Votes

[Kildonan]

I have been keeping a record of the scores which I have given for St Kilda players for their performance each week.

I give 10 players a score of 10 (for best) through to 1 (for 10th best).

This weeks votes:

Hayes 10
Harvey 9
Riewoldt 8
Peckett 7
Burke 6
Goddard 5
Clarke 4
Powell 3
Koschitzke 2
Ball 1

Cumulative votes ladder:

Harvey 56
Hayes 51
Riewoldt 37
Hamill 27
Gehrig 26
Jones 22
Ball 21
Koschitzke 19
Powell 15
Clarke 13
Goddard 13
Hudghton 12
Thompson 12
Peckett 10
Milne 9
Burke 8
Montagna 7
Capuano 7
Lawrence 6
Black 6
Penny 3
Moyle 1

 

[St-KriS]

Im glad you recognized Frankie there. He had a cracking game last night once he came off the bench. I dont think any Blue player payed him any respect and just let him run all around the wing by himself racked up disposals and in most cases, he used them well.

 

[Kildonan]

Thanks St Kris

Yes Frankie played well and I am happy to give him credit for it, but as you say his performance may have been enhanced by the fact that he was not tagged.

Other players I left out still played well and sometimes it is difficult to know how to rank players eg defensive players like Max Hudghton and Luke Penny played great games but their stats are nothing to write home against.

Also Fraser Gehrig played well but couldn't finish.

 

[St-KriS]

As you said u didnt mention Maxy and I didnt notice that at first, but surely he would have been in our best ten! He shut down Felova, which is no mean feat these days (how strange it feels to say that) with 2 bad ankles. I'd swap him with Powell in your list, otherwise I think ur spot on.

 

[Winmar]

Peckett had a very good game, as did Max. I'd put them both in the top ten.