Remove this Banner Ad

Werewolf Work it out Werewolf

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I imagine it’s like flog, unsuccessful unless they get a faction member.

Clarke, JHF and myself can’t all be telling the truth. Based on this I’d be looking at Clarke getting seer results and thinking he’s one of the big bad evils.
You could all be telling the truth. Clarke as Mafiosa or Beta would get successful results without getting any obvious result. Without a faction, those roles don't have a place or a direct action so technically he has a role, but they aren't actionable as such.
 
Correct. My “action” (note singular) was successful. You would know more than me.
Yeah if true, I reckon you're either Beta or Mafioso tbh.

Which if so would clear Headless.
 
You could all be telling the truth. Clarke as Mafiosa or Beta would get successful results without getting any obvious result. Without a faction, those roles don't have a place or a direct action so technically he has a role, but they aren't actionable as such.
Which is the same as flog though, Cadsky confirmed flog would come up as unsuccessful unless they hit a member of the same faction
 
2IC's would get unsuccessful actions, and also would die from.dousing.
But it would clear Headless (hence not being the arsonist). Which I know would put us back to square one with the arsonist/SK look, but at least explains it.
 

Log in to remove this Banner Ad

Can you summarise them?
Threads all over the shop this morning and I've clearly missed results because I have clarkey on ignore and don't know why people are even mentioned JHF

Remind me not to try and read before coffee
Can admin put people on ignore? I know it doesn’t work in reverse (never mind how I know this)
 
Which is the same as flog though, Cadsky confirmed flog would come up as unsuccessful unless they hit a member of the same faction
He was getting successful actions though, which is what has stopped me thinking flog (which would have been unsuccessful).
 
How would a 2IC get a successful action?
They don't have a direct action as such but it can't be unsuccessful (I would think). But they don't get any noticeable result from it. That's a Cadsky logistics question though.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

I’m pretty sure he’s just lying and has been getting seer results.
Well yeah I'm sure a few people who have said the results are lying. But the fact he said they were successful makes it all the more puzzling (would have been easier to just say unsuccessful).
 
They don't have a direct action as such but it can't be unsuccessful (I would think). But they don't get any noticeable result from it. That's a Cadsky logistics question though.
I think you're wrong there. Anyone with N/A for primary should get an unsuccessful result.
 
Gotta flip Clarke just to solve the mystery I think.
Yeah I don't think they're a flog (otherwise would have got unsuccessful) so either they're lying (which surely if a good role you wouldn't now) or they're more likely the 2IC if the "successful" action is what Cadsky has been doing with 2ICs. Either way he's much more likely a baddie than a goodie.
 
Well yeah I'm sure a few people who have said the results are lying. But the fact he said they were successful makes it all the more puzzling (would have been easier to just say unsuccessful).
Unfortunately ClarkeM is the one poster who might have an insane game occasionally just for shits and giggles.

And Headless obviously and Jmoo on occasion
 

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

I think you're wrong there. Anyone with N/A for primary should get an unsuccessful result.
Let's solve it then.

Cadsky in the case where a player has a role but not a direct action and then action is not impacted by any other outside entity (ie amulet, roleblock, protection) would it come up as successful or unsuccessful?
 
Unfortunately ClarkeM is the one poster who might have an insane game occasionally just for shits and giggles.

And Headless obviously and Jmoo on occasion
What are you saying, Gander?
 
Unfortunately ClarkeM is the one poster who might have an insane game occasionally just for shits and giggles.

And Headless obviously and Jmoo on occasion
My brain is just continuously exploding trying to piece this together. Like the spreadsheet is coming together, but there's still holes obviously.
 
Current plan is for flogs to shoot JHF so no real need.
I'd roleblock and shoot if they can use multiple actions at once. Only being one person left they will know who they are now. Just stops any chance of Shueygod being blocked.
 

Remove this Banner Ad

Werewolf Work it out Werewolf

🥰 Love BigFooty? Join now for free.

Back
Top