Williams gets a full game........Why?

[pieman1]

When this guy is on the field it's 17 v 18 pure and simple. Can't kick, stick a tackle, play close, gave Eagleton a free ride. Looked lost, would someone on the coaching staff have the COURAGE to tell Mick the lovechild must go! The wing is for Rowe or even Egan, not a lost cause.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

When this guy is on the field it's 17 v 18 pure and simple. Can't kick, stick a tackle, play close, gave Eagleton a free ride. Looked lost, would someone on the coaching staff have the COURAGE to tell Mick the lovechild must go! The wing is for Rowe or even Egan, not a lost cause.

Mick Malthouse has absolutely NO IDEA. Worst I have seen him coach since 2003GF. Utter disgraceful

 

[Nardz]

williams... the mere sound of his name makes me shreik!

 

[chaos_barbie]

i dont think he was that bad today, i think he jus needs abit more game time..his not a bad player when he gets going

 

[Captain Clement]

Certainly seeing Williams play in the 1st round was a shock, as he was ordinary (again), we cant let loose on him, there were some pretty average performances that i saw today, one in particular was A Rocca, absolutely pathetic today. Ryce Shaw disposal again terrible, woewodin unsighted, taz missing, why buckley played no one knows, he sat the bench 70% of he match. Until collingwood bites the bullet and decides that it actually has to let good players go to get a player they actually need, like a key position backman, a quick, skilled midfielder,or a tall key position marking full forwrd, we are going no where.
I know that eade plays that bull**** flooding game, its the only way he can actually coach a side to a victory, i thought mick was completely out coached today. To me his coaching tatics are still trapped in the early nineties.
We play like that against adelaide next week, we will get absoulutely smashed, because i rate the crows more than the w.b, and if they can beat us by 5 or 6 goals, the crows will crap on us.
Who can come into this side???

 

[yikes]

Why did Buckley, Cole, Davis and Fanning all start the last Qtr on the bench?

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Why did Buckley, Cole, Davis and Fanning all start the last Qtr on the bench?

Buckley is rooted....hammy is fukd again i rekon. Not sure about the other 3.

 

[browny4PM]

After Williams handed the doggies one of their early last quarter goal, i took my frustration out on the fence and busted my hand.

The medical bills will be forwarded onto Andrew Williams

 

[hilly69]

when i looked at the teams during the week and they named williams before rowe i was shocked, he may have been a good player but hes days are up. Hes too slow and no up to it any more, give young rowe a go he can run and he uses the footy well. I have all the time in the world for when we lose but the young kids get there chance to run and use their talent but when guys who have been playing Afl footy for years there is no way it should happen. Shaw may of got alot of the ball today but i still think he played poor he turns the ball over 2 out of 3 times he gets it he might as well not get the ball because if comes back over his head 3 touches later .

 

[coasting]

Andrew Williams... only the best for Collingwood

 

[machine]

When this guy is on the field it's 17 v 18 pure and simple. Can't kick, stick a tackle, play close, gave Eagleton a free ride. Looked lost, would someone on the coaching staff have the COURAGE to tell Mick the lovechild must go! The wing is for Rowe or even Egan, not a lost cause.

im not against williams but at times today he did look really lost. however he if can find some form he could be handy, yet he should be left to find that form in the vfl.

 

[browny4PM]

Yesterday was not a question of form, it was a question of commitment. He was pathetic. I don't care if a player is out of form and can't find the pill, but FFS he can at least put a body on his man and create a contest. He has got to go.