SC Dilemma

[AD03]

I've fiddled with my team and I have 399,300 left for one more forward!

Theres a few options I'm considering...

Tarrant - $399,100
Akermanis - $395,600
J Westhoff - $394,400
Robert Murphy - $383,800
Yze - $380,200
Daniel Motlop - 365,200
Mitch Hahn - $341,800
Colin Sylvia - $338,300


What do you guys think? Who should I go for? And why? Keep in mind if I take a cheaper player it will leave me a bit left over if I need it later.

 

[The Captain]

I've fiddled with my team and I have 399,300 left for one more forward!

Theres a few options I'm considering...

Tarrant - $399,100
Akermanis - $395,600
J Westhoff - $394,400
Robert Murphy - $383,800
Yze - $380,200
Daniel Motlop - 365,200
Mitch Hahn - $341,800
Colin Sylvia - $338,300


What do you guys think? Who should I go for? And why? Keep in mind if I take a cheaper player it will leave me a bit left over if I need it later.

Take Kurt Tippet at under $100k, and plough the balance into a midfielder.

Who are your other forwards?

 

[simplicity]

really depends on who else you have in your forward line if its consisted of high mid or low range players
but guess if you are looking for a player at that range i would consider porplyzia gunned it in the NAB cup if that counts for anything he's an improving player in the side

 

[IhateMondays]

Tarrant-NO
Akermanis-good preseason but I'm not convinced.
Westhoff- won't improve much after first year. Will be held more accountable.
Murphy-coming back from injury
Yze-over the hill
Motlop-too inconsistent
Hahn-???
Sylvia-won't play round one

 

[IhateMondays]

If I really wanted someone, go for Hughes (rich), Betts (Carl) or Newton (melb)

 

[AD03]

Yeah I've got Tippett.... My other forwards are Fevola, Deledio, Franklin, Cyril Rioli, Alwyn Davey, young Vezspremi, and Robert Murphy.

My forward lines probably the weakest out of all areas so I'd prefer to spend the money on another good forward.

 

[Panthera]

I've fiddled with my team and I have 399,300 left for one more forward!

Theres a few options I'm considering...

Tarrant - $399,100
Akermanis - $395,600
J Westhoff - $394,400
Robert Murphy - $383,800
Yze - $380,200
Daniel Motlop - 365,200
Mitch Hahn - $341,800
Colin Sylvia - $338,300


What do you guys think? Who should I go for? And why? Keep in mind if I take a cheaper player it will leave me a bit left over if I need it later.

Aker will be valued @ 500k before Rd. 10, Get on him

 

[bailz66]

I wouldn't go near Aker really inconsistent.

Looking at your forward line you don't really have any guns in there yet?

i would try and free up some more cash somewhere else and spend up on your last forward.

Either that or get someone like Thompson and upgrade Fev or Delideo

 

[AD03]

I wouldn't go near Aker really inconsistent.

Looking at your forward line you don't really have any guns in there yet?

i would try and free up some more cash somewhere else and spend up on your last forward.

Either that or get someone like Thompson and upgrade Fev or Delideo

Haha are you serious? Fev isn't a gun? Franklin isn't a gun? Deledio isn't a gun? :S :S :S

 

[DockerNJL]

Haha are you serious? Fev isn't a gun? Franklin isn't a gun? Deledio isn't a gun? :S :S :S

Probly only Fev will score consitent points there,
There is no Pav, Brown, Johnson or chapmen there wich is a concern for me.

 

[DockerNJL]

what about Didak at $370k ?

 

[Spartan]

Haha are you serious? Fev isn't a gun? Franklin isn't a gun? Deledio isn't a gun? :S :S :S

Correct.
Correct.
Correct.

 

[AD03]

Okay hows this sound to everyone?

Paul Chapman
Fevola
Deledio
Franklin
Nathan Krakouer
Cyril Rioli
Tippett
Ben Reid (Emerg)
Vezpremi (Emerg)

Thoughts?

 

[Spartan]

Okay hows this sound to everyone?

Paul Chapman
Fevola
Deledio
Franklin
Nathan Krakouer
Cyril Rioli
Tippett
Ben Reid (Emerg)
Vezpremi (Emerg)

Thoughts?

Lose Delidio and Franklin. Pick up Riewoldt and Porpliza or S.Johnson and C.Jones (if you can afford it).

Also I'd probably drop Chappy for Pavlich.

Vezpremi wont get a game.

Nathan Krakouer?

 

[AD03]

So I have three options

Option A. Deledio and Franklin

B. Pavlich/Riewoldt and Porpliza

C. Steve Johnson and Alwyn Davey (Don't have enough for Jones)

 

[Yoda_]

I have a dilemma aswel. was just wondering if you could help with my emergencies any one. I currently have on my interchange:

BACKS
S.Selwood (W.C) *
Pfeiffer (Carl)

MIDFIELD
Myers (Ess)
Ebert (W.C) *

RUCKS
Leunberger (Bris)
Kruezer (Carl)

FORWRDS
Tippet (Adel)
Rioli (Haw) *

* = Emergency

I still have $28,600 left, are their any players that you think i should look at to replce with. am not entirely happy with my benches.

 

[swansfan51]

I have a dilemma aswel. was just wondering if you could help with my emergencies any one. I currently have on my interchange:

BACKS
S.Selwood (W.C) *
Pfeiffer (Carl)

MIDFIELD
Myers (Ess)
Ebert (W.C) *

RUCKS
Leunberger (Bris)
Kruezer (Carl)

FORWRDS
Tippet (Adel)
Rioli (Haw) *

* = Emergency

I still have $28,600 left, are their any players that you think i should look at to replce with. am not entirely happy with my benches.

If your goal is to have the bench players that 90% of people who post their team on BigFooty do, then your team is absolutely fine as it is . You don't need to change it unless you actually want to think independently or try someone that hasn't been mentioned on here. For the record, I wouldn't pick Myers or Ebert to start the season.