Seaby

[jack_riewoldt_rulz]

Should we trade pick 19 for seaby ?

 

[Ancient Tiger]

No. His performance in the final the other night shows what an inferior ruckman he is compared to Cox. We should be developing youngsters to be better than what Seaby has plateaued at.

 

[peterss]

Good luck trying to get him in a trade....Considering he re-signed a new contract last week

 

[jack_riewoldt_rulz]

Good luck trying to get him in a trade....Considering he re-signed a new contract last week

oh crap did he, my bad

 

[Rodney Dangerfield]

Thank god for that.Rubbish player.

 

[4th Button Boy]

yuk! yuk! yuk!

getting seaby would just be going back to the mistakes we use to make in picking up recycled s#$! players! no way...

 

[jko'neal]

I remember he talked to our guys last time Richmond was in Perth, so it was reported in the West.Glad it went no further. Very suprised WC rushed in to sign him up again and not have a look elsewhere.

 

[kainokaino]

There has been to much talk on here recently of trading off our draft picks,
it was only a few weeks ago when we were all saying that we MUST continue following the path were taking and draft more youngsters to develop with our own boys.

I think it would be stupid to start throwing around draft picks this year for blokes like seaby and mcguire ....
If we can get someone like them in the PSD then fair enough,
but there is no way i would trade high picks for these players.

We have our own spine developing and i dont think we need to bring players from other clubs into it,
our backline is finally starting to take some shape about it with the likes of thursty mcguane and polak.
And down foward we still have richo for imo adleast two more years ...
and then theres schulz who we can continue to use for the next couple of years until riewoldt and hughes are up and ready and playing consistent football.

PLEASE RICHMOND FC DONT TRADE AWAY OUR DRAFT PICKS.

 

[Cosmo Kramer]

Seaby wont be going anywhere, but definatley on your radar should be david hale(huge upside, not sure you would have to give up too much either). Also there is a fair chance some rucks will be available at pick 1 in the PSD.

 

[Don Logan]

Thank god for that.Rubbish player.

Funny you should say that 'cause Mark is a committed Christian and has prayer readings after matches.

 

[lids2004roar]

Why trade for Seaby when we have Carl Peterson who has proven to be a much better ruckman already?

Peterson beat Seaby 4 of 5 times in the WAFL last year, and he is 182cm

 

[Trump]

Why trade for Seaby when we have Carl Peterson who has proven to be a much better ruckman already?

Peterson beat Seaby 4 of 5 times in the WAFL last year, and he is 182cm

No he didnt. 4 out of 5 times, where are you getting your info from.

 

[JSFish]

We've already got 2 young ruckmen + simmo. If patto and/or graham turn out duds then maybe we should start talking about getting another one.

 

[Weaver]

Seaby signed a new contract last month - not elligable to be traded.

 

[Chris who]

Eagles only have spaanderman in reserve and he struggles at WAFL Seaby is as good as youll get second ruckman... not mobile but hes the only eagle to take pack marks in the 50. WHY WOULD WE TRADE?

 

[Rodney Dangerfield]

Eagles only have spaanderman in reserve and he struggles at WAFL Seaby is as good as youll get second ruckman... not mobile but hes the only eagle to take pack marks in the 50. WHY WOULD WE TRADE?

It's ok.We don't want him.