Remove this Banner Ad

Tivendale

  • Thread starter Thread starter CJH
  • Start date Start date
  • Tagged users Tagged users None

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

CJH

CJH

Norm Smith Medallist
Veteran
Joined
Oct 20, 2000
Posts
6,149
Reaction score
80
Location
Belgrave
AFL Club
Richmond
Other Teams
Richmond
Clearly had one of his worst games ever today. Only 4 touches. Not good enough for someone who should get 20 kicks each week. Would not be surprised if he went for a trip up Sydney road next week.
 
yeah, he's down on confidence. He always seems to run into trouble. He's not very good in crowded situations. He usually picks the ball up when it's obvious he will get tackled. He's very good as a receiver though. Give him a run for Coburg as well as Chaffey.
 
Tivendale, Chaffey and Jackson for Raines, Roach and Moore would be my changes for the week.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

He still has a chance, but the best thing for him and the team is to get some confidence back at Coburg. Right now we can't afford to carry someone so out of touch in the seniors.
 
We just dropped Roach because he isn't quite ready, why would we play him next week? I would give Meyer a try this week because his class stands out in the 2nds. Raines and Meyer to come in for Tivva and Chaff. I'd love to see Tambling in although he's been injured
 
Roach played pretty well according to all reports, so he should be rewarded for his efforts. Was dropped after only one bad game so he should be brought back in after one good game.
 
If it were up to me:

OUT:
Jackson
Tivendale
Chaffey

IN:
Moore
Roach*
Meyer/Gilmour/Polo/Raines

*Roach was in Coburgs best. Id player who ever stands up for Coburg next week and not Tambling untill he is 100%
 
i really dont want to see meyer in the 22 for a lil while yet. he's size worries me. but yes his body can take a lot for his size. up to TW if he thinks he's ready. id probs pefer kelvin moore to be given a crack.
 
Tambo!!!! said:
i really dont want to see meyer in the 22 for a lil while yet. he's size worries me. but yes his body can take a lot for his size. up to TW if he thinks he's ready. id probs pefer kelvin moore to be given a crack.
Click to expand...
Thats a good call. You can really ******** them up if they aren't ready.
 
Tambo!!!! said:
i really dont want to see meyer in the 22 for a lil while yet. he's size worries me. but yes his body can take a lot for his size. up to TW if he thinks he's ready. id probs pefer kelvin moore to be given a crack.
Click to expand...

If Farren Ray, Monfries, Thurgood can play AFL I wouldnt mind seeing Meyer getting a game if form warrents it.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Can people stop naming Moore to come into the side, he's done nothing to warrant selection over the preseason and is still trying to get some scar tissue in his foot to settle.
Wallace has made it clear that you need to earn your spot in the side, so at this point in time Moore shouldn't be considered.

Bulldogs aren't the biggest side going around, so theres no reason a Meyer or Gilmour couldn't get a call up. According to the Coburg site Roach was best for us so should get a go in place of Tivendale on the wing.
 
With the years the club has persisted with him, he should be doing alot more.
I use to really like him as a player but RFC can no longer accept passengers in its side.

This will be his last year at the club. He can't cut it when the pressure is on.

Sorry to say, but it will be ; "Thanks for the memories..."
 
I would like to see Tivendale on the forward line.....he is not a wingman nor a running player, too slow and one dimensional...has a raking long kick but shocking short pass disposal.

Put him around the arc of the fifty and i think he would be more suited. :)
 
Press Conference......


Terrys words: When asked


Were do you think Greg Tivendale is at


Answer:

" Good Question" Greg over the last few months has shown that he is not in the best 18 players. Then went on to say no one is safe when it comes to selection. All you have to do is look at Hall has not been dropped for 6-12months. Greg Tivendale knows what he has to do and he is working on it. So really its up2 greg what he wants to do seniors or seconds haha

From that I feel he is a good chance to get the arse this week.
 
CJH said:
Clearly had one of his worst games ever today. Only 4 touches. Not good enough for someone who should get 20 kicks each week. Would not be surprised if he went for a trip up Sydney road next week.
Click to expand...


Opposition has him worked out. Has no right foot and a heart the size of a peanut. Will be shown the door. Wallace has him in his sights. Mediocre footballer.
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

tiger of old said:
Has pace.the Pies will give up their 1st rnd pick for him :D
Click to expand...


There isnt one player on the collingwood list i would be interested in right now. Perhaps tarrant but thats about it. They have some dark dark days ahead. And the funny thing is buckley, at 33 years of age, believes he can come back and be just as good as he was at 25. Just goes to show they live in fantasy land at lexus.
 
Being a Taswegian its interesting to see a few of you guys mention Gilmour. It has been tough here getting a handle on how he is developing. He showed a lotta promise playign VFL here. Can anyone update me?
 
Truetiger said:
Press Conference......


Terrys words: When asked


Were do you think Greg Tivendale is at


Answer:

" Good Question" Greg over the last few months has shown that he is not in the best 18 players. Then went on to say no one is safe when it comes to selection. All you have to do is look at Hall has not been dropped for 6-12months. Greg Tivendale knows what he has to do and he is working on it. So really its up2 greg what he wants to do seniors or seconds haha

From that I feel he is a good chance to get the arse this week.
Click to expand...


you forgot the bit where he continued

"He struggled last week and was rightly so coming off the bench today, but I thought when he was on he did some good things and did enough when he was on"

dont let a good story get in the way of the facts now. :D

IMO he is borderline 22, considering if Sugar Kane overcomes his heel injury as to whether Tivendale keeps his spot when a fit Tambling returns.
 
Truetiger said:
Press Conference......


Terrys words: When asked


Were do you think Greg Tivendale is at


Answer:

" Good Question" Greg over the last few months has shown that he is not in the best 18 players. Then went on to say no one is safe when it comes to selection. All you have to do is look at Hall has not been dropped for 6-12months. Greg Tivendale knows what he has to do and he is working on it. So really its up2 greg what he wants to do seniors or seconds haha

From that I feel he is a good chance to get the arse this week.
Click to expand...

Good to see the likes of Hall, Chaffy & Tiv are not just being fooked off but are giving the chance to prove them selfs.

That said we may as well blookd kids; Raines, Roach, Meyer, etc.

roo_stew said:
Being a Taswegian its interesting to see a few of you guys mention Gilmour. It has been tough here getting a handle on how he is developing. He showed a lotta promise playign VFL here. Can anyone update me?
Click to expand...

Personally ive got high hopes for Gilmour. With the influx of talented kids comming into the club and Jackson, Hartigan, Raines and Roach showing abit you forget about Gilmour. However was taken first round and just made the draft cut off (1 day?) so to be fair its as if this is his season - with the bonus of 2 preseasons.

He is not even 19 untill later on this year so but has shown some good signs at Coburg. Lets hope he continues his development.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom