Sydney Swans v Carlton, Rd 14, 2013

[The King!]

Jesus Christ you lot are sheep. It was a good game well umpired. Stop whining

Apart from stiring a blues flog i could care less about the umpiring

 

[QuietB]

Rubbish.
Judd was better than Kennedy, Hannebery and Jack and some of his touches were quite important in a wet game.
Take your blinkers off.

Compared to O'Keefe though. All I saw all night was Judd fumbling. Judd was clearly beaten by O'Keefe. If you are getting tagged, and your tagger has it half a dozen more times than you and uses it better you have been soundly beaten.

 

[Ghostwriter]

Games like tonight are why I miss Tippo so much. Such a ferocious competitor in the wet, and has some of the best hands in the comp.

A mistake to trade him?

 

[DapperDon]

But if you play on, towards the field, you're still OOB but deemed not to be

Maybe they give them some leeway, but if they continued to run around the boundary they'd be called for it. It's a fair point though, he is deemed in play when he takes the kick so probably should be called OTF but i'm 90% sure the rule they paid is correct.

Though, I have been wrong many times in my life before

 

[The King!]

Games like tonight are why I miss Tippo so much. Such a ferocious competitor in the wet, and has some of the best hands in the comp.

Yeah he looked like it was dry weather when he got it.

 

[Dangas]

On a dry day even those are let go depending who it is, on a wet night play on every time, Rosebury is a hack.

On a dry day deliberate rushed behinds are usually never paid...

 

[The King!]

Respect for this post.

Hes one of the better big footy posters

 

[mxett]

What was the crowd tonight?

 

[swan14]

Tip Tip so clean in the wet. I will Fap to the replay later.

 

[The King!]

What was the crowd tonight?

Wet

 

[Andrew Mc]

Craig Bird BOG I reckon, best game of his career. Gibbs proving his doubters wrong yet again with a magnificent game in the wet.

Agree with both of those. Parker was good too.

 

[mxett]

Wet

How many wet people?

 

[Ron]

30 behinds (combined). Most this season?

Wouldn't be close i don't reckon.

If i remember we had 32 or 33 last week in the Tigers and Dogs game. Surely there would be more than that in a game though.

 

[The King!]

How many wet people?

Well when tippett was on fire who knows

But 25349 apparently

 

[vonn]

How many wet people?

Depends how many sat under cover.
Edit: seriously, about 25,800

 

[Kickin_Goals]

Tippett might be a bit slow didn't seem to notice it rained...
Is there a more poached from side going about then Adelaide?

 

[The Dog]

Two soft frees in a row inside Sydney's 50 to ruin what could have been an interesting finish.

Exactly, on a night like tonight it was just unnessecary. What did we get, 1-2 frees for the entire half then 2 shots on goal dubious to ice the game.

 

[Percel]

What was the crowd tonight?

Swans mostly, enjoyed the weather

 

[vonn]

​

Exactly, on a night like tonight it was just unnessecary. What did we get, 1-2 frees for the entire half then 2 shots on goal dubious to ice the game.

Game was essentially iced when Carlton failed to kick a legitimate goal in the first half.

 

[The Jet]

Sigh

I guess not then.

So Carlton again had a chance to win but failed. ALMOST took at the end but didn't. Blues = An Almost team. Almost making the finals. Always 2014 I guess.

 

[The Dog]

That is the one thing you can point to that has been poor about their recruiting. you simply can't carry that number of stupid players in one team.
As to that incorrect disposal call against Henderson, I like it. He was actually directing the ball toward his player as it came free. There was intention. I believe all incorrect disposal should be paid but at least this was adjudicated correctly to the letter of the rule as it stands.

Ok. How many others lie that went unpaid tonight though?

 

[Andrew Mc]

Exactly, on a night like tonight it was just unnessecary. What did we get, 1-2 frees for the entire half then 2 shots on goal dubious to ice the game.

They'd been paying the McGlynn one all night. That shouldn't change because it's late in the game and tight.

 

[Blueboys11]

They'd been paying the McGlynn one all night. That shouldn't change because it's late in the game and tight.

Say what??

 

[The Dog]

​

Game was essentially iced when Carlton failed to kick a legitimate goal in the first half.

Yeah, and Sydney got 1 of 4 'legitimate' goals in the 2nd half.

 

[Andrew Mc]

Say what??

Anyone on their feet, taking the player on, was paid pretty consistently all night if they were caught. Heck, I even commented on it on about page 4 or 5 of this thread.

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/sydney-swans-v-carlton-rd-14-2013.1015449/page-5#post-28897424