Sylvia deserving nomination?

[Zeke]

Colin 'Zzzzz' Sylvia has done nothing for the past season and a half, but then pops up with 20 cheap possessions and snares a nomination.

Deserving or not?

 

[ManWithNoName]

20 odd posessions will get you a nomination. Travis Cloke looks the goods, he'll get a nomination this season.

 

[Blues_Man]

of those 20 posessions 8 were handballs back and forth as he ran around in circles and ten of them were turnovers

 

[Nightwolf]

Cloke wont get one this week, Croad will towell him up...

 

[Slander]

of those 20 posessions 8 were handballs back and forth as he ran around in circles and ten of them were turnovers

Not bad, could be the next Nick Stevens.

 

[ManWithNoName]

of those 20 posessions 8 were handballs back and forth as he ran around in circles and ten of them were turnovers

Wowoedin won a brownlow by doing that.

 

[Swifty_446]

Whinging Collingwood supporters......is there no respite?

What difference does it make? If Cloke gets nominated this week, will he play better next week? I don't think so.

Oh, sorry, I just had a thought, rising star nominations are the only thing Collingwood has a chance of winning this year, so that's why you're so upset.

 

[celtic_pride]

God Zeke, Slyvia is a better midfield prospect than any of the young bums you have down at Collingwood.

 

[Zeke]

God Zeke, Slyvia is a better midfield prospect than any of the young bums you have down at Collingwood.

Even Julian Rowe who has outperformed Sylvia, to date?

 

[rick James]

Zeke.

Let me spell it out for you.

Colin Sylvia is the NAB rising Star nominee for Round 9.

clear?

 

[Zeke]

Zeke.

Let me spell it out for you.

Colin Sylvia is the NAB rising Star nominee for Round 9.

clear?

Yeah, I heard.

Shocking decision, don't you agree?

 

[rick James]

Yeah, I heard.

Shocking decision, don't you agree?

Nah i don't. He's played too good games in a row, one in which he got 15 possies and two goals in 50 minutes of footy. Definitely showed he deserves the nomination.

Not that it matters, Brock McLean will be taking the award this year.

Hey, isn't it awesome, you guys are bottom of the ladder and can't even get one player to get a nomination, yet Melbourne are top 4 and will have 3 nominations by year end, and the actual winner of the award too? Maybe a premiership as well!

Isn't that cool?

 

[Zeke]

Nah i don't. He's played too good games in a row, one in which he got 15 possies and two goals in 50 minutes of footy.

Stop the press, the messiah has arrived.

Not that it matters, Brock McLean will be taking the award this year.

You lot are quite partial to counting your chickens before the eggs have hatched, aren't you.

Maybe a premiership as well!

Now you're just being silly.

Travis Cloke > Colin Sylvia

 

[Nightwolf]

One Handball Boy is alot better now, was terrible in his first handfull of matches.

Hes passed Walker easily now....

 

[rick James]

One Handball Boy is alot better now, was terrible in his first handfull of matches.

Hes passed Walker easily now....

Are you being serious? I mean, I agree, but it shows a level of maturity I rarely see here for an opposition supporter to admit Sylvia has been showing a bit.

 

[Nightwolf]

Are you being serious? I mean, I agree, but it shows a level of maturity I rarely see here for an opposition supporter to admit Sylvia has been showing a bit.

Yeh im serious, the Hawthorn game showed he could play, even made a thread...

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=170431

But he'll always be one handball boy to me

 

[AllStar7]

Anyone who says Sylvia didn't deserve a nomination this week, suffers from one of the following conditions:

Either they are too affaird to admit they were wrong about him
Or they are Collingwood supporters

The second condition often contains symptoms of the first. Just get over it, I don't remember too many kids who got a nomination and didn't deserve it. He played two good games, has previously had very little ground time, and is playing in a top 4 team. People who keep bringing up the fact that its his second year, neglect to mention that he struggled with OP last year and could hardly run a full game in the VFL.

He probably won't win it, neither will Cloke. Both will get nominated, both will be good players. Move on!

 

[Pie 4 Life]

He deserved it but Cloke deserved it more.

 

[dacame]

He deserves it he is awesome. Cloke isnt good he is ********

 

[Marns]

Colin 'Zzzzz' Sylvia has done nothing for the past season and a half, but then pops up with 20 cheap possessions and snares a nomination.

Deserving or not?

Are you stupid or just ignorant? Sylvia had OP, which means he doesnt have much of a choice whether he plays or not. He has now overcome the injury and is finding his feet.