Troy longmuir

[tico]

CC believes that troy should look elsewhere...even though i don't agree with it i understand why it would be for the good of the player, although i am hoping we don't trade him just for the sake of trading him. if it means that we are going to get a crab for him please don't trade him ,THEN give him a fair go next season .

i think thats fair

 

[Kapow!!!]

CC believes that troy should look elsewhere...even though i don't agree with it i understand why it would be for the good of the player, although i am hoping we don't trade him just for the sake of trading him. if it means that we are going to get a crab for him please don't trade him ,THEN give him a fair go next season .

i think thats fair

Trade him to Brisbane for Hadley, they said they'll take him!

 

[rgauci]

If he is traded he'll be traded for a pick. We have problems with too many players on the list. Its an especially big problem considering we want to entice players to come to freo.

 

[Farrand]

Keep T-lo and lose Medhurst.

 

[voodoo_86]

Too many players on the list? how do you mean?

I trade i'd like to see is t.lo for chambers. Interesting to see what eagles fans think of that one but I think it's relatively even. We need midfield depth and the eagles have it in abundance.

sif brisbane would give up hadley for t.lo.

I hope t.lo gets traded (as long as we get something of value in return) cause I want him to get the opportunity and do well. Doubt that'll happen at freo.

 

[pav_is_god]

Two words - trade bait.

Don't exactly know what we'd catch though...

 

[funkyfreo]

Well we have a forward line that is tradeable. I guess no point keeping Medders AND T-Lo, as then there is no room for new blood in the FWD line. So I'd see what we could get for them, and trade for the most promising offer, and keep the other.

It is not like a trade is a damning slur on a footy player - it is just footy.

I do think T-Lo is overrated by frustrated Freo fans, and wish he had had more serious game time so that he could be considered on merits, rather than be constantly held up as the scapegoat saviour.

 

[Mr Q]

I trade i'd like to see is t.lo for chambers. Interesting to see what eagles fans think of that one but I think it's relatively even. We need midfield depth and the eagles have it in abundance.

TLo for Chambers? Certainly doable I'd think. Chambers run would fit in well at the Dockers, but I don't think he has the right attitude. Skill wise he'd be a good selection, but I think he'd be better getting out of WA altogether.

Perhaps you might like to consider Jeremy Humm? Similar level to TLo and Chambers in the WAFL, but there is no doubting that Humm has a bucketload of heart when he plays, which might be a good thing at Freo. I suspect Humm would be very good for a team that gave him a second chance.

 

[funkyfreo]

TLo for Chambers? Certainly doable I'd think. Chambers run would fit in well at the Dockers, but I don't think he has the right attitude. Skill wise he'd be a good selection, but I think he'd be better getting out of WA altogether.

Perhaps you might like to consider Jeremy Humm? Similar level to TLo and Chambers in the WAFL, but there is no doubting that Humm has a bucketload of heart when he plays, which might be a good thing at Freo. I suspect Humm would be very good for a team that gave him a second chance.

There certainly are players that need the kick up the arse of getting traded. Much as Essendon like to claim they worked miracles on McPheee, I think it was the realisation that if he didn;t pull his finger out he didn't have long left in the game.

I really have no comment on who we should get, because it is a lottery of who will and won't come/go. Just so long as will get dirty, rip off some heads, and get hands on the ball, that will do me.

 

[mick ryan]

If he is traded he'll be traded for a pick. We have problems with too many players on the list. Its an especially big problem considering we want to entice players to come to freo.

And what are you going to do with the pick if you already have too many players on the list??

 

[mick ryan]

There certainly are players that need the kick up the arse of getting traded. Much as Essendon like to claim they worked miracles on McPheee, I think it was the realisation that if he didn;t pull his finger out he didn't have long left in the game.

Weren't Freo capable of doing what Essendon has done? short answer NO plus the fact that Connolly didn't rate him.

 

[mick ryan]

TLo for Chambers? Certainly doable I'd think. Chambers run would fit in well at the Dockers, but I don't think he has the right attitude. Skill wise he'd be a good selection, but I think he'd be better getting out of WA altogether.

Perhaps you might like to consider Jeremy Humm? Similar level to TLo and Chambers in the WAFL, but there is no doubting that Humm has a bucketload of heart when he plays, which might be a good thing at Freo. I suspect Humm would be very good for a team that gave him a second chance.

You won't get Chambers for Longmuir because WCE don't want Longmuir, you could get him by other means though.

 

[mick ryan]

Keep T-lo and lose Medhurst.

That is undoubtedly the most intelligent post I have seen on this site for a long time. Do every one a favour and send it to your Coach.

 

[bee dee]

V West Coast played 102mins for 2 handballs, just go and get the ball. Is overated and will be better of at a Carlton/WB. Remember Koops how did he go this year?

 

[mick ryan]

V West Coast played 102mins for 2 handballs, just go and get the ball. Is overated and will be better of at a Carlton/WB. Remember Koops how did he go this year?

Very very selective, wouldn't be difficult to find some similar performances from Medhurst. How did Koops go this year? ********house!!

 

[voodoo_86]

Perhaps you might like to consider Jeremy Humm?

Just what we need, another midgit
I think our midfielders are too small, and Humm is very much like Smith really, no point having both and seeing Smith is already in freo colours I'd assume it'd be him we kept.


Nice to see the valient return of mick ryan.. that was sure worth the wait

Koops has had injury troubles, but hasn't been anything special. Bulldogs didn't lose too much to get him anyway and he still has a bit of potential.

 

[mick ryan]

Nice to see the valient return of mick ryan.. that was sure worth the wait

Koops has had injury troubles, but hasn't been anything special. Bulldogs didn't lose too much to get him anyway and he still has a bit of potential.

Thankyou voodoo, by the way it's valiant.

Re Koops, you are exactly right that is why the Dockers got rid of him and why the Bulldogs should never have taken him.

 

[bluey17]

mick ryan - bolton or wolverhampton ?

 

[mick ryan]

mick ryan - bolton or wolverhampton ?

What are they?

 

[Mr Q]

You won't get Chambers for Longmuir because WCE don't want Longmuir, you could get him by other means though.

Ummmm, you might want to look at the entry under "Club" on my profile mickey boy.

Anyway, I think Chambers and a second round pick are likely to be dangled Adelaide's way for Stenglein.

 

[mick ryan]

Ummmm, you might want to look at the entry under "Club" on my profile mickey boy.

Anyway, I think Chambers and a second round pick are likely to be dangled Adelaide's way for Stenglein.

I don't need to look at your profile and I don't see the relevance.

 

[Mr Q]

I don't need to look at your profile and I don't see the relevance.

You won't get Chambers for Longmuir because WCE don't want Longmuir, you could get him by other means though.

It won't take you long, the relevant information is just to the left, where it says Club: West Coast

 

[mick ryan]

It won't take you long, the relevant information is just to the left, where it says Club: West Coast

And what has that got to do with what I said?

 

[Farrand]

It sure is a puzzle.

 

[Mr Q]

And what has that got to do with what I said?

Good Lord. Do I have to spell it out in words of one syllable or less?

You said: "You won't get Chambers for Longmuir because WCE don't want Longmuir, you could get him by other means though."

I'm an EAGLES supporter. My club already has Chambers. We don't need to get him by any means. We already have him. However I think Chambers for Longmuir might be a passable trade.