Votes V Norf

[ImperialPurple]

5. Cookie - does he ever stop trying...
4. Jeffrey - ditto.
3. Dodd - had a point to prove and played his heart out.
2. Bellie - same as Jeffrey and Cookie
1. Schammer


My apologies to Pav as it's pretty hard to score a vote when you have 3 or 4 opponents for the whole afternoon, with not a lot of support.

Young BP tried hard in his first game also, and Mundy (as per usual) was not disgraced. Parker didn't give up either.


Polak needs to seriously lift his game and improve his attitude, JC needs to realise that getting 25 possessions (or whatever it was - I don't know exactly) is no use if 20 of them are turnovers, and medhurst wasn't allowed to play his game by being shoved from pillar to post and all over the shop. He used to be a selfish little ******** on the field... and he kicked lots of goals. Let him be a selfish little ******** and leave him forward and let him do what he does best - kick goals, Des is a complete front-runner.

It's official... today is the day CC lost me.

 

[Scham]

5. Dodd
4. Schammer
3. Farmer
2. Mundy
1. Crowley

 

[Freo Big Fella]

5. Cook
4. Schammer
3. Dodd/Farmer
2. Mundy
1. Crowley

 

[Ripper]

5: Bellie
4: Dodd ("this kid will be a player" - Gerard Healy )
3: Cookie
2: Our Jeffery (r*ped again)
1: Action Man

Thought Crowley , Schamm , Thornton were good and Young Bomber did allright first time out with excellent disposal which was a pleasant surprise.

 

[FreoDocker]

5: Dodd
4: Farmer
3: Bell
2: Cook
1: Schammer

With a mention to Schofield, who I thought played pretty well.

 

[dugrene]

5 cookie
4 Farmer
3 Dodd
2 Parker.... the usuall & Nearly slotted one
1. JLo ......Big heart the only ruckman.

Peake did ok. Looks too relaxed. Needs more intensity.

 

[Slacker]

5: Dodd
2: Cook
4: Farmer
3: Bell
1: Sch....ofield or ammer

I'm also gutted. Somehow this seems even worse than 2001. Whoever mentioned that we are burning out long term supporters was dead right.

 

[Ausgard]

5. Bell - I miss him <sniff>
4. Cook - Tried his guts out - would have got 5 but his disposal is as dodgey as every
3. Farmer - Umpires Crucified him twice. No wonder he gave Colbert a shove but needs to learn to shove below the shoulders
2. Dodd - Haven't really seen him before but looked pretty good
1. Haselby - for putting up with Rawlings without getting suspended and for a damn fine mark

 

[auste1234]

I am amazed so many could give that many votes. I was sure some would only find maybe 3 players worthy of votes. I myself struggled.


5. Dodd
4. Cook
3. Schammer
2- Void
1. Farmer

I thought Peak started very well, but he burnt out his petrol tickets early. I thought Dodd was our best, despite his shocking turn over. I am being very kind to Jeff giving him a vote, but i couldnt think of anyone else.

What i want to know is where is bell, haselby, Black etc. Our main leadership group is missing. Black once again got quiet a few disposals that meant nothing.

J Carr seems to be getting worse and worse, he is the new Mcmanus

 

[voodoo_86]

5. dodd
4. schammer
3. farmer
2. cook
1. parker

 

[Moo]

5 Cook
4 Farmer
3 Dodd
2 Crowley
1 Schammer

As I saw it.

 

[pinkus maximus]

5 Cook
4 Farmer
3 Dodd
2 Schammer
1 Bell

 

[Farrand]

5. Cook
4. Dodd
3. Mundy
2. Farmer
1. Schofield

 

[masai]

5. Cook
4. Dodd
3. Farmer
2. Bell
1. Parker (damn, if only he could kick a further 5 metres!!!).

I'm with IP, it is now official CC has lost me.

Drop Gilmour + 211, why?.

 

[hoss]

5. Dodd
4. Cook
3. Bell
2. Farmer
1. Schammer

 

[ImperialPurple]

While there may be more pressing issues at hand, I figured we may as well keep on top of this one....

Results Rd 13 v NM:

7. Dodd
6. Cook
5. Farmer
4. Schammer
3. Bell
2. Crowley
1. Mundy



Leaderboard:

1. Pavlich (59)
2. Cook (43)
3. Farmer (39)
4. McPharlin (23)
5. Black (22)
6. JCarr (21)
7. MCarr (20)
=8. Longmuir & Parker & Bell (18)
11. Mundy & Schammer & Dodd (10)
=14. Hase & DJ & Medders (9)
17. Sandi (8)
=18. Gilmore & Grover & Siegert & Thornton (4)
=22. Polly (3)
23. Crowley (2)
=24. Murphy & Webster (1)

 

[Ripper]

11. Mundy & Schammer & Dodd (10)

Thanks IP.
At least that is something to cheer us in these trying times.