What If...

[Tzatziki_Man]

I thought we could have a bit of fun with this.

Simple.

1. Answer to the poster above you.

2. Write your own 'What If...' so the next poster can respond.



I'll start.


What if...Neville Crowe played in the 1967 Grand Final?

 

[BF Tiger]

Neville Crowe would not have felt bad about premiership re-unions.

What if... we "sacked" Jewell after 80 and went with Sheeds?

 

[Bazzar]

What if...Neville Crowe played in the 1967 Grand Final?

We would have won by more than 9 points and Polly Farmer wouldnt have had anything to bitch about.


What if Helen D'Amico had slept in and didnt get the train to Melbourne...

 

[tugga]

What if Helen D'Amico had slept in and didnt get the train to Melbourne...

I wouldn't have had two weeks of wank fodder as a young bloke after seeing his first ****.

What if Richo hadn't done his knee in 95?

 

[Roachy8]

What if Richo hadn't done his knee in 95?

He would have won the Coleman... nothing surer that year.

What if Sanchez had of missed v Melbourne?

 

[Tzatziki_Man]

What if... we "sacked" Jewell after 80 and went with Sheeds?

Would have probably won 82' but the cracks would have continued to show and we'd still end up this way, with Sheeds coaching career cut drastically short.

What If...we drafted Lance Franklin instead of Richard Tambling?

 

[slimdusty4]

What If...we drafted Lance Franklin instead of Richard Tambling?

everyone would be saying "how could richmond pass up on richard tambling, he is one of the afls elite, and this frankl.in kid, has barely strung a season together".



what if nathan g brown never broke his leg?

 

[1980GFVideo]

What If...we drafted Lance Franklin instead of Richard Tambling?

everyone would be saying "how could richmond pass up on richard tambling, he is one of the afls elite, and this frankl.in kid, has barely strung a season together".



what if nathan g brown never broke his leg?

Would have got Wallace another contract extension after his fifth year based on final appearance in the year Browny went down. Regardless of how we went afterwards.

What if John Northey had stayed with us after 1995 - Need to do better than saying it would have saved a 5 page thread questioning Bojangles sanity.

 

[_DBF_]

what if nathan g brown never broke his leg?

Tigers would have made the 4. Nathan Brown would've been top 5 in the brownlow, top 3 in the coleman.

What if Mark Coughlan never had to have those recos? What would he be now?

 

[Bazzar]

What if Sanchez had of missed v Melbourne?

We would be getting a compensation pick this year for Skully and Dustin would be tearing up the track with the Dee`s.

What if we hadnt let Cloke, Taylor and Raines go to Collingwood?

 

[1980GFVideo]

We would be getting a compensation pick this year for Skully and Dustin would be tearing up the track with the Dee`s.

What if we hadnt let Cloke, Taylor and Raines go to Collingwood?

If we kept Taylor, then Hogg never would have got his chance at full forward in the late eighties and we wouldnt have had anything worthwhile to trade for Broderick and Gale.

same question as above

What if John Northey had stayed with us after 1995 -

 

[Tzatziki_Man]

What if John Northey had stayed with us after 1995 -

Would have made a Grand Final, the instability of the 95 post season ruined our chances at tilting for a flag. Not too mention the terrible coaches we appointed in return, the playing group cared more for Northey, they played for him.

What If Matthew Richardson was a young 20 year old playing alongside Vickery and Riewoldt right now?

 

[Puntroad]

what if nathan g brown never broke his leg?

Ah **** it. That was going to be mine

Ill come back later

 

[delediofan3]

Would have made a Grand Final, the instability of the 95 post season ruined our chances at tilting for a flag. Not too mention the terrible coaches we appointed in return, the playing group cared more for Northey, they played for him.

What If Matthew Richardson was a young 20 year old playing alongside Vickery and Riewoldt right now?

We would be in the finals by now.

What if we were in Melbourne's shoes and had to choose between Scully, Trengrove and Martin? Also knowing that Scully was a Richmond supporter.

 

[Heisenberg_]

What if we were in Melbourne's shoes and had to choose between Scully, Trengrove and Martin? Also knowing that Scully was a Richmond supporter.

Would have taken Martin still and gotten the local boy Scully and GWS would need to find another player to offer obscene amounts of money to.

What if the AFL didn't intervene and Tony Lockett joined Richmond instead of Sydney?

 

[Bojangles17]

what if I had of asked mum to buy me a North jumper for my fifth birthday in 1973 instead of a tiger one...it came down to 2 choices,...lucky for me I was always an astute judge

 

[Heisenberg_]

what if I had of asked mum to buy me a North jumper for my fifth birthday in 1973 instead of a tiger one...it came down to 2 choices,...lucky for me I was always an astute judge

Nobody in my family barracks for Richmond except for me, everyone else is Hawthorn, Essendon or Collingwood and have all tasted the ultimate success and I have seen 1 finals victory.
My best friend when I was about 8 or so barracked for Richmond so I followed him, brother says I should go to his house and beat the shit out of him for the pain he has caused me.

Yet I wouldn't change a thing.

 

[Kingsley Anguish]

what if nathan g brown never broke his leg?

Tigers would have made the 4. Nathan Brown would've been top 5 in the brownlow, top 3 in the coleman.

What if Mark Coughlan never had to have those recos? What would he be now?

He'd be a lot better than most would assume. Losing him and Brown was a pretty hard hit. Not as hard as this hit though:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rbNyfl33GEU

 

[Crow_Sting]

Would have taken Martin still and gotten the local boy Scully and GWS would need to find another player to offer obscene amounts of money to.

What if the AFL didn't intervene and Tony Lockett joined Richmond instead of Sydney?

can only imagine!! but would we have got richo?

If Marc Dragicevic didnt do his knee, how good could he have been?

 

[captain blood 17]

can only imagine!! but would we have got richo?

If Marc Dragicevic didnt do his knee, how good could he have been?

Dragga would have been a better than average footballer.

Would Pavlich have got us any further in hindsight?

 

[tugga]

Dragga would have been a better than average footballer.

Would Pavlich have got us any further in hindsight?

Dragga would have been a gun.
And Pav? No. Hasn't helped Freo be a successful side one iota.

If John Northey didn't leave at the end of 95, would we have won a flag under him?

 

[captain blood 17]

Dragga would have been a gun.
And Pav? No. Hasn't helped Freo be a successful side one iota.

If John Northey didn't leave at the end of 95, would we have won a flag under him?

A flag no, but i reckon we would have made the granny by 97.

Who was a better CHB, Stuart Wigney or Paul Bullus?

 

[tugga]

A flag no, but i reckon we would have made the granny by 97.

Who was a better CHB, Stuart Wigney or Paul Bullus?

Wigney had a better season in 95 than Bullus did ever, but overall Bulluss gave us more over the journey.

If RIcho played for a successul side, would he have been as good a player as he was for us, or worse, or better?

 

[IDGAF]

Wigney had a better season in 95 than Bullus did ever, but overall Bulluss gave us more over the journey.

If RIcho played for a successul side, would he have been as good a player as he was for us, or worse, or better?

Imagine him at the Lions early 0's ... .. shudder ... self explanetary

What if Peter Wilson could actually play football ???

 

[captain blood 17]

Imagine him at the Lions early 0's ... .. shudder ... self explanetary

What if Peter Wilson could actually play football ???

He wouldn't have been known as "chook"!!!

How much did losing Justin Charles hurt us in the long run?