner]

I'm just grateful that I'll only be burning 1 trade on Rocky this year since I started with him.

That's why I always start Fyfe.

 

[Andrew Birch]

Lol uve been playing this insanity for 10 years. Dont pretend is thinking is logical.

I'm not though, I'm saying the opposite of that.

 

[vast]

View attachment 643356

Truth hurts.

 

[PowerForGood]

I read this thread and wish that they changed the rules and let you have 30 trades total, use them when you want, but weekly prize limited to those with less than 3 trades that week.

Just for the lolz week 2 trades. Imagine....

"I'm thinking of trading players D1, D3, D4, D6, D7, M3-10 incl, R2, F4, F5 and F6. For this list of 16 other players that killed it last week. My strategy is that if every player gets the same score as last week, I'll score 3147."

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Truth hurts.

Yes it does ....

 

[vast]

I read this thread and wish that they changed the rules and let you have 30 trades total, use them when you want, but weekly prize limited to those with less than 3 trades that week.

Just for the lolz week 2 trades. Imagine....

"I'm thinking of trading players D1, D3, D4, D6, D7, M3-10 incl, R2, F4, F5 and F6. For this list of 16 other players that killed it last week. My strategy is that if every player gets the same score as last week, I'll score 3147."

Just give us unlimited trades.Imagine all the in and out manuevring we could do then Judd_Magic

 

[vast]

Yes it does .... View attachment 643361

Some truths take longer to reveal themselves...