Votes v Essendon

[JuveRule]

3 - Morton
2 - Sylvia
2 - Bruce
2 - Bate
1 - McDonald
1 - Jamar
1 - Whelan

 

[StingaArmstrong]

3 - Bate
3 - McDonald
2 - Sylvia
2 - Morton
2 - Whelan

 

[bringbackschwarter5]

3 - The Master
3 - Col
2 - Junior
2 - Jamar
1 - Whelan
1 - Morton (just scraps in, based on his last quarter alone, for the first three quarters he was bloody average)

 

[omit]

3 - Bate
2 - Garland
2 - Sylvia
2 - Jnr
1 - Whelan
1 - wheatley
1 - Morton

 

[master bate]

2 - Bate
2 - Sylvia
2 - Junior
2 - Bruce
2 - Morton (played a part in 6 of our goals)
1 - Jamar
1 - Maric

 

[dee-molishon]

6-Bate
2- Junior
2- Morton (Kicking is shithouse)
1- Garland
1- Chris Johnson

 

[Supermercado]

7 - McDonald (absolutely slaughtered it in the middle)
2 - Bate
1 - Dunn (tagfest!)
1 - Buckley
1 - Sylvia

Apologies to Valenti, PJ, Garland, Green, Whelan, Bruce, Morton (can't wait for him next season when he's had time to work on disposal) and Jamar (botched attempts at playing on aside I thought he was good in the ruck)

 

[Bartram_Class]

4 - McDonald (could go on for years if he keeps playing like that)
2 - Morton
2 - Sylvia (frustrating, but never stopped trying)
2 - Bate (tireless worker, can have CHF to himself, Miller at FF)
1 - Jamar (dumb at times, but negated Hille)
1 - Whelan (does he ever miss a target?, so cool)

 

[whelan=legend]

3- McDonald
2 -Morton
2- Sylvia
2- Dunn
2- Bate
1- Whelan

 

[Headless]

I did a double take when I saw Jamar in the votes for the first time, but nearly everybody giving him votes is ridiculous.

He was shocking, he has to go.

3 - McDonald
3 - Morton
2 - Bate
2 - Sylvia
1 - Garland
1 - Whelan

 

[master bate]

I did a double take when I saw Jamar in the votes for the first time, but nearly everybody giving him votes is ridiculous.

He was shocking, he has to go.

3 - McDonald
3 - Morton
2 - Bate
2 - Sylvia
1 - Garland
1 - Whelan

Watch the game again, the ruck contests are bloody important, without a good ruckman winning the taps you can't win a flag. Jamar won more than his fair share of taps, and then fought like hell for the ball when it hit the deck. He and PJ also controlled Hille (supposed AA ruckman) around the ground.

Right now Jamar is at par with the other ruckman in the AFL around the ground, and is probably top 10 for tap ruckman. Jeff White would be at par for around the ground but thats it.

 

[RandB]

I did a double take when I saw Jamar in the votes for the first time, but nearly everybody giving him votes is ridiculous.

He was shocking, he has to go.

3 - McDonald
3 - Morton
2 - Bate
2 - Sylvia
1 - Garland
1 - Whelan

You have NFI about the ruck

 

[Headless]

Watch the game again, the ruck contests are bloody important, without a good ruckman winning the taps you can't win a flag. Jamar won more than his fair share of taps, and then fought like hell for the ball when it hit the deck. He and PJ also controlled Hille (supposed AA ruckman) around the ground.

Right now Jamar is at par with the other ruckman in the AFL around the ground, and is probably top 10 for tap ruckman. Jeff White would be at par for around the ground but thats it.

He was good in the ruck, I'll give you that, but he's shocking around the ground. Dreadful. The kid has potential, needs some confidence though...

Playing on in the goal square and screwing it up when the game was in the balance deserves -5 votes on its own.

 

[Bartram_Class]

He was good in the ruck, I'll give you that, but he's shocking around the ground. Dreadful. The kid has potential, needs some confidence though...

Playing on in the goal square and screwing it up when the game was in the balance deserves -5 votes on its own.

No-one is saying he's the next Dean Cox but if Dunn can get votes for keeping a a player like Watson to 14/15 touches, why can't Jamar have a vote for keeping the AA ruckman to a handful of touches and hardly any impact in the ruck?

 

[Headless]

Point taken - played well defensively, but every time he gets it, he turns it over.

Well actually, every time he gets it, he handballs it to somebody under pressure, who turns it over...

 

[hulld]

3. Bate
3. Sylvia
3. PJ
3. Morton

 

[2 Dogs]

6- McDonald- Vintage stuff today
2- Buckley- Starting to impress me more and more
2- Bate- Solid game
2- Green- Showed how important he is, uses the ball well evertime he gets it. Captaincy please

 

[dee-molishon]

Point taken - played well defensively, but every time he gets it, he turns it over.

Well actually, every time he gets it, he handballs it to somebody under pressure, who turns it over...

Im with ya headless
He was shithouse and still is shithouse.
Trade him fknin away, as for negating a ruckman in the middle, fk me, all you have to do is jump ealry into them like stynes did. Didnt realise it was such a scientfic nature that required a fine football brain like Mark "play on from the goal square after a mark and miss" Jamar has.

Bring on Robbie Warnock, even Jake Spencer.

 

[Dez!]

Im with ya headless
He was shithouse and still is shithouse.
Trade him fknin away, as for negating a ruckman in the middle, fk me, all you have to do is jump ealry into them like stynes did. Didnt realise it was such a scientfic nature that required a fine football brain like Mark "play on from the goal square after a mark and miss" Jamar has.

Bring on Robbie Warnock, even Jake Spencer.

He made a couple of mistakes so what, he was far from shithouse. He was very serviceable and his attack on the ground ball and in the marking contest were superb. Even if he didn't win the contest, he still made the opposition work hard to get rid of him.

He's improving slowly, but improving nonetheless and I say keep him.

 

[saj_21]

3- McDonald
2 - Morton
2 - Sylvia
2 - Bate
1 - Jamar
1 - Bruce
1 - Maric

 

[DemonJim]

Pretty poor skill level in the game from both sides. But exciting (in the 2nd half) none the less.

4 - Morton
3 - Bate
3 - McDonald
2 - Buckley

 

[The Great Gabsby]

3-Bate
3-Sylvia
2-Mcdonald
2-Buckley
2-Morton