Votes....yes....votes :(

[melbournemartin]

You have 12 votes to give to whom you please.

Carroll - 12

Done

 

[Supermercado]

4 - Morton
4 - Carroll
4 - Jones

 

[Sylvia Saint]

Carroll - 8
Morton - 4

 

[FOOOOTY]

Carroll 9
Morton 2
Jones 1

 

[Marns]

6 - Carroll (easily our best. solid down back, and also provided rebound out of the 50. The biggest mistake I saw him make was not sticking on Welsh down the punt rd end giving him a set shot goal...other than that, very good)
3 - Chunk (Whatever. Got enough of it)
2 - Sylvia (Was good early, went quiet)
1 - Morton (Tried hard for a skinny lad)

 

[dspeed]

5 Carroll - really solid, credit where its due
4 Jones - just never gives up, absolute champ
2 Morton - looks promising, he just makes it look like he has more time then others, really poised, lock him in the weight room for a couple of years and we have a player
1 Paul Johnson - thought he presented well, won a fair few taps, some encouraging signs
1 Bruce - fair effort on BJ i thought, certainly not our worst

wasnt pretty today, for mine i just started to focus on jones and morton, thats the future

 

[Go-Ricky15]

Carroll - 6
Morton - 3
Jones - 3

 

[bringbackschwarter5]

4 - Carroll
4 - Morton
4 - Jones (take time when you get the ball, dont just go and slam it on the boot)

 

[Deenamite]

Carroll-9
Jones-3

 

[2 Dogs]

5- Carroll
3- Jones
3- Morton
1- Neitz

I will personally hunt down and gut anyone who puts Wheatley in their best.

 

[Supermercado]

I will personally hunt down and gut anyone who puts Wheatley in their best.

SECONDED. Cheap possessions as a loose man in defence don't mean jack if you botch them.

 

[The Demon]

PJ - 4
Whitey-4
N Jones-2
N Carroll-2

I can't recall Brocky playing a worse game than today! What has happened with his leg speed?

 

[Deenamite]

6 - Carroll (easily our best. solid down back, and also provided rebound out of the 50. The biggest mistake I saw him make was not sticking on Welsh down the punt rd end giving him a set shot goal...other than that, very good)
3 - Chunk (Whatever. Got enough of it)
2 - Sylvia (Was good early, went quiet)
1 - Morton (Tried hard for a skinny lad)

Surely not Marns.

 

[mdrecords]

Carroll 9
Morton 2
Jones 1

agree

 

[Marns]

Surely not Marns.

He wasn't bad early. Certainly not great, by any means. He left in the third with a sore hammy and didn't come back, so I'm sure that didn't help.

 

[Headless]

None of them deserve votes, but, guess I should...

6 - Nathan Carroll
2 - Nathan Jones
2 - Cale Morton
2 - Paul Johnson

 

[Pjkimber]

8 Nathon Carroll- Played a solid game today, probably his best since 06.

4 Morton- What can I say? He goes hard for a bloke that has the frame of a stick insect. Get him in the weights room and in a couple of years will a) win a brownlow b) be the captain of the melbourne footy club c) BOTH!

 

[Bartram_Class]

6 - Carroll
3 - PJ
2 - White
1 - Morton

 

[Aquaman]

6 carrol
3 morton
3 p johnson

watching morton lining up on the wing he was really giving it to his opponents and trying to show some heart for a club he hasnt spent much time at. johnson was good early then was taken off i dont know why. carrol - my friends always joke about him being the worst player in the afl. he showed passion today and was actually physical unlike the other soft**** out there trying to earn a wage.

 

[Pipefitter]

6 - Carrol (Would have lost by 200 points without him)
2 - Mcdonald (Week in week out same effort)
2 - Morton (Has a skinnier bloke played afl? Didnt Shirk once)
2 - Wheatley (At least he kicked the bloody thing)

Hang your Head

Most of the others. In particular brocky (was he drunk the night before? He was asleep out there), Robbo (flying for speccys in wet weather conditions, he couldnt hold em on the lead let alone the air) Green (Most nothing footballer ever?)

 

[RandB]

I think had Davey played the whole game he would have been in the mix. Of all the players to get a bloody injury.

 

[saj_21]

5 - Carroll
3 - Morton
2 - Jones
1 - Bruce
1 - Johnson

And to those who are saying brock has lost leg speed, i do not think he was ever a quick bloke to start with. But after watchin the game saturday i believe the amount of hospital handballs he was reciving and then been caught out becuase of them would make Aaron Davey look slow.