Tom Scully

[axel2cotch2lids]

I mentioned this towards the end of last season but im bring it up again damn it!

Why dont we have a crack at getting this lad. Unless GWS are offering crazy crazy money we'd have fair chance with the money left on our salary cap.

Melbourne tanked to get him so they deserve everything they get IMHO.

 

[Morro]

I mentioned this towards the end of last season but im bring it up again damn it!

Why dont we have a crack at getting this lad. Unless GWS are offering crazy crazy money we'd have fair chance with the money left on our salary cap.

Melbourne tanked to get him so they deserve everything they get IMHO.

I dont think we have a lazy mill per season laying around!

 

[cotcha now]

he was a true tigers supporter so he still might be at heart

 

[ScallyWag1]

let GWS burn their money on him, the less they've got to splash around in other places, the less chance they get one of our youngsters.

 

[jack the ripper]

why would he play for a club thats played 3 finals matches in 27yrs, do you want him to end up like richo.

 

[_RT_]

why would he play for a club thats played 3 finals matches in 27yrs, do you want him to end up like richo.

Because that same club has won a flag or 5 since 1964, unlike the one he currently plays for.

 

[turtle27]

why would he play for a club thats played 3 finals matches in 27yrs, do you want him to end up like richo.

Oooohhh, burn.

 

[Cleishy]

why would he play for a club thats played 3 finals matches in 27yrs, do you want him to end up like richo.

Becuase we are the Mighty Tigers and he is a Tiger at heart.

 

[jack the ripper]

Because that same club has won a flag or 5 since 1964, unlike the one he currently plays for.

how many finals did campbell play in,yze played in 14, c,mon, your 50/50 chance of playing finals every season,why would he go to the tigers when they never play finals.

 

[Rustof]

Certainly can't hurt to approach him with interest. It's every kids dream to play for his team he grew up supporting and to also be a part of it when he could be an intergral part of its growth. Though if by some unbelieveable feat he actually considers moving to us the cost would most probably way too high.

 

[The Goon]

how many finals did campbell play in,yze played in 14, c,mon, your 50/50 chance of playing finals every season,why would he go to the tigers when they never play finals.

And how many Flags did Yze win? That's right, 0. I guess if you've not won one in your life you can be excused for not realising thats what it's all about.

By the way, Bay 13 is that way <<<<<<<.

 

[THE_GUN]

why would he play for a club thats played 3 finals matches in 27yrs, do you want him to end up like richo.

Why would he want to play for a club that hasnt won a flag for nearly 50 years ................ hope that has answered your question.

Now F***k OFF

 

[borntigerfan]

how many finals did campbell play in,yze played in 14, c,mon, your 50/50 chance of playing finals every season,why would he go to the tigers when they never play finals.

Turn it up, No one remembers who came 2nd-16th. Maybe we can only remember 1980 but thats a whole lot better than 1964.

 

[delediofan3]

If Scully was a die-hard Tigers fan like me he would go to Richmond for anything

 

[jack the ripper]

Turn it up, No one remembers who came 2nd-16th. Maybe we can only remember 1980 but thats a whole lot better than 1964.

i like the tigers, there losers like us, but lets face it dane swan played more finals last season than richo played in 16yrs, think about it,if he wants to play for the tigers he will wait for free trade, if goes to GWS its a pipe dream, i hope you winners finaly play nxt season.

 

[ThePuppetMaster]

so i guess pendlebury and franklin will jump ship right across to melbourne then???

 

[Shere Khan]

Scully still had a poster of Lids up in his bedroom even after he had been drafted to Melbourne.

 

[Tiger_Stripes]

Any calls for Scully to come to us are delusional. GWS have the capacity to offer far more and even then why would we want a player so readily wanting to betray the club that chose him? On top of that, even should we be able to match the absurd pay packet it would take to get him, how would that sit with the rest of our list? Would they be comfortable getting paid a third as much as a greenhorn kid? What about at contract negotiation time? How much more will they all be asking for?

But all this useless rhetoric gets in the way of the simply stupidly blatant truth, Scully isn't going to go anywhere full stop.

 

[_RT_]

how many finals did campbell play in,yze played in 14, c,mon, your 50/50 chance of playing finals every season,why would he go to the tigers when they never play finals.

Number of flags won by Yze: 0
Number of flags won by Campbell: 0
Number of spoons won by Yze: 2
Number of spoons won by Campbell: 1

Speaking of spoons, did you know that since the Dees last flag they have won more spoons(7) than Richmond have managed in their entire history(6). This includes successive spoons in 2008-09 which just happened to deliver Scully to the Dees, no wonder Scully wants out, who would want to play for a side that blatantly tanks.

 

[jack the ripper]

Any calls for Scully to come to us are delusional. GWS have the capacity to offer far more and even then why would we want a player so readily wanting to betray the club that chose him? On top of that, even should we be able to match the absurd pay packet it would take to get him, how would that sit with the rest of our list? Would they be comfortable getting paid a third as much as a greenhorn kid? What about at contract negotiation time? How much more will they all be asking for?

But all this useless rhetoric gets in the way of the simply stupidly blatant truth, Scully isn't going to go anywhere full stop.

your smarter than the rest.

 

[Bazzar]

Wont happen. Scully will be out of contract and the GWS is allowed up to 16 out of contract players (1 per club.)

 

[jack the ripper]

Number of flags won by Yze: 0
Number of flags won by Campbell: 0
Number of spoons won by Yze: 2
Number of spoons won by Campbell: 1

Speaking of spoons, did you know that since the Dees last flag they have won more spoons(7) than Richmond have managed in their entire history(6). This includes successive spoons in 2008-09 which just happened to deliver Scully to the Dees, no wonder Scully wants out, who would want to play for a side that blatantly tanks.

do you see the irony, there both shit clubs, without scully were still better off than you guys,you didnt beat won VIC side last season, the time you guys fire riewoldt will be 36, if you nuts think us or you are going to win before GC or GWS your in a dreamworld,GC have a better list than our clubs now, sad but true.

 

[T4P]

why would he play for a club thats played 3 finals matches in 27yrs, do you want him to end up like richo.

i'm sorry, ending up like Richo is a bad thing?

And I wouldn't call this baloney yet. A little birdy has revealed to me certain information regarding Richmond's salary cap space and a certain gentleman's agreement between two parties.

I myself though won't believe it until I see it.

 

[jack the ripper]

i'm sorry, ending up like Richo is a bad thing?

And I wouldn't call this baloney yet. A little birdy has revealed to me certain information regarding Richmond's salary cap space and a certain gentleman's agreement between two parties.

I myself though won't believe it until I see it.

is that the same deal that the crows and GWS had about jack viney, were do you think these media outlets get this info from, THE MIGHTY BIG FOOTY.

 

[Shere Khan]

I can understand the kid wanting to leave Melbourne.

The club has absolutely no dignity or pride, as evidenced by the blatant tanking and reinforced by the Melbourne fans when they were cheering a loss to Richmond. The club also has sweet fa loyalty, throwing out their older loyal players onto the scrap heap earlier than they should.