Round 23 Trades

[PHOENIX_RISING]

..............

 

[GenuineMatchWinner]

ok boys and girls, wondering what people think should be doing this week. i was here last week and managed to get through holding the trade. so got 1 left and $87,800 in the bank. My list of players and players in brackets are his different players.

Backs:
Deledio
Scotland
Goddard
Hurn (Birchall)
H.Shaw
Lake
Carrazzo
---------------
S.Shaw (Ellis)
Bell (Paine)


Midfield:
Ablett
Watson (Kennedy)
Thompson
Hayes (J.Selwood)
Dal Santo (Pendlebury)
Priddis
----------------
Barlow (Gibson)
Baguley (Couch)


Rucks:
Jacobs (Naitanui)
Giles (Goldstein)
-----------------
Redden (Stephenson)
Campbell


Forwards:
Dangerfield
Beams (Sidebottom)
Pavlich
Harvey (S.Johnson)
Martin (Lewis)
Franklin
Zorko
-----------------
Goodes (Adams)
Crozier (Elliott)

Im thinking of trading a ruck or a defender, interested to see peoples thoughts!

 

[BORK]

Absolutely no point asking the question until at least Thursday evening.

 

[shaun1800]

Im thinking of trading a ruck or a defender, interested to see peoples thoughts!

I'd probably go lake to adcock, hanley or hurn.

 

[gh172]

Im finally going to trade out that spud Cloke and grab Tippett for a big one against the Sun's!

 

[1989]

Im finally going to trade out that spud Cloke and grab Tippett for a big one against the Sun's!

Hoping for your sake that Cloke doesn't beat up on the Bombers and bag eight.

 

[gh172]

I'd been hoping that all season, I've given up on him!

 

[Double the Fist]

2 left to cover 'the General'.
Will be good to have Jselwood back. Dunno about Ryder. Giles may just have to stay put. Unless I do a Lyon and chuck Sandi in

 

[Propagandhi]

Will definitely be...
Out: Whichever premium gets rested (Dangerfield perhaps...?)
In: The next best available

 

[Commando]

Will upgrade a defender to scotland

Lake, Dempsey, S.Shaw? Need to trade one, play one and bench one?

Thoughts...

Cheers

 

[SCchamp]

Will upgrade a defender to scotland

Lake, Dempsey, S.Shaw? Need to trade one, play one and bench one?

Thoughts...

Cheers

i would upgrade Lake, bench Shaw and play Dempsey.

Who should i leave on the bench....
Franklin, Sidebottom, Martin, Fyfe, Hawkins, Dangerfield, Zorko or Tippett

 

[Propagandhi]

i would upgrade Lake, bench Shaw and play Dempsey.

Who should i leave on the bench....
Franklin, Sidebottom, Martin, Fyfe, Hawkins, Dangerfield, Zorko or Tippett

Wow, that's a tough one. I like all of those options this week! I'm taking it you can't move one of those guys to the midfield and bench a Rocky or Stanton type player?

I guess it has to be out of Martin, Fyfe, Zorko, Tippett and Hawkins - and they all showed something last week! I'd probably go Hawkins as the key positional forwards tend to have a lower floor and the Cats play Sydney.

Will definitely be...
Out: Whichever premium gets rested (Dangerfield perhaps...?)
In: The next best available

Damn, where are all the generals?? None of my players rested... In which case I suppose it has to be:

Out:Giles
In: Sandi

 

[Madison]

Thinking about trading out Lake, but it would be a sideways trade. Michael Johnson, Birchall and Suckling are all in my range.

Opponent has all except Johnson, who is a nice POD and can score big. I'm worried Lake won't play. I have average cover if he doesn't.

Should I just stick with Lake or make a trade? Are there other players I should think about?

 

[SCchamp]

Wow, that's a tough one. I like all of those options this week! I'm taking it you can't move one of those guys to the midfield and bench a Rocky or Stanton type player?

I guess it has to be out of Martin, Fyfe, Zorko, Tippett and Hawkins - and they all showed something last week! I'd probably go Hawkins as the key positional forwards tend to have a lower floor and the Cats play Sydney.

My mids are pretty solid Ablett, Pendles, Jelwood, Watson, Boyd and Priddis

For some strange reason my guts telling me to bench Zorko, last week i had Tippett on the bench which costed me in one of my leagues. Tomahawk is in great form and im guessing he's gonna want to try overtake Pav for the Coleman.

Cant wait for supercoach to be over, my mind can rest for a while, well untill i started preparing for 2013 ahaha

 

[Dizzy Stuff]

Thinking about trading out Lake, but it would be a sideways trade. Michael Johnson, Birchall and Suckling are all in my range.

Opponent has all except Johnson, who is a nice POD and can score big. I'm worried Lake won't play. I have average cover if he doesn't.

Should I just stick with Lake or make a trade? Are there other players I should think about?

If there's nowhere else you can make the trade, you might as well get rid of Lake. Of the 3 you mentioned, I like Birchall the most. If however you want to a pick a player that your opponent doesn't have, perhaps Hanley could be an option? His scoring is pretty erratic so be wary of the fact that he could pull out a 50, but he has the Dogs this week, against whom he scored 151 earlier in the year, and he generally seems to score well against the weaker sides. If you need to take a risk to win your league GF I'd go Hanley. Otherwise play it safe with Birchall.

