Recommitted Sydney Stack [has re-signed with Richmond]

[Demon in Hell]

Jesus Christ, Walsh is $1.40 fav at Sportsbet.

Stack is on the second line at $6.00

That’s not even close.

 

[The Nostradamus]

Stack next year will be on more than any drafteee

Perks of his 1 year initial deal has worked out amazingly for him

 

[Morro]

Jesus Christ, Walsh is $1.40 fav at Sportsbet.

Stack is on the second line at $6.00

That’s not even close.

I agree Walsh deserves the RS, he is the complete midfielder and killing it every week.

I reckon a massive amount of neutrals would take Stack over Walsh if based on talent alone and dismissing potential off field issues.

 

[The Nostradamus]

I want him just cos I think we are already stacked with mongrel. Pardon the pun

But would love to add more

 

[juss]

Walsh will rightly win the RS, been amazing and ultra consistent for a first year player. However when you consider where they came from, Stack has far greater upside.

Walsh has always been the best he's ever been, there's not much he can do better off field to improve, hes been the top rated junior for a couple of years, already had elite endurance and professionalism. Stack has a hell of a lot more areas he can improve and mature in and if that correlates with onfield improvement then he will very quickly close any gaps in the performances.

 

[Espio]

Walsh will rightly win the RS, been amazing and ultra consistent for a first year player. However when you consider where they came from, Stack has far greater upside.

Walsh has always been the best he's ever been, there's not much he can do better off field to improve, hes been the top rated junior for a couple of years, already had elite endurance and professionalism. Stack has a hell of a lot more areas he can improve and mature in and if that correlates with onfield improvement then he will very quickly close any gaps in the performances.

Super professional so therefore less likely to improve? Seriously, I have heard it all now.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[juss]

Super professional so therefore less likely to improve? Seriously, I have heard it all now.


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

No just poor comprehension of the point on your half.

 

[THE_GUN]

15 possessions
5 marks
4 tackles
4 goal

This kid is such a natural and will be a brilliant player for many years to come, No Doubt should have been a top 5 selection
Tigers have a beauty here

 

[Trucker Tiger]

Jesus Christ, Walsh is $1.40 fav at Sportsbet.

Stack is on the second line at $6.00

That’s not even close.

Walsh is 1.36.

Stack is 3.75.

Walsh will win partly because one of the judges (Richo) has indicated that he couldn't put Stack on top because of the perception of bias.

 

[The Chad and I]

Sorry folks, I haven't been following this.
Why wasn't he taken earlier?

 

[THE_GUN]

Sorry folks, I haven't been following this.
Why wasn't he taken earlier?

Recommitted - Sydney Stack [has re-signed with Richmond]

On a 1 year rookie deal out of contract at years end. Will command a pay rise Do tigers have space? Every week his value goes up

www.bigfooty.com

 

[M Malice]

This bloke looks like he has the potential to be an elite player in the competition, it all comes down to whether he wants it enough, certainly has the raw talent.

 

[branedotorg]

players really come into afl ready to play these days, no more two-three years apprenticeships in the vfl

 

[ManOfClay]

I reckon a massive amount of neutrals would take Stack over Walsh if based on talent alone and dismissing potential off field issues.

I agree with this and just believe Stack will impact games much more. In fact I think he and Miers are a good 1-2 bet for the rising star on the basis of overall impact on the game.

Walsh is swell though and I think he’s great, I’m certainly not being negative about him

 

[ManOfClay]

Stack isnt far off Walsh with the bookies for the rising star. Walsh is sold but a bit vanilla, Stack has shown signs he can be anything down the track. A unique mixture of attributes

There are millions of Tigers fans btw

Walsh projects to be a bit of a macrae type if he can maintain his consistency. Which would be great for Carlton tbh. Yes he will never have the hurt factor of others who reach an elite level but every team would have a spot for that type of player.

Give me Stack any day with the Walsh types already on our list

 

[HavUEvaSeenTheRain]

Walsh will rightly win the RS, been amazing and ultra consistent for a first year player. However when you consider where they came from, Stack has far greater upside.

Walsh has always been the best he's ever been, there's not much he can do better off field to improve, hes been the top rated junior for a couple of years, already had elite endurance and professionalism. Stack has a hell of a lot more areas he can improve and mature in and if that correlates with onfield improvement then he will very quickly close any gaps in the performances.

The players who have the highest ceilings in last years group would be JL and King.

 

[juss]

The players who have the highest ceilings in last years group would be JL and King.

Yeh maybe. I just think Stack is a pure raw talent that has never had the professionalism in his game or his upbringing. That's easier to change than it is for someone else to develop football related shortcomings (which Stack can still improve upon too).
On raw talent and football ability, he's top 5 easily.

 

[HurleyHepsHird]

He stays.

Will constantly be mad at WC for not drafting him.

 

[Herne Hill Hammer]

More that as long as he doesn't have enough money to support people in need from back home, moving them over and bringing poor habits with them that he slips into.

You can 't say that. I basically said the same sort of thing on the Geelong board about Kelly staying at Geelong rather than going back to WA and got absolutely smashed for it.

 

[Herne Hill Hammer]

Sorry folks, I haven't been following this.
Why wasn't he taken earlier?

Apparently the Eagles were going to take him with their next pick.

 

[Taylor]

You can 't say that. I basically said the same sort of thing on the Geelong board about Kelly staying at Geelong rather than going back to WA and got absolutely smashed for it.

Just so you know, the cats can include a full time pair of nannys to help Caitlin at home with the three kids from next season.

 

[David C]

Walsh is 1.36.

Stack is 3.75.

Walsh will win partly because one of the judges (Richo) has indicated that he couldn't put Stack on top because of the perception of bias.

That's like one vote mate?

 

[ARES]

According to AFL rankings, Stack is rated number one for first year players, comfortably ahead

He has been a revelation on and off the field

 

[Stevi_Tigers]

Think he will stay and if for some reason he wants out then a side will have to pay up

 

[captain cotch 9]

He stays.

Will constantly be mad at WC for not drafting him.

Sumich has said he needed to get out of WA to make it.