Beerfish
Unscripted Hot Takes
- Jan 20, 2008
- 64,539
- 110,071
- AFL Club
- Essendon
- Other Teams
- Nic Martin
- Moderator
- #2
Last edited by a moderator:
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.

BigFooty AFLW Notice Img
AFLW 2025 - AFLW Trade and Draft - All the player moves
Due to a number of factors, support for the current BigFooty mobile app has been discontinued. Your BigFooty login will no longer work on the Tapatalk or the BigFooty App - which is based on Tapatalk.
Apologies for any inconvenience. We will try to find a replacement.
Thomas the Tank Engine stuff.
Log in to remove this Banner Ad
Always rated him as pretty handy
Will automatically make our forward line stronger.
Spells the end of the meatball though
He'll be an attacking upgrade on Guelfi for sure, but I'm not sure he'll be a defensive upgrade. We still need the ball to not rebound out of our forward fifty. Guelf is a player you know will do all he can to keep it locked in. Not sure Gresh has the same defensive tenacity, so I'll reserve judgment. Scott obviously wants better options to goal.Yeah I think he will suit a need.
Don't think hes a player you over pay for but as a non trade., He would be an upgrade of Gueif . Almost think his papers have probably now been stamped. Hopefully he can help with forward pressure.
Hear hear.I’m a big meatball fan tooSnelling actually sticks tackles and knows where to run when the opposition have the ball
He is above both in average tackles. Where he really shines is disposals, elite category. This suggests he retains the ball. Also above average in marks.He'll be an attacking upgrade on Guelfi for sure, but I'm not sure he'll be a defensive upgrade. We still need the ball to not rebound out of our forward fifty. Guelf is a player you know will do all he can to keep it locked in. Not sure Gresh has the same defensive tenacity, so I'll reserve judgment. Scott obviously wants better options to goal.
Welcome aboard Gresh!
Defend!
Are those disposal numbers inflated because he was given midfield time though?He is above both in average tackles. Where he really shines is disposals, elite category. This suggests he retains the ball. Also above average in marks.
His goal average is slightly below Guelfi but with those disposal numbers I suspect he massively brings others into the game with goal assists etc.
Maybe, I have no idea what midfield minutes he had.Are those disposal numbers inflated because he was given midfield time though?
And that also explain why his goal average sits below Guelfi's?
I was under the impression that his attacking work - vision, agility, marking, disposal etc., as well as scoring capability - must have been better than Snelling / Guelfi.
When I think of Guelfi I think of his desperation for 1%ers. Smothers and the like.
At first I was a bit non-plussed, but I can see a long term strategy bringing him in and lifting our performance. I don't usually use the word 'bolster', but Gresham, McKay and Goldstein really do bolster.Maybe, I have no idea what midfield minutes he had.
Guelfi can go missing a bit and Snelling get run off too easily.
Will be interesting but I am excited to what he can bring.
Congratulations on getting Gresham.
He has given me a number of highlights during a particularly rough period.
Most notably earlier in his career when he kicked the winners against Geelong and GC, and when he used his sidestep to great advantage.
Definitely he has X factor, if he can bring that to you then you will be very happy.
But for me, it was time for him to leave.
You know when you invest in a player and there comes a point you realise that they’re flawed and will not get you the next step?
Well, that was me and Gresh after our loss to Richmond this year.
His last few years with us were injury interrupted and I don’t know, but suspect, that may have taken a toll. Back, achilles and knee; all major.
At the very worst, you have a GOP that will fill a role for you.
At the very best, you have a match winner.
Let’s hope it is the latter.
I just wish meatball had a bigger bootI’m a big meatball fan tooSnelling actually sticks tackles and knows where to run when the opposition have the ball
This post would make so much more sense if you actually lost to Richmond this yearCongratulations on getting Gresham.
He has given me a number of highlights during a particularly rough period.
Most notably earlier in his career when he kicked the winners against Geelong and GC, and when he used his sidestep to great advantage.
Definitely he has X factor, if he can bring that to you then you will be very happy.
But for me, it was time for him to leave.
You know when you invest in a player and there comes a point you realise that they’re flawed and will not get you the next step?
Well, that was me and Gresh after our loss to Richmond this year.
His last few years with us were injury interrupted and I don’t know, but suspect, that may have taken a toll. Back, achilles and knee; all major.
At the very worst, you have a GOP that will fill a role for you.
At the very best, you have a match winner.
Let’s hope it is the latter.
Round 14, Sat 17th June 2023.This post would make so much more sense if you actually lost to Richmond this year
See now it makes senseRound 14, Sat 17th June 2023.
Richmond won by 20 points (90 to 70).
Gresham kicked one goal, had 16 disposals and amassed 55 AF points.

No current season stats available
Our small forwards typically get about 3 disposals and zero goals on a bad day. I get that he gave the ball away but at least he was in the game. Luck plays a big factor on a rough day. If a few of his kicks worked out then it wouldn’t have looked so bad I’m guessingRound 14, Sat 17th June 2023.
Richmond won by 20 points (90 to 70).
Gresham kicked one goal, had 16 disposals and amassed 55 AF points.