Super Coach Dilemma

[occy437]

Hey guys need you to help me out here i have $20 riding on this:

My Team Vs Opponents Team

Backs
J.Sinclair H.Shaw
G.Polak G.Birchall
D.Wirrapunda J.Smith
T.Croad C.Cornes

Midfield
Dal Santo S.Mitchell
K.Cornes B.Kirk
N.Malceski D.Swan
J.Bartel L.Hodge -Draw

Fowards
C.Cornes Q.Lynch
J.Brown N.Riewoldt
L.Franklin B.Johnson
T.Cloke M.Lloyd

Rucks
Luenberger/Darcy/Jamar Lade

I have bolded the player who i think will win their position against the opponent of similar scoring power

Other than this we have the same team

I have one trade left get rid of Bartel for Hodge or Goodes. What you guys think??

Also who should i play of Luenberger/Darcy/Jamar.????


Thoughts/Opinions

I can get anyone for Bartel.

 

[blueboy13]

I will go for Goodes has been fantastic second half of the year. Hodge might have a tighter tag against Sydney

And I will probably play Darcy it is his last game they might kick it to him a few more times the doggies have nothing to play for. They might as well send Darcy off on a high

 

[sane]

I think a lot of those match ups could go either way.. it'll come down to luck on the day!
I'd play Darcy and get Goodes, has been on fire lately!
Best of luck

 

[BuffDaddy]

whoa $20 dollars

 

[Star]

whoa $20 dollars

ease up, its a lot of money for some...

 

[occy437]

so the general concensus is to get Goodsesy...it could make or break me. i was thinking of getting hodge to nullify his potential to score and counteract one of my opponents GUNS.

 

[Hawkmad]

so the general concensus is to get Goodsesy...it could make or break me. i was thinking of getting hodge to nullify his potential to score and counteract one of my opponents GUNS.

It's okay if it works I tried that 1st week of the finals & got bartel as my oppenant had him & as captain worked ok as he got (350 odd).which nutralized that score. But it won't work & is a waste of a trade if that player doesn't get a good score.

What if the following happened:
You get Hodge to nutralize his score & only gets 80 odd (waste of a trade) OR
You get Goodes he scores 150 & Hodge gets only 80 odd (Winner)

With your ruck question I am just leaning towards Luenberger over Darcy not sure why just a gut feeling

These are only my thoughts & at the end of the day it your decision
Best of luck