Post BF Upgrade Feedback - Click Here

Remove this Banner Ad

Saddington

  • Thread starter Thread starter berisha
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

berisha

berisha

Club Legend
Veteran
Joined
Mar 22, 2008
Posts
1,978
Reaction score
3,006
Location
Melbourne
AFL Club
Carlton
Other Teams
Burnley, San Jose Sharks
Since I've been on here i've got the vibe that many don't rate him.
Why?
I happen to think he should be getting a game in our defence.
I thought he did alright last year when played.
 
He can't jump to save his life, and his kicking is average. He's not good enough to displace: Waite, Bower, Thornton, Jamison, or even Bannister. He's not quick enough to take the smalls they don't. On the plus side he's experienced and expendable.

Does that cover it?
 
Thornton at times I find him our weakest defender. This season i think he has improved. I would stick Waite forward and put Saddington in.
I think his coverage is good and IMO he reads the play well.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

He's an OK player? Wouldn't mind seeing him have another go. Could he Pinch hit in the forward line? He's a good marking target and could be used as a decoy for fev and fish! :P
 
Blu3_Boy said:
He's a good marking target and could be used as a decoy for fev and fish! :P
Click to expand...
He could be used as a decoy for wood ducks. That's more likely than him being selected as a key marking forward.
 
AlecDuncan said:
He could be used as a decoy for wood ducks. That's more likely than him being selected as a key marking forward.
Click to expand...

HAHAHAHAHA :thumbsu: Good one! hahahaha! Yeh true. Not to sure with Saddo! Alec Duncan what are your thoughts on Saddo? Will he be at Carlton next year?
 
berisha said:
I'd play Saddington over::
Carrazzo, Grigg, Russell, Hartlett, Houlihan
Click to expand...

Big Call Berisha!
1 person I would pick Saddo for NO DOUBT ABOUT IT on that list is Adam Hartlett! I personally don't rate him, harsh but honestly, he is an ABSOLUTE LIABILITY TO THE CARLTON FOOTBALL CLUB!
 
He may get a gig now that Thornton will miss six or so weeks......but he did train with the rehab group last Friday so I don't really know where he is ftiness wise.
Carlos may get a recall ahead of him for thornton...not sure!
 
THEBLOODS85 said:
only hartlett could he possibly replace.....all the other players are totally different types:eek:
Click to expand...
yes sorry i meant that I would rate Saddington higher than the following.
Not in their positions.
Carrazzo though has been playing back pocket, on the line up.

Don't rate Houlihan anymore, too slow and to soft. I agree Saddo is not the quickest but I think he has a lot to offer!
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Blu3_Boy said:
Alec Duncan what are your thoughts on Saddo? Will he be at Carlton next year?
Click to expand...
He'll be very lucky to still be here. Was only saved last year by Big Red's forced retirement.

It all depends on our situation at season's end. We know there will be at least three new faces on the list, so at least three will go. I don't think we'll have any trouble filling that dinghy, and Saddo will be near the front of the queue.

OTOH, never underestimate a bloke in the last year of his contract!
 
AlecDuncan said:
He'll be very lucky to still be here. Was only saved last year by Big Red's forced retirement.

It all depends on our situation at season's end. We know there will be at least three new faces on the list, so at least three will go. I don't think we'll have any trouble filling that dinghy, and Saddo will be near the front of the queue.

OTOH, never underestimate a bloke in the last year of his contract!
Click to expand...

Have to think Ackland, Wiggins, Saddington and Blackwell are most likely.
 
If you beleieve the idea of all teams having a Premiership window or clock you would say Carlton are currently at about 9PM. Our chance for a flag should be at it's peak in about 2011-2012. If that is the case then we cannot waste games on somebody like Saddington, Wiggins, Ackland.
We all know we cannot make the finals this year and make any impact so I can't see why we would use these 3 players as stop gap solutions to long term problems. We need to be giving the young untried players game time to see who is and who isnt up to it.
 
I don't think he's got a spot in our best 22, but he's a handy bloke to have around the club, particularly with the injuries we've got now.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Matt72 said:
Saddington is 28 years old. Bannister is 25 thats the main difference that I see.
Click to expand...
What about the 100 games difference in experience? Saddington can be more than handy when fit but unfortunately couldn't play the youth card or "we're developing him" excuse when our entire defence was getting the shit kicked out of it week-in week-out during Pagan's reign. I think Saddo would do a lot better in todays side.
 
one_twelve112 said:
What about the 100 games difference in experience? Saddington can be more than handy when fit but unfortunately couldn't play the youth card or "we're developing him" excuse when our entire defence was getting the shit kicked out of it week-in week-out during Pagan's reign. I think Saddo would do a lot better in todays side.
Click to expand...

It's not a matter of his quality or his past it is his future.
Lets say that he plays every game for the rest of the year and we win say 6 games 4 of them directly due to his influence. Then at the end of the year when he is 29 the match committee decide to let him go. Are we better off for having him play this year?
I am not bagging him and saying he is shit but he is not the future at Carlton.
 
Matt72 said:
If you beleieve the idea of all teams having a Premiership window or clock you would say Carlton are currently at about 9PM. Our chance for a flag should be at it's peak in about 2011-2012. If that is the case then we cannot waste games on somebody like Saddington, Wiggins, Ackland.
We all know we cannot make the finals this year and make any impact so I can't see why we would use these 3 players as stop gap solutions to long term problems. We need to be giving the young untried players game time to see who is and who isnt up to it.
Click to expand...

I think this is a good post. Maybe some people are right that Saddington would currently be a good option. But let's keep developing new players. It may seem weird, but will probably help us in 3 years time.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom