White V Sandilands

[Gus2Gumby]

... or keep Simmonds and use the money elsewhere?

White has the superior average currently, but how will they each perform from here on out?

If you could provide some reasoning too that would be appreciated!

Cheers in advance!

 

[cryptor]

What's the rest of your team?

 

[Kid A]

Keep Simmonds for now. White will fall in price over the next two weeks. Re-assess then. You've probably got other priorities as far as upgrades go, but I will want White in my final team. He's 13-15 ppg better than Simmonds IMO (currently about 18) so it's worth a fringe upgrade.

 

[Jeremias]

Surely you've got other upgrades that take priority over Simmonds

Simmonds is fine to leave in for the entire season. If you are insistent on trading him out, wait a few more weeks.

And I would choose White over Sandilands, easily.

 

[Gus2Gumby]

Surely you've got other upgrades that take priority over Simmonds

Simmonds is fine to leave in for the entire season. If you are insistent on trading him out, wait a few more weeks.

And I would choose White over Sandilands, easily.

Thanks guys...

So White it is?

I want to upgrade Simmonds, SDT, Judd and Palmer with my remaining trades. Simmonds is due to drop over the next few week so I thought I'd make the move now.

My current team is

1. Shaw (DEF)
2. Fisher (DEF)
3. Milburn (DEF)
4. Cornes (DEF)
5. McLeod (DEF)
6. Bowden (DEF)
7. Myers (DEF)
8. Bartel (MID)
9. Cornes (MID)
10. Cross (MID)
11. Stevens (MID)
12. Judd (MID)
13. Palmer (MID)
14. Cox (RUC)
15. Simmonds (RUC)
16. Franklin (FWD)
17. Richardson (FWD)
18. Pavlich (FWD)
19. Johnson (FWD)
20. Brown (FWD)
21. Riewoldt (FWD)
22. Chapman (FWD)

23. Thompson (DEF)
24. Selwood (DEF)

25. Geary (MID)
26. Cotchin (MID)

27. Kreuzer (RUC)
28. West (RUC)

29. Tippett (FWD)
30. Valenti (FWD)

 

[Kid A]

Mcleod (will prob avg 70, can get a defender who averages 85), Myers/SDT and Palmer (85-->105) are probably more worthy of trading than Simmonds (75->90). You should probably keep an eye on Bowden as well. Unless you have a couple of trades in hand on top of all of that, I wouldn't trade out Simmonds in the near future.

 

[Alvin Purple]

I have White and Sandilands and both are doing ok (apart from a zero for White a couple of weeks back) however I think that Sandilands will get less game time for the rest of the year as Mark Harvey plays Robbie Warnock more often too see how he goes. I am a bit concerned that White might be a bit fragile as he is getting on in years now, I haven't got an emergency ruckman and dropped a game when he didn't play the other week, I think it was a sore back that kept him out.