Who will we promote?

[irish_setanta]

"I reckon Setanta O'hAilpin has been terrific and I reckon Jesse Smith's been pretty good and Nick Becker, and they're guys that you'd probably look at, these words where wrote by pagan in late july, what do others think?

 

[deluxeman]

SEtanta has already been promoted
Smith might be depending on how many people we trade and draft etc
Becker will spend another year on the rookie list

 

[no. 4]

Both Smith and Becker will make the senior list its just a matter of when.

 

[irish_setanta]

ok i didnt know that o'hailipin had been promoted, and i think smith will be a good player too.

 

[Kouta_legend]

I hope smith does get promoted asap, because he is a gunn midfielder.
Also can anyone answer, if he was Calder Cannons B+F last year, and also TAC best on ground, why wasnt he taken in the national draft, was he still not good enough.

Setanta: Promoted
Smith: Maybe 50/50
Becker: One more Year

 

[SMOO]

No rookie has been promoted as of yet.

 

[blues4flag]

I know hes on the senior list, but how has Harlett gone this year?

 

[Kouta_legend]

He had a shocking year injury wise

 

[irish_setanta]

They said that smith was slow thats why he didnt get drafted, but he seems fast enough to me, as for Hartlett i think he had alot of injurys this year.

 

[BlueBoy41]

Hopefully Ross Young will be promoted from the Northern Bullants list to the Carlton rookie list. I think he's done enough.

 

[Pivot]

Setanta and Smith. Becker I would like also but give him another year and hopefully promote him then. Rossy Young would be good to have on the rookie list next year. Smith could have an impact next year on the senior list.

 

[WTTF]

Hopefully Ross Young will be promoted from the Northern Bullants list to the Carlton rookie list. I think he's done enough.

No good mate, don't think we'd even look twice at him. Smith is the interesting one, a bit of a Bentick clone in some respects, so will be interesting to see what we do with him.

Will certainly depend on how the draft and trading period pans out. If we draft a few KPP, Smith will probably stand more chance of being promoted. Tomi Johnston might play a role here as well, if overlooked for the F/S and considered as a Rookie selection.

Bentick, Smith, Blackwell are all similar types and lack a little in terms of pace, so I question Smith's real value in when we already have a couple of similar players.

I'd prefer to take a punt on another KPP myself.