which Richmond players should go

[thetigerman]

Which players should Richmond de-list at the end of year ???
my list -- Blumfield , Marsh , Fleming , Nicholls , Houlihan.
any others ????

 

[BulldogMike]

Originally posted by thetigerman
Which players should Richmond de-list at the end of year ???
my list -- Blumfield , Marsh , Fleming , Nicholls , Houlihan.
any others ????

You have the main offenders listed.

 

[mighty tiges]

Originally posted by thetigerman
Which players should Richmond de-list at the end of year ???
my list -- Blumfield , Marsh , Fleming , Nicholls , Houlihan.
any others ????

Although he lacks skills based on attitude and commitment I believe Fleming will get one more year as there are many others around him that lack both. Duncan and Rogers are already gone.

As for the rest they'll go plus Hilton, Fletcher and Weller. The likes of Fiora, Rodan, Chaffey and Gas would be on thin ice too although we would be looking for trades for them.

 

[sante]

my list would be


Marsh
Fletcher
Nicholls
Houlihan
Hilton
Blumfield

 

[JohnF]

Blumfield
Houlihan
Hilton
Nicholls
Weller
Fletcher
Marsh
Morrison
D.Kellaway (ret.)
Rogers (ret.)


2005 Most likely:
Fiora
Rodan
Chaffey
Fleming
Zantuck
Dragicevic (we'll probably draft him again at the end of 04)
A.Kellaway
Tuck
Stafford (ret.)
Campbell (ret.)

 

[1980]

Trade Blumfeld to the NT league. Make an example of the slacker.

Get rid of Campbell. Look how well the Saints have done since they gave Burke the a$$

 

[JohnF]

Originally posted by 1980
Trade Blumfeld to the NT league. Make an example of the slacker.

Get rid of Campbell. Look how well the Saints have done since they gave Burke the a$$

Reckon they should get rid of Harvey as well?

 

[1980]

Originally posted by JohnF
Reckon they should get rid of Harvey as well?

What I reckon is that your poster boy Campbell should retire and avoid embarrassing himself in 2005.

And I reckon Dragga will play better in 2005 than Campbell.

 

[JohnF]

Originally posted by 1980
What I reckon is that your poster boy Campbell should retire and avoid embarrassing himself in 2005.

And I reckon Dragga will play better in 2005 than Campbell.

I wouldn't mind if Campbell retired this year, said it all before, he is over the hill. But he is still better than 35 guys on our list. But that's more a reflection of how ****ed we are at the moment than how good he is.

As for Draga playing better in 2005 than Campbell, I think Draga's got a 50/50 chance IF Campbell retires this year.

 

[BulldogMike]

Get Coughlan as captain.

 

[Tiger_Of_Old]

Johnson Will be the next capt.
as for the delistings id keep marsh for the fact that staff is getting on and you cant expect a rookie ruckman to shoulder the ruck duties so early in his career.

cheers!

 

[DirtyDogTiger]

The rucks are an issue

the rucks (Marsh and stafford) are interesting. if we go a youth policy we could still keep these two old fellas.

The alternative is to cut them too, let Otto ruck and recruit (EXAMPLES ONLY) Mott and Angwin as short term back upwith picks in the pre season draft .

 

[Pirate]

Originally posted by JohnF
Blumfield
Houlihan
Hilton
Nicholls
Weller
Fletcher
Marsh
Morrison
D.Kellaway (ret.)
Rogers (ret.)

They are the same 10 players I'd let go, although I'd try to con another club in to giving us a mid-level pick( Round 3 to 5) for Blumfield.

 

[IDGAF]

Originally posted by tiger of old
Johnson Will be the next capt.
as for the delistings id keep marsh for the fact that staff is getting on and you cant expect a rookie ruckman to shoulder the ruck duties so early in his career.

cheers!

Not the "Marsh " chestnut T.O.O . Why? Why would they not be playing Marsh , when Stafford is out now , has been for three weeks ?

Surely if the bloke had the vaguest notion of a future at punt rd. they would be playing him now.

He is finished . Full stop . Have a back up ruckman , sure , just not him . People are saying that this is the worst team in our history and yet Marsh still can`t get a game .

 

[Coach Required]

Been saying all year, I'll say it again

Add Bradley Nottens to that list

only player where we could trade and actually come out better for it.

 

[tigermania]

Originally posted by JohnF
Blumfield
Houlihan
Hilton
Nicholls
Weller
Fletcher
Marsh
Morrison
D.Kellaway (ret.)
Rogers (ret.)


2005 Most likely:
Fiora
Rodan
Chaffey
Fleming
Zantuck
Dragicevic (we'll probably draft him again at the end of 04)
A.Kellaway
Tuck
Stafford (ret.)
Campbell (ret.)

2005............. fair go mate. let's get 2004 out of the way.

What does the F stand for.

Fwit?????

 

[thetigerman]

Which players should Richmond de-list at the end of year ???
my list -- Blumfield , Marsh , Fleming , Nicholls , Houlihan.
any others ????

will now add --- Hilton , Hyde , Moore , Dragicevic to my list
with trade baits
Chaffey , Fiora , Rodan , Hall ,

I'm sure Terry will view each and every player on the list.

 

[sante]

My List is


Blumfield
Marsh
Fletcher
Hilton
Nicholls
Houlihan
Morrison
Dragicevic
DK (retired)
Rogers (retired)