Worst Draft Ever

[Juddbemetron]

Im going to have to go with th 2003 draft
cooney (and possible fisher) the only A grade players
im starting from 1995 as its the first draft i remember
but feel free to nominated drafts before that in the other category

 

[Rosstickle]

2002 was pretty bad. Goddard turned out good, wells is OK but I couldn't even name any of the others

 

[murph#3]

2002 was pretty bad. Goddard turned out good, wells is OK but I couldn't even name any of the others

agreed, but i think kade simpson also turned out good.

 

[CrazyQ]

Goddard, Wells, McVeigh, Mackie, Malceski, McIntosh and others are very good players.

 

[Rabbit of Caerbannog]

2003 comfortably. I can only find 8 players from the whole draft that I'd classify as good.

 

[Rosstickle]

agreed, but i think kade simpson also turned out good.

Kade's OK but but if he went with a high pick (top 10) then it's a bit disappointing.

Goddard, Wells, McVeigh, Mackie, Malceski, McIntosh and others are very good players.

They're all good players. If that's Sydney's McVeigh then he goes alright too. Haven't seen enough of Malceski to really rate. Still, no real superstars in there.

 

[Cassius_Clay]

Im going to have to go with th 2003 draft
cooney (and possible fisher) the only A grade players
im starting from 1995 as its the first draft i remember
but feel free to nominated drafts before that in the other category

Did you just mention Fisher and 'A Grade' in the same sentence? Totally hopeless.

 

[Schulzenfest]

^^^^^^^^^^^^^ You are an idiot. Being a Collingwood supporter, I'm sure you probably think Chris Dawes/Ben Reid/Tyson Goldsack/Random rookie who's never played a game is better.

 

[Dave The Man]

^^^^^^^^^^^^^ You are an idiot. Being a Collingwood supporter, I'm sure you probably think Chris Dawes/Ben Reid/Tyson Goldsack/Random rookie who's never played a game is better.

Not Yet - But Who Knows.

H Shaw was also from the 2003 Draft

 

[Cassius_Clay]

^^^^^^^^^^^^^ You are an idiot. Being a Collingwood supporter, I'm sure you probably think Chris Dawes/Ben Reid/Tyson Goldsack/Random rookie who's never played a game is better.

Most Carlton fans dont even rate him. Dawes and co cant be worse than Fisher

BTW, Goldsack is a defender if you havent noticed.

 

[__aria__]

2003 easily

 

[qldbluesman_43]

The 2003 draft isn't as bad as many think but its still not good
2003
Cooney, Walker, Sylvia, Ray, McLean, Waters, Stanton, Mundy, Chaplin, Symes, Adcock, Blake, Buchanon, Shaw, S. Fisher, Hudson, Rischitelli, Bannister, Tuck, Raines

2002
Goddard, Wells, Brennan, J.McVeigh, Salopek, Mackie, McIntosh, Laycok, Winderlich, Schulz, Gilham, T. Selwood, Minson, T. Lonergan, P. Johnson, Rivers, Merett, Callan, Watson, Ebert, C. Cloke, Corrie, Simpson, A. Selwood, Crowly, Malceski, B. Fisher

1998
Headland, longmuir, fosdike, Carr, J. Bolton, McVeigh, Hayes, Ramanauskus, Rawlings, Burton, Street, Davis, Wojcinski, C. Bolton, Jacobs, Fevola, Thurstans, Scotland, Embly, McGregor,

1996
Gardiner, Nathan g. Brown, H. Black, Notting, J. Johnson, Sinclair, Pike, Montgomery, Braun, Mooney, Pickett, Robertson,

Based at looking at this 1996 wins! It's got nobody else, and this lot isn't that great at all - altough i might not know some of the players very well.

Just for comparison
2001
Hodge, Ball, Judd, Polak, X. Clarke, Sampi, Hale, Bartel, S. Power, Dal Santo, reilly, Ladson, Kelly, Gram, Maguire, Seaby, S. Johnson, Roberts-Thomson, C. Brown, Rodan, Mitchell, Montagna, Hansen, Ablett, Waite, Welsh, Miller, Medhurst, Swan, Schneider, White, Hyde, Lake/ Harris

 

[00Stinger]

Im going to have to go with th 2003 draft
cooney (and possible fisher) the only A grade players
im starting from 1995 as its the first draft i remember
but feel free to nominated drafts before that in the other category

Brock McLean is A grade he just keeps getting injured.
We were crap this year and when he got injured in R13 he was in the top 6 for possessions in the league. Imagine what he would do in a good team

 

[Winner]

They're all good players. If that's Sydney's McVeigh then he goes alright too. Haven't seen enough of Malceski to really rate. Still, no real superstars in there.

Trying to say Essendon's Mcveigh is bad/worse than Sydneys? Some people have such short memories.

 

[CrazyQ]

Jarryd McVeigh is a better footballer than Mark IMO.

 

[Rabbit of Caerbannog]

Jarryd McVeigh is a better footballer than Mark IMO.

Both are better than Wells.

 

[WN123]

Jarryd McVeigh is a better footballer than Mark IMO.

Let me see. In 2008 Mark averaged more possessions, more contested posessions, more clearances, more tackles, more 1%ers, more inside 50's more rebound 50's. Guess you are mistaken. Jarrad is good (and may end up better) but at the moment Mark is in front.