This is not good!

[Coin_Toss]

Scroll through the playing list, and name all of the half back flankers we have - heaps. Is this a concern?

The following have/ can play on a half back flank;
James Clement
Jason Cloke
Ben Johnson
Ryan Lonie
Nick Maxwell
Chad Morrison
Heath Shaw
Rhyce Shaw
Harry O'Brien
Danny Stanley
Scott Pendlebury

Scary!

 

[The_New_Recruit]

Scary? not necessarily,

Half forward flankers at our disposal,

Buckley, Burns, Caracella, C & T Cloke, Davis, Didak, Egan, Fraser, Lonie, Rocca, Rusling, Tarrant & others. Have not included our New Recruits either.

Wouldn't be overly concerned about it.

 

[Stan.]

Most of those players can play elsewhere they are not just half back flankers.

 

[Coin_Toss]

Most of those players can play elsewhere they are not just half back flankers.

Heath Shaw
Harry O'Brien
Ben Johnson (who I believe is a Half Back Flanker, not a midfielder)
Nick Maxwell
Chad Morrison
Rhyce Shaw
Ryan Lonie


They're half back flankers only. 7 is still a lot.

 

[Lensen]

Chad Morrison can't play on a HBF!

 

[Stan.]

Maxwell can easily play forward, heath shaw can play in the middle and up front, rhyce and johnno can play anywhere and johnno has pinched hit across half forward.

There pretty flexible.

 

[hotpie]

Heath Shaw
Harry O'Brien
Ben Johnson (who I believe is a Half Back Flanker, not a midfielder)
Nick Maxwell
Chad Morrison
Rhyce Shaw
Ryan Lonie


They're half back flankers only. 7 is still a lot.

O'Brien and Maxwell can play back pocket or FB/CHB. Maxwell has shown some form in the forward line. Johnson and Shaw can play midfield, especially tagging roles. Lonie can play wing

That leaves the Crab as our only genuine half back flanker, and thats because he's no good at anything else!!

Sorry, but its a stupid thread.

 

[Jabso]

Johnson can play anywhere (see some of his forward line work).
Lonie shows a bit as a tagger.
Shaw can play midfield/wing and this is probably his preferred spot.

 

[MarkT]

What's scarey is that MM wants everyone to play HBF.

 

[magpies42]

Scroll through the playing list, and name all of the half back flankers we have - heaps. Is this a concern?

The following have/ can play on a half back flank;
James Clement
Jason Cloke
Ben Johnson
Ryan Lonie
Nick Maxwell
Chad Morrison
Heath Shaw
Rhyce Shaw
Harry O'Brien
Danny Stanley
Scott Pendlebury

Scary!

Versatility isnt a bad thing. For instance i see pendelbury as a Pavlich type player, Sheedy said CLement would be a 100 goal FF. Johnson and lonie spending time in the middle.

 

[FadeAway]

Chad Morrison can't play on a HBF!

Well put!!! He cant play CHB! I would like to see him play in the GUTS!!! Give him some game time there and see how he goes, he is surprisgly quick. Rated in our top 10 in time trials last year!

 

[Lensen]

Well put!!! He cant play CHB! I would like to see him play in the GUTS!!! Give him some game time there and see how he goes, he is surprisgly quick. Rated in our top 10 in time trials last year!

I was inferring he can't play. Period.

 

[Therussian]

I was inferring he can't play. Period.

no arguments here.

 

[Jabso]

Walker: CHB/FB or bust.

 

[hotpie]

Walker: CHB/FB or bust.

yes, spot on

 

[Johnson#26]

I reckon its ok. Creates healthy competition for places in the side.