List Mgmt. The Chopping Block

[Frank Gallagher]

Who's leading the race to be delisted come seasons end? Here's my selections.

Sier (simply has to go unless he shows something in the remaining weeks)

Oxley (gone unless contracted)


Sinclair

And Grundy and Moore.

Who else might find themselves in trouble?

 

[MagpieBat]

Who's leading the race to be delisted come seasons end? Here's my selections.

Sier (simply has to go unless he shows something in the remaining weeks)

Oxley (gone unless contracted)


Sinclair

Who else might find themselves in trouble?

He is.

 

[Howezat]

Not Sinclair under any circumstances unless he retires due to concussion or injury. He is literally the only speed we have out of defence.

Blair
Oxley
White
Schade
Mackie *

At this stage.

 

[Frank Gallagher]

Not Sinclair under any circumstances unless he retires due to concussion or injury. He is literally the only speed we have out of defence.

White
Oxley
Blair
Schade
Mackie *

At this stage.

Mackies a rookie.

 

[Frank Gallagher]

He is.

Fair dinkum, who's bloody running the show down there.

 

[Howezat]

Mackies a rookie.

Yeah I put an asterix there but these days it's the same thing, there's always an injury or upgrade opportunity, we built a premiership on them once.

 

[Frank Gallagher]

Pretty sure White has another year, not 100% though, but even if he hasn't i think he's worth keeping around.

I think we have to make the call on Cox this year, as in senior list or delist, so he'll be on the senior list next year IMO.

 

[pablo disco bar]

Oxley gone regardless of contract
White should stay imo but he wont
Keefe gone
Thomas may head home
Blair gone
Reid will leave
Mackie gone
Schade hopefully gone
Fasolo will ask for trade

 

[whiskeytown]

Blair
Keeffe or White
Oxley (trade out for 4th round or later)
Mackie
Sier (rookie list)
Sinclair (retirement)
Thomas

And Bucks....

 

[Frank Gallagher]

Oxley gone regardless of contract
White should stay imo but he wont
Keefe gone
Thomas may head home
Blair gone
Reid will leave
Mackie gone
Schade hopefully gone
Fasolo will ask for trade

Might have to start calling you Uncle Chop Chop

 

[pablo disco bar]

Might have to start calling you Uncle Chop Chop

Haah also agree with whiskeytown sinclair gone.....snip snip mutha far.....kers

 

[Bad Horse]

White
Blair
Sier to the rookie list
Sinclair

Will probably lose at least one of if not all of regardless if we want to

De Goey
Scharenberg
Fasolo
Goldsack
Cox

Who we should get rid of instead but cant and that's an indictment on our incompetence

Wells
Oxley
Mayne

 

[legendstatus]

Cool thread


On iPhone using BigFooty.com mobile app

 

[Saintly Viewed]

White
Blair
Sier to the rookie list
Sinclair

Will probably lose at least one of if not all of regardless if we want to

De Goey
Scharenberg
Fasolo
Goldsack
Cox

Who we should get rid of instead but cant and that's an indictment on our incompetence

Wells
Oxley
Mayne

Get rid of Wells?

Really? Pure skill.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Delisting:

Blair
White
Schade (to be re-rookies.)
Mackie (maybe be re-rookied)

The rest will depend on what's traded or not.

Oxley as contracted is the lucky player standing.

 

[Go Woods]

Delist
Blair
Oxley
Sier
Trade Bait
Mayne

 

[Bad Horse]

Get rid of Wells?

Really? Pure skill.

Pure broken down body. Will not play more than 10 games a season.

 

[Kappa]

If Blair stays in the VFL the rest of the year then the obvious changes are

Oxley
Sier
Blair

Maybe Mackie and Schade depending on how many spots we need opened.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Pure broken down body. Will not play more than 10 games a season.

And if he does just 10 games a season it's a WIN for us.

People can knock everyone except Pendlebury and Wells.
On wells I draw the line.

He came for free, we just pay him a salary.

He is sublime.
He's elite level talent.
Best 10 talent on list, best 5 if fully healthy for most of season.

Plays five games a year those 5 games were a far better team.

Sorry on Wells, worth every risk we took.
On that kudos for getting him.

IF you're board watch highlights of him play.
I always marvelled at him when watching North games.

Plus no doubt he and Varcoe are helping and aspiring Kirby. Yet another bonus of him.

(ok, serious man love for him.)
(On wells I can not be swayed, sublime talent)

 

[Frank Gallagher]

And if he does just 10 games a season it's a WIN for us.

People can knock everyone except Pendlebury and Wells.
On wells I draw the line.

He came for free, we just pay him a salary.

He is sublime.
He's elite level talent.
Best 10 talent on list, best 5 if fully healthy for most of season.

Plays five games a year those 5 games were a far better team.

Sorry on Wells, worth every risk we took.
On that kudos for getting him.

IF you're board watch highlights of him play.
I always marvelled at him when watching North games.

Plus no doubt he and Varcoe are helping and aspiring Kirby. Yet another bonus of him.

(ok, serious man love for him.)
(On wells I can not be swayed, sublime talent)

Wells was a dumb move IMO, if we'd played finals last year and looked like contending i would've been all for it, but fact is we weren't contending and how the powers that be thought we were considering our pathetic forward line and bland defense is mindboggling.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

Wells was a dumb move IMO, if we'd played finals last year and looked like contending i would've been all for it, but fact is we weren't contending and how the powers that be thought we were considering our pathetic forward line and bland defense ] If wells is not a good move for his talent levels and mentoring of Kirby then the discussion must end I'm afraid as unsure anymore can be added

 

[Frank Gallagher]

?

 

[Saintly Viewed]

?

If people don't agree with Wells and see the value then I just won't be able to convince them.
He cost nothing as free agent.

To me he's a sublime talent and worth the risk whether we're top or bottom.
Too good to refuse.

 

[Frank Gallagher]

If people don't agree with Wells and see the value then I just won't be able to convince them.
He cost nothing as free agent.

To me he's a sublime talent and worth the risk whether we're top or bottom.
Too good to refuse.

He cost plenty mate, 3 years on good coin hurts our cap, could mean the difference between landing a gun FA and not.

 

[Saintly Viewed]

He cost plenty mate, 3 years on good coin hurts our cap, could mean the difference between landing a gun FA and not.

Then it's not so clever, still I'd take him. We could always dump Mayne errrr wait a minute ooops no we can't