Review Who's in you're top 25??

[332docker]

Who’s in you’re top 25 players – I’m only counting those who can play this year (Not counting those out for season),
I’ve put them in order – I’ll be happy when our team has all of these top 25 squeezed into our 22
1. Aaron Sandilands (inj)
2. Matthew Pavlich
3. Luke McPharlin
4. David Mundy
5. Michael Barlow
6. Stephen Hill
7. Nathan Fyfe
8. Kepler Bradley
9. Greg Broughton
10. Hayden Ballantyne
11. Chris Mayne
12. Adam McPhee (inj)
13. Matthew de Boer
14. Paul Duffield
15. Alex Silvagni (inj - test)
16. Garrick Ibbotson
17. Nick Suban (inj)
18. Tendai Mzungu
19. Jonathon Griffin
20. Antoni Grover
21. Ryan Crowley
22. Rhys Palmer
23. Nick Lower
24. Michael Johnson
25. Roger Hayden (inj - test)



Will be pushing for a chance:
Jay van Berlo, Dylan Roberton, Jesse Crichton, Zac Clarke, Jack Anthony, Clancee Pearce, Michael Walters, Jayden Pitt, (all played already) Justin Bollenhagen, Byron Schammer
http://www.sportal.com.au/afl-player-profile/1967/2011014/60
The Rest:
Clayton Hinkley, Viv Michie, Anthony Morabito, Josh Mellington, Peter Faulks, Ben Bucovaz, Tim Ruffles, Casey Sibosado, Gavin Roberts, Hamish Shepheard, Joel Houghton

 

[Quokka]

Another good game or two would be enough for Pearce to make my 25, there's a lot worse people to be kicking to a leading forward. On form he could have Palmers spot but still hoping he'll come good.... eventually.

I think Walters will be but need to see him playing this year before adding him in.

What we really need is some of those other players like Faulks, Sibbo, Anthony, Mellington etc to start showing they're good enough for a spot. If by the end of the season 2 or 3 of 'the rest' are getting results worth a call up we'll be a lot better off.

 

[Nickos66]

Having Palmer as your 22nd - does that mean he's your sub?

 

[Clay Davis]

I wouldn't have Mzungu ahead of Hayden.

 

[Nickos66]

I'd have Grover & Lower in front of Ibbo also.

 

[prattsta]

I wouldn't have Michael Johnson anywhere near the top 25 based on his efforts in 2011.

 

[Leslie_Chow]

1. Aaron Sandilands
2. Michael Barlow
3. Nathan Fyfe
4. David Mundy
5. Luke Mcpharlin
6. Stephen Hill
7. Greg Broughton
8. Matthew Pavlich
9. Matthew de Boer
10. Hayden Ballantyne
11. Kepler Bradley
12. Paul Duffield
13. Antoni Grover
14. Adam Mcphee
15. Chris Mayne
16. Nick Suban
17. Nick Lower
18. Garrick Ibbotson
19. Alex Silvagni
20. Roger Hayden
21. Tendai Mzungu
22. Rhys Palmer
23. Ryan Crowley
24. Jonathon Griffin
25. Clancee Pearce

Borderline; Johnson, Walters, Anthony, Clark, Van Berlo, Roberton

In desperate situations; The rest

I wish; Morabito Would be top 10 without question

 

[dockshark]

How do you go about squeezing 25 into 22?

 

[Forey Johnson]

1. Aaron Sandilands
2. Michael Barlow
3. Stephen Hill
4. David Mundy
5. Matthew Pavlivh
6. Nathan Fyfe
7. Greg Broughton
8. Luke Mcpharlin
9. Anthony Morabito
10. Hayden Ballantyne
11. Matt De Boer
12. Paul Duffield
13. Antoni Grover
14. Adam Mcphee
15. Chris Mayne
16. Nick Suban
17. Nick Lower
18. Garrick Ibbotson
19. Alex Silvagni
20. Roger Hayden
21. Tendai Mzungu
22. Rhys Palmer
23. Michael Walters
24. Kepler Bradley
25. Clancee Pearce

I chose to include players comming back next year

 

[Farrand]

How do you go about squeezing 25 into 22?

I'm thinking emergencies.

 

[maybethisyear]

1 Sandilands (Inj)
2 Mundy
3 Fyfe
4 Barlow (Inj)
5 Pavlich
6 McPahlin
7 Hill
8 Broughton
9 Moribito (Inj)
10 Ballantyne
11 Hayden (inj)
12 Duffield
13 Keplar
14 Subin (Inj)
15 Grover
16 De Boer
17 Mayne
18 Lower
19 Silvagni (Inj)
20 McPhee (Inj)
21 Griffin
22 Mzungo
23 Ibbotson
24 Palmer
25 Johnson (Inj - something wrong with his heart)