Who to de-list at year end.

[Benny MOF]

Henneman

Watson

Bolton

Richards

Allan

Cupido

Hunt

Reynolds

Winderlich

Alvey

SHEEDY

 

[ManWithNoName]

Remove Watson, Allan, Cupido, Winders and Sheeds from that list, add Bullen and I'd agree.

 

[Bombers 2003]

SHEEDY

And the Tiges delist Terry Wallet?,yeah,right!!!!!!!!.

 

[dodgyJim]

I would say Allan will retire.

He is getting on and with Hille, Laycock and Carts. There isn't really a spot for him anymore.

 

[dougthelegend]

Henneman

Definately agree with him being delisted.

Watson

NO WAY!

Bolton

Get rid of him already!

Richards

Tough Call, but he's had ample opportunity to prove himself at AFL Level

Allan

Will retire after this season

Cupido

Give one more chance

Hunt

Hasn't had much opportunity, but i cant see him forcing his way into the 1st team, so he could make room for another player.

Reynolds

Delist

Winderlich

Keep for one more year. Could develop into a quality player

Alvey

Get rid of him!

SHEEDY

Stay. He's done a good job with a young list, the team we have for next season, with the likes of Lovett, Lovett Murray, Dyson, Stanton etc could be a very formidable side!

 

[DarthAnnihl8or]

Keep Teddy!!!!

I rate teddy but he just doesn'e get a chance, in one week out the other.

At the family day he said he wanted to take over from Sean Wellman, when Fletch goes and Keps likely takes his spot I can see Teddy being our link man he just needs to get a few games in a row.

 

[go team]

don't think there will be wholesale changes.. it didn't exactly get Carlton anywhere...

I'd rather see the club get rid of three players, four max - anymore and chances are we wouldn't be improving our list. If eight on the list need to go, break it up over two years.

 

[dougthelegend]

With Allan likely to retire at the end of the year, i believe that the few that we delist this year should be: Henneman, Bolton, Reynolds and Alvey (either three, or all of them). We are well served in the ruck with Cartlidge, Laycock and Hille, so keeping Allan would be a waste of cap space. The other three have not proved to be worth the paper their contract is written on, so they need to go sooner rather than later.

 

[mcphee is king]

Henneman

Watson

Bolton

Richards

Allan

Cupido

Hunt

Reynolds

Winderlich

Alvey

SHEEDY

take out
Cupido
Winda
Watson


Add
Bullen
Haynes

then you got yourself a deal ..

Teddy and Hunt to go of there own accord, never going to get a fair run at Essendon, would rather see them go somewhere else, and make it, rather than rot away at Bendigo

 

[CrackerJack]

zantuck

 

[robrulz5]

Henneman

Watson

Bolton

Richards

Allan

Hunt

Reynolds

Bullen

Here's a better list.

 

[McVeighs Chick]

yeh allan would have to retire, we cant keep him anyway, we got hilly as our main ruck then laycock and carts

 

[Benny MOF]

Remove Watson, Allan, Cupido, Winders and Sheeds from that list, add Bullen and I'd agree.

Could you tell me what value Watson has been in his 4 years on the list? None

Cupido is too self absorbed and really only gets a kick when were already winning by heaps.

 

[Benny MOF]

Keep Teddy!!!!

I rate teddy but he just doesn'e get a chance, in one week out the other.

At the family day he said he wanted to take over from Sean Wellman, when Fletch goes and Keps likely takes his spot I can see Teddy being our link man he just needs to get a few games in a row.

Teddy is no good, he struggles at VFL level. He seemed disinterested against the pies. Doesn't seem to enjoy physical contact either. His defensive skill are also poor. He can't take a significant grab.

I think he was a bit ambitious when he made the Wellman call.

 

[dougthelegend]

Could you tell me what value Watson has been in his 4 years on the list? None

Cupido is too self absorbed and really only gets a kick when were already winning by heaps.

Watson has shown signs of being a good player for us. He has found it difficult to make his mark with the quality of players that we have had around over the last couple of years. But with a few careful delistings and recruitments, he will have a place in our lineup.

 

[ant555]

Bolton being under contract next year excludes him from be de listed so he has to be traded.
I think Bullen , Haynes and Alvey are gone. Cant see them keeping Allen with three other ruck choices. Thats 4 gone and it is likely we will get rid of 7(depending on who may come up in the pre season draft).
I wouldnt think Reynolds would be in such a strong position. Justin Murphy must now be under pressure to retain his spot now he has been dropped.
Not sure why Sam Hunt cant get in , really he has had a great year for Bendigo with a heap of games where he has been in the best players inculding last week.If he cant get into the side now he never will so he must be close to being cut.
Cupido is an interseting one , i would be prepared to give him one last chance but i can see why others want him gone.
Winderlich looks like he is coming good with some solid form this year.
It is too early to dump Watson but if the injuries keep coming next year then his place on the list must be looked at. Personally i dont think he can make it with us as a midfielder but he does have the talent to be a good half forward/back.

 

[ant555]

Forgot to mention a couple.Richards who i think has had his chance. For me i would not be fussed if we let him go but in saying that if they trade Bolton and deslist Henno (which we should) then he may earn a reprive. We cant dump too many 190cm plus players in one go. so who do i think we get rid off.
Allen
Alvey
Bullen
Haynes
Hennaman
Murphy
Reynolds
Richards/Bolton/Hunt -dont think we can afford to dump all 3 unless we pick up another tall back so one of these three to go.
That would be 8 players off the list which is a fair number.