Remove this Banner Ad

Club History The Ollie Wines Society for young stars who break out against Melbourne

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

In the lead-up to the 2012 draft, Melbourne were broadly expected to take Ollie Wines with their first pick. One of the highest-rated players in the draft, he was also best friends with Melbourne's highly fancied father-son recruit that year, Jack Viney.

Draft night came, and Melbourne surprisingly decided to take Jimmy Toumpas with their first selection. Ollie Wines would later be picked by Port Adelaide with their first-round pick.

As it happened, Melbourne would face off against Port Adelaide in the first round of 2013. Unfortunately, Port Adelaide went on to win the game by 79 points, with Ollie Wines collecting 24 disposals, 16 contested posessions, seven marks (two contested), three tackles, and a goal. He went on to be nominated for the Rising Star award for his performance.

Toumpas, on the other hand, managed just nine disposals, three marks, two tackles, and a behind. He would later be traded to Port Adelaide for their third-round pick at the end of 2015.



In 2014, Melbourne brought in legendary coach Paul Roos to turn their fortunes around. Despite some improvement in their performances, wins were still scant for Melbourne that season. In Round 15, they faced another rebuilding team, the Western Bulldogs, at Etihad Stadium.

Tightly contested all afternoon, Melbourne very nearly found themselves in a winning position—until a young man in his first season managed to kick a spectacular goal to win the game for the Bulldogs. The goal was so celebrated that it later went on to win that season’s Goal of the Year award. The man in question was Marcus Bontempelli.



In early 2024, Melbourne still believed they were in premiership contention. They had made a reasonable start to the season and sat fourth on the ladder going into a game against the struggling West Coast Eagles.

That is, until they ran into the previous draft’s number one pick—Harley Reid. Reid played the most exciting game of his short career, kicking two goals and making Melbourne's highly vaunted midfield look silly. One of his goals also went on to win that season’s Goal of the Year award:

 
Last edited:
Note: 'Young Star' will follow the Rising Star rule. The player must be under 21 at the time of their performance.

Unforturnately, this means that despite Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera's heroic performance a few weeks ago, at 22 that performance is disqualified.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Note: 'Young Star' will follow the Rising Star rule. The player must be under 21 at the time of their performance.

Unforturnately, this means that despite Nasiah Wanganeen-Milera's heroic performance a few weeks ago, at 22 that performance is disqualified.
Don’t worry Legs. Nas can have his own thread - The NWM get rich quick scheme for players who ruin Melbourne thread has a good ring to it.
 
This has the trappings of an all Australian type thread where we put together the best 22 from all these type of threads.

KK spuds, Boomer grandpas, Dean Kent perennially injured and any other could see us put together quite the team.

Any other of these type of threads I've missed?
 
This has the trappings of an all Australian type thread where we put together the best 22 from all these type of threads.

KK spuds, Boomer grandpas, Dean Kent perennially injured and any other could see us put together quite the team.

Any other of these type of threads I've missed?
Melbourne board draft of players who get nominated in 'who play well against melbourne' threads.
 
Last edited:
Melbourne board draft of players who get nominated in 'who play well against melbourne' thread.
We are going to be putting together another draft comp soon so it may be a chance.
 
Does a player qualify if they broke out against us, then broke back in immediately after?

e.g. Round 1, 2012 Rising Star nominee Claye Beams, who then proceeded to do sod all.
 
Does a player qualify if they broke out against us, then broke back in immediately after?

e.g. Round 1, 2012 Rising Star nominee Claye Beams, who then proceeded to do sod all.
The rare Wines/Kingsley combo.
 
Does a player qualify if they broke out against us, then broke back in immediately after?

e.g. Round 1, 2012 Rising Star nominee Claye Beams, who then proceeded to do sod all.
I say absolutely.

I’m now going to the Kingsley thread to nominate all the players I would like to select.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

There are too many societies nowadays, please eliminate three. I am not a crackpot
1034482.jpg
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Club History The Ollie Wines Society for young stars who break out against Melbourne

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top