Remove this Banner Ad

Review Voss Beat Malthouse

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

TradeDraft

TradeDraft

Post-Human
Veteran Collingwood - Beau McCreery Player Sponsor 2023 10k Posts 30k Posts Collingwood - Caleb Poulter Player Sponsor 2022 HBF's Milk Crate - 70k Posts Collingwood - Josh Daicos Player Sponsor 2021 Collingwood - Tyler Brown Player Sponsor 2020
Joined
Oct 18, 2009
Posts
160,886
Reaction score
92,063
Location
Mornington Peninsula
AFL Club
Collingwood
We lost in in the Coaching Box and the Selection Table.

Reasons:


  • Mick Not Changing to Man on Man when the Zone was getting Destroyed
  • Playing too many Talls
  • Too Slow Side. Get O'Bree out of the Side
  • N Brown should of played instead of Ben Reid
  • Defense who Leak to many Goals
  • Midfield getting Flogged
  • Not Heavy Tag Black or Power

Any Others?
 
Wrong, this had nothing to do with coaching, or selection. Our midfield shits on Brisbanes, it shouldn't have mattered. It was the players and nothing else.
 
Magpie said:
Yep, Reid shouldn't be playing hasn't shown anything this year.
Wood also looks asleep.
Click to expand...

Might as well Player Leroy then Wood and That is saying Something
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Zahki said:
Wrong, this had nothing to do with coaching, or selection. Our midfield shits on Brisbanes, it shouldn't have mattered. It was the players and nothing else.
Click to expand...

So Ring IN the Changes in Then because then some of them don't deserve to play for the Pies in the AFL
 
Jack Anthony - Absolutely Pathetic.
Shane O'Bree - Absolutely Pathetic.
Malthouse - Absolutely pathetic coaching. Beams stuck in the forward line doing nothing all night. Shaw in the backline. Lets gid rid of this guy cant coach for nuts.
 
Anthony wood reid all horrid

Reid being beaten by brown meant fev got loose, wood was just poor in general play does he have any urgency ever? And Anthony he drops an easy mark from a presti kick straight down to fev goal game over
 
beaten at the selection table
should of made a change when it was slippery
but we also got smashed in the middle and is there any harm in having players any where near the middle of the ground?

last week i was angry at this site and the people on it and the reaction to the loss to geelong
tonight im angry at the team ... you dont lose games like that ... now you can start roasting
 
mattys123 said:
but also because our list is 3-4 years from reaching anywhere near it's full potential.
Click to expand...

It makes me sad so many pies supporters are deluded enough to think this. Our list will be weaker in 3-4 years than it is now.
 
mattys123 said:
Mick wouldn't move Heath Shaw all night either.

Heater was tagged all night, yet stayed in the backline.

All pre season we heard that when Heater got tagged, we would make a move, BULLSHIT.

I'll say it now, WE WILL NEVER WIN A FLAG UNDER MALTHOUSE, not only because of his inadequate and antiquated coaching techniques, but also because our list is 3-4 years from reaching anywhere near it's full potential.
Click to expand...

Mick is to Bloody Stubborn to Change Things when we get Flogged. Bring on Bucks
 
Player's just weren't in it. End of.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

the question i ask is where are these new faces he said were coming?
barham was best on again in the vfl .. bring him in and stick him on a half forward flank, at least he will be quick enough to put some pressure on better than obree could or would, and jack for that matter
tarks would of been good out there tonight
a broken out of form leon at least keeps a defender honest
lots of options
 
Reid had 2 goals kicked on him by Brown in the 1st half from 5 shots, Presti had 2 goals kicked on him by Brown in the 2nd half from 4 shots.

Maxwell was put on Fev and Fev kicked 4 2nd half goals, but hey lets all pot the under 20 gamer.

O'bree has been shit for a while but has been part of the team becuase he is an MM love child.

We lack crumbers up forward, Rounds and Barham should be given a look in.

Didak is starting to really play like a pussy regularly and it's costing us.

We still do not protect the corridor and teams easily run the ball through there, we will not win a flag with MM.
 
Malthouse is a stubborn old fool who should do this great club a favour and resign. Typical beat quality teams and lose to rabble. Brisbane had 6 regular players out. Never prepared to make the changes - you are a tool Malthouse!
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Yep, definitely agree with most.

My biggest concern was we did NOT defend the corridor at all. I lost count at the number of times Brisbane were allowed to spot up free targets at will through the centre- just like last week vs Geelong and just like last time vs Melb. All these losses (bar Melb who should have really won realistically) are far too familiar in style and the opposition denied us the ball and pierced through the corridor with too much ease.

Also, forward line pressure was non-existant. Everyone called and screamed for Davis; head but the facts are that he is our #1 tackler inside F50- something that was MIA tonight. Perhaps people got a reality check after that performance tonight. Even with minimal impact Davis still pressures.

Sloppy by foot all night, did not revert to man-on-man style when we should have and poor decision making all night. If not for Thomas, Pendles and Swanny- this game would have been a rout, particularly with how easy we lost the stoppages and clearances all night.

Whilst we don't want to lose, this isn't a bad time to actually have some "reflecting losses" to get things right, rather than in 10 or so weeks time to be going through a trough.
 
Calm down guys, MM will be gone by next year. And hopefully Buckley actually listens instead of being so stubborn (Not saying he will be better than MM. Just hoping.)
 
couldn't agree more. massively out coached.
we changed it up in the semi final last year against Adelaide and it worked! of corse it worked how could it not. but during a home and away game MM is to bloody arrogent to change anything. we can't win or make top 4 if MM keeps that up!!!!
 
wtf was beams doing in the forward line all night? why do we never EVER use the corridor.. and what is with all the bombing into the forward line.. its ****n pathetic.. there is no point bombing it to talls who cant mark and especially when there are no crumbers in the forward line to pick it up.. is malthouse that dumb.. its pathetic its really about time the old fool is gone.. this is simply a game u DONT lose..
 
migz said:
wtf was beams doing in the forward line all night? why do we never EVER use the corridor.. and what is with all the bombing into the forward line.. its ****n pathetic.. there is no point bombing it to talls who cant mark and especially when there are no crumbers in the forward line to pick it up.. is malthouse that dumb.. its pathetic its really about time the old fool is gone.. this is simply a game u DONT lose..
Click to expand...

If you kick in the Corridor you are dropped and in the VFL next week
 
The answer to why we won't use the corridor is because if the ball is turned over in there it really hurts. In Malthouses own words he said our players are not good enough to use it, and he believes they'll turn it over more often than not if they try. Yes, he said that.

So basically it boils down to Malthouse having no faith in his players.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Remove this Banner Ad

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top Bottom