Substitution question

[MrNatural]

I currently have a dilemma with my backline
Heath Shaw is in my backline, but due to his suspension i need to do something.
I was tempted to trade him. But i wanna keep trades in hand
So i have decided to send him to the bench

I have S.Hill and Suban as subs.
But i am unsure which one to go with. So i thought, what happens if i leave Shaw in the side, but select both Suban and Hill as EMGs...

Which score of the 2 players will count? will it be the player with the highest score who subs for Shaw?


Is this correct?

 

[joe30]

no according to supercoach rules the lowest will

 

[MrNatural]

Dammit i thought that id found a loophole lol

Who do you people think i should go with?
Or should i just trade Shaw?

 

[ohhhh wonaeamirri]

no according to supercoach rules the lowest will

lowest scorer unfortunately, i wanted to do this last year in the forward line with rioli and matt campbell and found out the hard way

 

[duckboy]

In the first season or two of SC you could do that. They changed it last year or the year before from memory.

 

[L_J_T]

Get rid of him, he can't seem to handle the tag and he will only lose money, go for someone like Rance for the money before he rises.

 

[MrNatural]

Rance would be ok, but i need someone who will be reliable to score 100+ most games
I can afford a player like Lindsay Gilbee
Which seems like a safe option

I think i might hold back on the trade till next week and see if Shaw will play after his suspension

 

[FBDonkey]

Definitely dont trade Shaw. He is only out for 1 week so it is a waste of trade.

 

[J6shSC]

Definitely trade Shaw because he's no good, haha.

 

[Judd_Magic]

Definitely trade Shaw because he's no good, haha.

I didn't even give Shaw a second thought this year when creating my team after the crap he served up half way through last year when I drafted him in.

 

[Captain Fantasy]

Place Suban on the ground if you'd like to keep Heater, Trade him to Gilbert if you don't mind burning a trade.

 

[FBDonkey]

Definitely trade Shaw because he's no good, haha.

agree: dont pick shaw to begin with. disagree: if you have him, keep him.

 

[d4vE]

shaw for hodge or goddard - thats what im doing this week.