Who Would You Rather?

[Stants_24_Legend]

Just a bit of fun.....

Heres 10 matchups, tell me who you would have in your team.

Judd V Bartel
Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey
J.Brown V Pavlich
Dal Santo V Heath Shaw
Goodwin V A.Simpson
Richardson V Lloyd
Cox V Sandilands
Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite
C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne
M.Murphy V B.Deledio

 

[Darealrath]

Just a bit of fun.....

Heres 10 matchups, tell me who you would have in your team.

Judd V Bartel
Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey
J.Brown V Pavlich
Dal Santo V Heath Shaw
Goodwin V A.Simpson
Richardson V Lloyd
Cox V Sandilands
Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite
C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne
M.Murphy V B.Deledio

Judd
Alwyn
Pavlich
Dal Santo
Goodwin
Lloyd
Cox
Johnson
Burgoyne
Murphy

 

[jodo27]

Judd V Bartel
Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey
J.Brown V Pavlich
Dal Santo V Heath Shaw
Goodwin V A.Simpson
Richardson V Lloyd
Cox V Sandilands
Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite
C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne
M.Murphy V B.Deledio

 

[Stants_24_Legend]

put ur own matchups as well so we can get more and more

 

[drew_j]

Just a bit of fun.....

Heres 10 matchups, tell me who you would have in your team.

Judd V Bartel
Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey
J.Brown V Pavlich
Dal Santo V Heath Shaw
Goodwin V A.Simpson
Richardson V Lloyd
Cox V Sandilands
Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite
C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne
M.Murphy V B.Deledio

.ergase

 

[DonMania#5]

Judd V Bartel
Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey
J.Brown V Pavlich
Dal Santo V Heath Shaw
Goodwin V A.Simpson
Richardson V Lloyd
Cox V Sandilands
Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite
C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne
M.Murphy V B.Deledio

 

[jnash196]

put ur own matchups as well so we can get more and more

Rutten vs. Glass
Foley vs. Montagna
Kennely vs. Heath Shaw
Lucas vs. Buddy
Hudson vs. Hille
Ebert vs. Milne
Riewoldt vs. Pavlich
Fletcher vs. Rutten
Fletcher vs. Glass
Kepler vs. Rowan Jones
Bolton vs. Tivendale

 

[Stants_24_Legend]

Rutten vs. Glass
Foley vs. Montagna
Kennely vs. Heath Shaw
Lucas vs. Buddy
Hudson vs. Hille

Rutten - Stronger,More muscle
Foley - Speed and skills
Shaw - simply because Kennelly is heading home in 3 years
Buddy - Younger, more versitle and a freak
Hudson - better ruckmen by far, never rated Hille as a ruckmen

 

[Stants_24_Legend]

Rutten vs. Glass
Foley vs. Montagna
Kennely vs. Heath Shaw
Lucas vs. Buddy
Hudson vs. Hille
Ebert vs. Milne
Riewoldt vs. Pavlich
Fletcher vs. Rutten
Fletcher vs. Glass
Kepler vs. Rowan Jones
Bolton vs. Tivendale

Ebert - Milne completely shit wouldnt get a game in local seniors
Pavlich - More consistent
Flecther - Just those gadget arms
Flecther - As Above
Bolton - anyone who can stop a dual brownlow medallist (Goodes) is doing alright

 

[Bombers Fan]

Judd V Bartel
Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey
J.Brown V Pavlich
Dal Santo V Heath Shaw
Goodwin V A.Simpson
Richardson V Lloyd
Cox V Sandilands
Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite
C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne
M.Murphy V B.Deledio
Rutten vs. Glass
Foley vs. Montagna
Kennely vs. Heath Shaw
Lucas vs. Buddy
Hudson vs. Hille
Ebert vs. Milne
Riewoldt vs. Pavlich
Fletcher vs. Rutten
Fletcher vs. Glass
Kepler vs. Rowan Jones
Bolton vs. Tivendale

 

[mathew ollaik]

Judd V Bartel
Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey
J.Brown V Pavlich
Dal Santo V Heath Shaw
Goodwin V A.Simpson
Richardson V Lloyd
Cox V Sandilands
Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite
C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne
M.Murphy V B.Deledio

Spot on

 

[RED AND BLACK SOLDIER]

Judd V Bartel
Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey
J.Brown V Pavlich
Dal Santo V Heath Shaw
Goodwin V A.Simpson
Richardson V Lloyd
Cox V Sandilands
Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite << Younger with huge future ahead
C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne
M.Murphy V B.Deledio

 

[DarthAnnihl8or]

Judd V Bartel
Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey
J.Brown V Pavlich
Dal Santo V Heath Shaw
Goodwin V A.Simpson
Richardson V Lloyd
Cox V Sandilands
Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite
C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne
M.Murphy V B.Deledio

I know people will raise eyebrows at Bruce, but Burgoyne wouldn't get off at the tribunal if he wore Essendon Colours.

