Werewolf Work it out Werewolf

[Pie 4 Life]

jmoo wan (Villager) Lynched by the Village
Jhye Clark 13 (Flog) Mod Killed for not voting

It is now N2

The clearly disinterested guy was a villager? Woah!

Hopefully we actually get some useful info tonight.

 

[Nothing]

Cadsky Do flogs/factions form if either of the 2 actioned names are in their group?

Also, will you announce if there are formations?

 

[boncer34]

The clearly disinterested guy was a villager? Woah!

Hopefully we actually get some useful info tonight.

Because evil never ever go to ground and hide

 

[Cadsky]

Cadsky Do flogs/factions form if either of the 2 actioned names are in their group?

Also, will you announce if there are formations?

Flogs form at the beginning of D2 regardless.
Factions form only when the Primary target is a teammate.

I will announce the formations in the thread

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Because evil never ever go to ground and hide

He didn’t even bother making a comment or doing anything though. Very few who do that with an important role (unless they’re literally absent).

 

[Gralin]

He didn’t even bother making a comment or doing anything though. Very few who do that with an important role (unless they’re literally absent).

He'd at most suspect he didn't have a role though

An unsuccessful result doesn't automatically mean villager on n1

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Gralin needs to get lynched I reckon. He visited me in my sleep last night.

I know a guy who can watch what you can do at night.

 

[DemurePrincess]

Why?

Just is. Very unfortunate loss for the village

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Just is. Very unfortunate loss for the village

The guy who posted once and voted for the tracker or the guy who didn’t post?

 

[Gralin]

I know a guy who can watch what you can do at night.

Who do you want to watch me try and visit?

 

[DemurePrincess]

The guy who posted once and voted for the tracker or the guy who didn’t post?

I’m more talking about the roles not the people who had them. Anyway, moving on

 

[boncer34]

He didn’t even bother making a comment or doing anything though. Very few who do that with an important role (unless they’re literally absent).

Of course you're assuming he knew his role.

 

[ClarkeM]

I know a guy who can watch what you can do at night.

Is it Crowwy?

 

[boncer34]

Just is. Very unfortunate loss for the village

Clear the deadweight?

 

[DemurePrincess]

Clear the deadweight?

I guess so but not great for village numbers. I’m assuming that’s what I am

 

[ZergMinion]

Just is. Very unfortunate loss for the village

Nah. It's jmoo.

 

[MC Bad Genius]

I'm only just catching up with the thread now, so apologies for the multi-quoting:

Christ I hope I die.

Also Pie isn't the tracker, he's using known information to appear useful.

Why would anyone come out as a good role day one under no pressure? The only known thing is MBR being the Mama Wolf. Nothing about you, I just reported my result. Very weird hill you’re trying to die on here.

All you’re doing there boncer34 is proving my point that there was no “known info” about you (which I reported my action) and that I misread the rules (which I’ve already admitted to).

To suggest I’m not the tracker off that is at the least silly, to the most, nefarious.

As I was reading through, I actually thought along similar lines to boncer. Which in and of itself is VERY concerning.

I was initially convinced by Pie's post copping to misunderstanding the rules. But him being THAT indignant about boncer not believing him seemed a bit over the top, especially since he loves these sorts of plays.

I think a few people would know their roles by now. Still uncertain about how the group PMS work if they're all together now or one by one.

I think there's a few roles that could be worked out by the holder tonight

1. Mayor if the second on their list is narrow enough
2. Arsonist
3. Doctor
4. Seers would already know
5. JOAT should know if it's in the order KILL Seer

Flogs would need to link up

1. Unlikely. It doesn't seem like the votes were close enough anyways, but in games that I've nodded before, the Mayor often is completely superfluous.
2. Not by tonight, but possibly by tomorrow morning. The thing is, we'll all know that they know too, which is somewhat comforting. Also, does this mean the Arsonist is essentially just a second Serial Killer?
3. How?
4. Yup, but not their allegiance (unless they got their own teammates for the evil seers)
5. No JOAT in this game.

