Shane Tuck

[Optimax]

Paul Medhurst couldn't get a game at Freo.

Freo were top 4 with their forwardline functioning wonderfully after medhurst got injured

No need to re-write history to make a case, Tuck is a spud medhurst always had talent

 

[Deledio2Conca]

yet nathan brown also delisted by richmond said he had, when asked on the footy show

Incorrect.

Lyon said to Browny that Tuck was delisted before asking him a question, and Browny basically said "yeah they are going with youth yada yada yada". Browny just didn't pick up Lyon on his mistake.

Fact of the matter is that Tuck still has one year to run and hasn't been/won't be delisted.

 

[deledio7]

Those saying Tuck wasn't good enough for Richmond are kidding themselves. Everyone was shocked when he was dropped and couldn't understand why he struggled to get back in the side. If he played the season out he would of finished 2nd or 3rd in our best and fairest and is still in our top 5 or 6 players. I know that doesn't mean much to the Pies as you's are a stronger outfit, but he would be in your best 25 no doubt.

He has always been hugely underrated and it's been confirmed even more by most supporters refusal to consider him. I think Tuck could be very useful for the Pies in 2010 as he is one of the best in contested disposals and clearances in the AFL.

Everyone has to forget about him getting dropped because it was a farce and it should hold no weight in him being picked up for 2010. I hope the tiges hold onto him but if he is to leave there is no doubt a club should pick him up.

 

[HFF]

Paul Medhurst couldn't get a game at Freo.

Medhurst was always talented but perhaps lazy and not used correctly under the guidance of Connolly.

Since coming across to us he has become an AA footballer and genuine match-winner.

Cannot compare Medhurst to Tuck.

Medders is miles ahead in terms of ability and football nous.