 

[wasupwidat]

Judd V Bartel
Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey
J.Brown V Pavlich
Dal Santo V Heath Shaw
Goodwin V A.Simpson
Richardson V Lloyd
Cox V Sandilands
Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite
C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne
M.Murphy V B.Deledio

 

[mathew ollaik]

Judd V Bartel
Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey
J.Brown V Pavlich
Dal Santo V Heath Shaw
Goodwin V A.Simpson
Richardson V Lloyd
Cox V Sandilands
Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite
C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne
M.Murphy V B.Deledio

Why would u want Waite over Johnson? Johnson is a gun!

 

[havoc_planet]

Just a bit of fun.....

Heres 10 matchups, tell me who you would have in your team.

Judd V Bartel Judd
Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey Alwyn
J.Brown V Pavlich Pav
Dal Santo V Heath Shaw Shaw
Goodwin V A.Simpson Simpson
Richardson V Lloyd Richo (not)
Cox V Sandilands Cox
Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite Waite (johnsons time almost up)
C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne Burgoyne
M.Murphy V B.Deledio

Deledio

 

[larson]

One that i've been debating with mates.
Winderlich v Wojcinski.
I'm outnumbered, but i still think Winder is better

 

[scottydeewah]

I'm outnumbered, but i still think Winder is better

- right now probably not quiet but he has a few years up his sleeve!

Surprised how many have tipped Alwyn over Aaron.

 

[Stants_24_Legend]

- right now probably not quiet but he has a few years up his sleeve!

Surprised how many have tipped Alwyn over Aaron.

im not aaron doesnt chase anymore and when he is under pressure he f**** up. If you have a look at the game between essendon and melbourne, in the last 1/4 alwyn davey came out of nowhere to almost run down james mcdonald, aaron davey wouldnt have done that. also Alwyn Davey can hold a tackle aaron cant

 

[Stants_24_Legend]

One that i've been debating with mates.
Winderlich v Wojcinski.
I'm outnumbered, but i still think Winder is better

wojcinski, just. Licha needs improvement on his kicking and he has since the start of the year but theres more to be done

 

[Jono B]

wojcinski, just. Licha needs improvement on his kicking and he has since the start of the year but theres more to be done

Winders kicking swings between brilliant and poor. He often sets up goals with passes that just about give the defender no hope yet he stuffs up the odd easy pass. He just needs to improve his consistancy a bit.

Probably the main advantage wojcinski has over Winders is the ability to kick goals otherwise I would say Winders. Especially because he is a 22 year old with only 41 games to his credit.

 

[BOMBERSG8]

Just a bit of fun.....

Heres 10 matchups, tell me who you would have in your team.

Judd V Bartel
Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey
J.Brown V Pavlich
Dal Santo V Heath Shaw
Goodwin V A.Simpson
Richardson V Lloyd
Cox V Sandilands
Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite
C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne
M.Murphy V B.Deledio

in bold are mine

 

[GoDons]

wojcinski, just. Licha needs improvement on his kicking and he has since the start of the year but theres more to be done

Wojcinski's kicking is ordinary at best. If that's what seperates them in your mind, Winderlich would be definately be ahead.

For me, Winderlich overall. Attracts more of the ball, is just as quick and has better disposal.

 

[bring it on]

Judd V Bartel ( easy one... judd is the best in the league...)

Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey (new talent... better than his bro)

J.Brown V Pavlich (tough one... dunno... both awesome)

Dal Santo V Heath Shaw (more of an in there tough nut who wins alot of ball
Goodwin V A.Simpson (simpson is over rated)

Richardson V Lloyd ( for the fact that lloyd is better and can kick. oh and doesnt sook.)

Cox V Sandilands (sandilands might be the best ruckman... hit out wise... but cox isnt far behind... and cox is prob the best ruckman i have seen around the ground and his skills are awesome for a ruckman)

Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite (waite sucks)

C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne (another tough one...)

M.Murphy V B.Deledio ( way more skills and talent)

 

[warney7]

Judd V Bartel
Aaron Davey V Alwyn Davey
J.Brown V Pavlich
Dal Santo V Heath Shaw
Goodwin V A.Simpson
Richardson V Lloyd
Cox V Sandilands
Brad Johnson V Jarrad Waite
C.Bruce V S.Burgoyne
M.Murphy V B.Deledio

I took Waite.....although if you were talking this season only the obviously it would be Johnson