Flogs might know each other, but they'll be joined up tomorrow anyways, so that's neither here nor there.

Oh. Well this is an interesting little outcome boncer34

In a normal game, it would be more interesting, but even if boncer is in a faction, the others wouldn't know at this stage, right?

 

[DemurePrincess]

I'm only just catching up with the thread now, so apologies for the multi-quoting:




As I was reading through, I actually thought along similar lines to boncer. Which in and of itself is VERY concerning.

I was initially convinced by Pie's post copping to misunderstanding the rules. But him being THAT indignant about boncer not believing him seemed a bit over the top, especially since he loves these sorts of plays.

1. Unlikely. It doesn't seem like the votes were close enough anyways, but in games that I've nodded before, the Mayor often is completely superfluous.
2. Not by tonight, but possibly by tomorrow morning. The thing is, we'll all know that they know too, which is somewhat comforting. Also, does this mean the Arsonist is essentially just a second Serial Killer?
3. How?
4. Yup, but not their allegiance (unless they got their own teammates for the evil seers)
5. No JOAT in this game.

Flogs might know each other, but they'll be joined up tomorrow anyways, so that's neither here nor there.


In a normal game, it would be more interesting, but even if boncer is in a faction, the others wouldn't know at this stage, right?

I wouldn’t have a bloody clue. I was lost about 10 pages ago!

I don’t even know what I’m meant to do in my pm now bc I’m convinced I’m just a villager so what’s the point of having a pm now

 

[Gralin]

I wouldn’t have a bloody clue. I was lost about 10 pages ago!

I don’t even know what I’m meant to do in my pm now bc I’m convinced I’m just a villager so what’s the point of having a pm now

One unsuccessful doesn't mean much

 

[MC Bad Genius]

One unsuccessful doesn't mean much

Indeed! There's still lots of reasons that a Night 1 action might not have gone through. If it's two from two tomorrow morning though, you'd be highly suspicious.

Speaking of, this is a great tune:

 

[Pie 4 Life]

Who do you want to watch me try and visit?

I reckon any one who was happy to jump on a late bandwagon is a good start. I’ll probably take a gander that way.

 

[Nothing]

I reckon any one who was happy to jump on a late bandwagon is a good start. I’ll probably take a gander that way.

Remember I started the train!

 

[Pie 4 Life]

As I was reading through, I actually thought along similar lines to boncer. Which in and of itself is VERY concerning.

I was initially convinced by Pie's post copping to misunderstanding the rules. But him being THAT indignant about boncer not believing him seemed a bit over the top, especially since he loves these sorts of plays.

No one loves these plays on day one lol. If it was later on or if I was under pressure, sure. But under zero pressure this early would be completely pointless. Boncer gets lynches and he’s a good role (in this hypothetical scenario) I’m dead the next day. Really pointless.

It was just a dumb play for me not to read the rules. I just assumed evil would be in PMs. But if I was trying to play people like Boncer was suggesting, that would be suicide.

 

[MC Bad Genius]

No one loves these plays on day one lol. If it was later on or if I was under pressure, sure. But under zero pressure this early would be completely pointless. Boncer gets lynches and he’s a good role (in this hypothetical scenario) I’m dead the next day. Really pointless.

It was just a dumb play for me not to read the rules. I just assumed evil would be in PMs. But if I was trying to play people like Boncer was suggesting, that would be suicide.

You love these plays every day and twice on Sundays! You probably don't do this, but in my mind you're actively trying to outdo your last subterfuge every game. You've probably got a scoreboard setup somewhere near your computer in your home office.

 

[Gralin]

You love these plays every day and twice on Sundays! You probably don't do this, but in my mind you're actively trying to outdo your last subterfuge every game. You've probably got a scoreboard setup somewhere near your computer in your home office.

He's probably got a vision board