Selection Hypothetical RE: Prismall

[madcat001]

If Prismall didn't do his knee last week, and you would think Kelly would then have been selected as the best replacement for Chapman, would Prismall be the unlucky one to be dropped for the Grand Final assuming he had a regular game tonight similar to Kelly's. If he was dropped for the big one, do you expect he'd be at KP in 2009?

 

[fugsy]

We have enough selection headaches as it is without bringing hypotheticals into it.

 

[madcat001]

That's what made me think about, imagining if Prismall hadn't have gone down, now the selectors would have both Chapman and Wojcinski pressing for a spot. Although, i think it's fair to say that had Wojcinski not played tonight it would have made it hard for him to break into the side next week after missing so much footy and overall the side having a very good game tonight.

 

[The rabbi]

Well I think that it pretty much guarantees that The Prizz will be at K-Park in 2008.

 

[jim boy]

why not chuck egan into the mix as well, or Gary Ablett Snr for that matter.

 

[polly63]

Kelly has never been a fringe player, is clearly one of our best tacklers. My guess is that Prismall and Kelly (& Wojcinski) would have been picked against Dogs and Varcoe would not.

 

[AM]

Well I think that it pretty much guarantees that The Prizz will be at K-Park in 2008.

More concerned about 2009 +

 

[year of the cat]

why not chuck egan into the mix as well, or Gary Ablett Snr for that matter.

No selection headeache with snr. Chuck him in a forward pocket at 50 years of age (or whatever he is) - drop Lonergan