My personal predicament is whether to upgrade Lake > Scotland or Treloar > Dangerfield. Treloar is currently on my bench, but if I did this trade, I'd start Dangerfield (obviously) and bench Goodes, so the trade is really Goodes > Dangerfield in terms of who will be playing in my 22. Anyone have any thoughts?

 

[Satan]

If there's nowhere else you can make the trade, you might as well get rid of Lake. Of the 3 you mentioned, I like Birchall the most. If however you want to a pick a player that your opponent doesn't have, perhaps Hanley could be an option? His scoring is pretty erratic so be wary of the fact that he could pull out a 50, but he has the Dogs this week, against whom he scored 151 earlier in the year, and he generally seems to score well against the weaker sides. If you need to take a risk to win your league GF I'd go Hanley. Otherwise play it safe with Birchall.

My personal predicament is whether to upgrade Lake > Scotland or Treloar > Dangerfield. Treloar is currently on my bench, but if I did this trade, I'd start Dangerfield (obviously) and bench Goodes, so the trade is really Goodes > Dangerfield in terms of who will be playing in my 22. Anyone have any thoughts?

If there's nowhere else you can make the trade, you might as well get rid of Lake. Of the 3 you mentioned, I like Birchall the most. If however you want to a pick a player that your opponent doesn't have, perhaps Hanley could be an option? His scoring is pretty erratic so be wary of the fact that he could pull out a 50, but he has the Dogs this week, against whom he scored 151 earlier in the year, and he generally seems to score well against the weaker sides. If you need to take a risk to win your league GF I'd go Hanley. Otherwise play it safe with Birchall.

My personal predicament is whether to upgrade Lake > Scotland or Treloar > Dangerfield. Treloar is currently on my bench, but if I did this trade, I'd start Dangerfield (obviously) and bench Goodes, so the trade is really Goodes > Dangerfield in terms of who will be playing in my 22. Anyone have any thoughts?

Dangerfield plays gold coast in ade, goodes is at geelong, dangerfield likely to score better than goodes . Big issues is the general making a late appearance

 

[Propagandhi]

My mids are pretty solid Ablett, Pendles, Jelwood, Watson, Boyd and Priddis

For some strange reason my guts telling me to bench Zorko, last week i had Tippett on the bench which costed me in one of my leagues. Tomahawk is in great form and im guessing he's gonna want to try overtake Pav for the Coleman.

Cant wait for supercoach to be over, my mind can rest for a while, well untill i started preparing for 2013 ahaha

Sounds like a really solid team. Zorko benched last week wouldn't have netted you any more points as he was the highest scorer of the round! Maybe I'm biased, but you gotta back Zorko; he hasn't really played a bad game... Martin on the other hand..... A gut feeling is a gut feeling though! I wish I had your problem :|

 

[toxic]

thinking about trading..... oops thats god damm rite i dont have any bloody trades!

 

[shaun1800]

Can't believe there has been no restings, seems too good to be true...
After tossing up between hurn and adcock I've decided to go Lake to Hanley.
Feels like he could be a good pod and can potentially go huge. Fingers crossed.

 

[toxic]

Can't believe there has been no restings, seems too good to be true...
After tossing up between hurn and adcock I've decided to go Lake to Hanley.
Feels like he could be a good pod and can potentially go huge. Fingers crossed.

Good call!

 

[Couch Coach]

Final Trade:
Keep Goodes (plays Geelong)
or trade to:
J Riewoldt (plays Port)
or D Petrie (plays GWS)

 

[LCJ_10]

I don't have any trades and have settled on most of my team but not sure who to bench out of my defenders. I've got Deledio, Goddard, Suckling, Carrazzo, Yarran, Shaw, Dempsey, Hibberd and Spurr. Last week I benched Hibberd and Spurr and Dempsey had a very quiet game. Who should I bench?

 

[SCchamp]

Final Trade:
Keep Goodes (plays Geelong)
or trade to:
J Riewoldt (plays Port)
or D Petrie (plays GWS)

Jroo is going to want that Coleman medal around his neck....he wont be passing much lol

 

[Couch Coach]

Jroo is going to want that Coleman medal around his neck....he wont be passing much lol

Thanks,

That's what I was thinking but with Petrie only 4 goals behind him and playing GWS I was second guessing myself that Petrie would make a big run for the Coleman also.

 

[TimC]

I don't have any trades and have settled on most of my team but not sure who to bench out of my defenders. I've got Deledio, Goddard, Suckling, Carrazzo, Yarran, Shaw, Dempsey, Hibberd and Spurr. Last week I benched Hibberd and Spurr and Dempsey had a very quiet game. Who should I bench?

If Shaw is Sam Shaw then bench him. If that is Heath Shaw I would be benching Suckling.

Any advice on what to do with trades, these are my unqiue players vs. the guy I am playing in the GF (mine in bold):

M. Johnson v S. Shaw

Boyd v J. Selwood
S. Mitchell v Dal Santo

Cox v Nic Nat
Giles v McEvoy

Pav v Harvey
Martin v Goodes

I have 2 trades left (I can downgrade one of my bench players if need be).