Round 3 Trades (with POLL)

[ubeaut]

Rozee or LDU ?

Without knowing ur team and who gets traded out, LDU cos he'll make more cash and is not much more than Rozee in price.

 

[Test Tickle]

Post your team bruh.

OK i think Ive made a mistake picking Dusty and Elliott.
Now I'm thinking Elliott OUT, move Drew FWD and trade in LDU or Rozee?
Then Dusty > Neale.

I'm really struggling with this one, help.

 

[adam10]

Tossing up if I should bite the bullet and offload Heeney early... limited midfield time worries me. Liked the idea of Caleb Daniel before the season and picked him in draft... I want him in classic.

Heeney - Boak
Greene - Daniel

or

Collins - Duursma
Greene - Daniel

 

[Requiem]

OK i think Ive made a mistake picking Dusty and Elliott.
Now I'm thinking Elliott OUT, move Drew FWD and trade in LDU or Rozee?
Then Dusty > Neale.

I'm really struggling with this one, help.

View attachment 647404

IMO LDU > Rozee for your purposes.

The trade you suggested is the one I would do.

 

[ubeaut]

OK i think Ive made a mistake picking Dusty and Elliott.
Now I'm thinking Elliott OUT, move Drew FWD and trade in LDU or Rozee?
Then Dusty > Neale.

I'm really struggling with this one, help.

View attachment 647404

Those trades with LDU sound great OR
What about Elliott > Rozee, Jones > LDU
And trade Dusty next week if necessary? Depending if u can afford it with breakeven etc.

 

[Test Tickle]

Those trades with LDU sound great OR
What about Elliott > Rozee, Jones > LDU
And trade Dusty next week if necessary? Depending if u can afford it with breakeven etc.

I like it thanks, deep down id like to give Dusty one more week.

 

[Duckworthy]

Does anyone think I'll be missing out on something good if I don't make a trade this week? Not that keen on LDU and I'm ok with holding Goldy, Heeney, Dunks and McGrath for a few more weeks.

 

[Daniel McL]

Thoughts North supporters on what happens to LDU’s role if Anderson, Dumont & Ahern come in.

Does LDU’s role change? Or has he been so good the first two weeks that he is ahead of those guys in the midfield rotations? Or is Brad Scott a kent?

 

[chillilovers]

Thinking Simpson -> Lloyd, maybe Balta -> Rozee or Heeney -> Boak? Any help appreciated.

Thanks.

 

[Brizzys Squizzy]

Cut the cheerleading. Noone doubts how good he is.

The issue, and its a very important one for many of us, is that he has gone from being a #2 mid behind fyfe, to a #1 mid who will attract more attention the better he is going.
Same question Sloane faced.
Same issue we saw in Zorko.
Same issue we see in many others over a long long time.

Neale is now due for that attention.

Not all guys cope well with it.

We dont need to hear how good they are when they are scoring 140's early. We know how good they are. But there are 20 more rounds to go and Neale will now get more attention than ever.

I want to know (from best guesses) if i might be buying another Sloane.

Bloody hell you've been given all the info what you want a crystal ball you know what don't pick him suits me and all the other smart one's that have him all ready

 

[ubeaut]

Does anyone think I'll be missing out on something good if I don't make a trade this week? Not that keen on LDU and I'm ok with holding Goldy, Heeney, Dunks and McGrath for a few more weeks.
View attachment 647412

Team looks good apart from McGrath at D2. He's not a SC player. In a JLT he was best on for us, kicked 2 goals and got 85.
You're right u don't need LDU with Libba and Walsh at M6+7. But McGrath is a liability.

 

[Chrissybabes]

I don't feel confident trading in any of Newman/Saad/Rich for Mills, so I've taken the same approach you have and gone for the cash cow rookies.

Mills > Scrimshaw
Attkins > LDU

Pity I can't also get Rozee, but we can't get them all can we?

No love for Newman?

 

[pincrusher]

Does anyone think I'll be missing out on something good if I don't make a trade this week? Not that keen on LDU and I'm ok with holding Goldy, Heeney, Dunks and McGrath for a few more weeks.
View attachment 647412

No pressing needs if you are set on holding your under performers. you have all the good rookies apart from LDU. i would be looking at freeing up funds for goldy>gawn though if he spuds it up again.

 

[gcsunsfc]

Does anyone think I'll be missing out on something good if I don't make a trade this week? Not that keen on LDU and I'm ok with holding Goldy, Heeney, Dunks and McGrath for a few more weeks.
View attachment 647412

I think you can hold

 

[Requiem]

No love for Newman?

Unsure about his consistency & doubt he'll be a top 6 defender this season. At this stage I've had a gut-full of Mid-pricers, my rankings are shit now and will be for a while, so why not make some cash while I'm down?

 

[Duckworthy]

Team looks good apart from McGrath at D2. He's not a SC player. In a JLT he was best on for us, kicked 2 goals and got 85.
You're right u don't need LDU with Libba and Walsh at M6+7. But McGrath is a liability.

McGrath is my only regret at this stage but I was expecting him to play mids. Gleeson and Redman are probably only a couple of weeks away from selection contention and that would free him up to move to the middle. His price won't change much so I'll hold him for the moment and upgrade him to an SP when I cash in on a rookie

 

[Duckworthy]

No pressing needs if you are set on holding your under performers. you have all the good rookies apart from LDU. i would be looking at freeing up funds for goldy>gawn though if he spuds it up again.

Changing Gawn to Goldy allowed me to change from Mills to the Seagull only a day or two before the season started. Happy with that. Will give Goldy a few weeks to assess his form.

 

[Tulendeena]

Billings > Rockliff

Thoughts?

 

[JuddgementDay]

Unsure about his consistency & doubt he'll be a top 6 defender this season. At this stage I've had a gut-full of Mid-pricers, my rankings are shit now and will be for a while, so why not make some cash while I'm down?

I'm 50/50 atm
Mills to moore for $$$
Mills to Milera for possible keeper & better scoring
Cant decide

 

[rocker_oz33]

Simmo giving me the shites.
Can go to Lloyd.

But greene likley wont play and his durability duing the year is a worry.

Grrrr kent of a game.

 

[PowerForGood]

Billings > Rockliff

Thoughts?

Short answer? Yes.
Long answer? A longer way of saying yes.

 

[PowerForGood]

Simmo giving me the shites.
Can go to Lloyd.

But greene likley wont play and his durability duing the year is a worry.

Grrrr kent of a game.

Greene is using up a bit of cash, but isn't losing cash for at least a fortnight. Hold for a week unless you really need the $$$

 

[SC fish]

Does anyone think I'll be missing out on something good if I don't make a trade this week? Not that keen on LDU and I'm ok with holding Goldy, Heeney, Dunks and McGrath for a few more weeks.
View attachment 647412

If I had that team I'd HOLD

 

[Girthquake]

Aitkens a possible late out this weekend, the people thinking of trading him to LDU, do it

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Can't quite afford LDU if I go Mundy>Kelly. About $20k short.



Cheers, I think if I go Mundy>Kelly I would certainly consider Hanley to Moore just for some cash back-up for later rounds, and easy rookie upgrades.



I'm liking the Mundy to Worpel trade as it gives me some cash if I need it to correct Heeney/Dunkley/Hanley over the next couple of rounds.

Mundy>Worpel and Hanley>Moore would leave with $239,300 in the kitty.

Thanks for the options fellas. Decisions, decisions!!

You will this !!! ......Moore to go up an estimated $47K this week ....plus leave you with $293K in the kitty