Would you..

[tashibatts]

Just wondering if you saints fans would accept this as a trade:

Carey to Adelaide
K.Johnson to the Saints
#3 to the Roos

I thought that it was pretty good for you because Harvey and Burke will retire soon, you have lots of young players- and they will need guidance, and an experienced midfielder would go well in your midfield, which has lots of young upcoming midfielders but without Burke and Harvey not much experience.. and you would have a very good lineup in a couple of years..

Just wanted your thoughts..

Go Roos

 

[Savatage]

Originally posted by tashibatts
Just wondering if you saints fans would accept this as a trade:

Carey to Adelaide
K.Johnson to the Saints
#3 to the Roos

I thought that it was pretty good for you because Harvey and Burke will retire soon, you have lots of young players- and they will need guidance, and an experienced midfielder would go well in your midfield, which has lots of young upcoming midfielders but without Burke and Harvey not much experience.. and you would have a very good lineup in a couple of years..

Just wanted your thoughts..

Go Roos

We got Heath Black for pick #17. He doesn't lack too much from Kane Johnson. In fact I'm happier with Black.

I'd take Kane Johnson, but not over Steven Salopek, so come back with another proposition.

 

[Groucho]

Re: Re: Would you..

Originally posted by Savatage


We got Heath Black for pick #17. He doesn't lack too much from Kane Johnson. In fact I'm happier with Black.

I'd take Kane Johnson, but not over Steven Salopek, so come back with another proposition.

I agree that tashi may have been a little ambitious with her proposal but Black over Johnson? I don't think so.

 

[Savatage]

Re: Re: Re: Would you..

Originally posted by Groucho


I agree that tashi may have been a little ambitious with her proposal but Black over Johnson? I don't think so.

Well I do think so.

Especially with our football club where ball carrying ability & pinpoint skills are most needed.

Kane Johnson is a different type of footballer, who would suit any club- but as per my opinion above, for what we need Heath Black is more important.

Like I said, I'd take him! Just wouldn't waste a 3rd pick.

 

[Falchoon]

Originally posted by tashibatts
Just wondering if you saints fans would accept this as a trade:

Carey to Adelaide
K.Johnson to the Saints
#3 to the Roos

Kane Johnson is not worth a top 3 pick.

Has been stated that the Saints will not trade top picks,
would have to be exceptional to consider it.

 

[evertonfc]

Re: Re: Re: Would you..

Originally posted by Groucho


I agree that tashi may have been a little ambitious with her proposal but Black over Johnson? I don't think so.

Pick 3 for Johnson...

I could give you a stack of expletives, but I'm all for trade talk so I admire your optimism.

Kane Johnson or Heath Black? I wouldn't trade Black for KJ, KJ is probably a better player but Blacky's developing still and quickly becoming a star in the midfield.

Adelaide:
Carey

Kangaroos:
Pick 19 + Moyle + Beethem

St.K:
Johnson

If I was a Roos fan, I probably wouldn't take it, but St.Kilda wouldn't want 'in' on the deal given the unrealistic demands asked by Allen Aylett. This is the most we could offer.

 

[Groucho]

Re: Re: Re: Re: Would you..

Originally posted by evertonfc



Pick 3 for Johnson...

I could give you a stack of expletives, but I'm all for trade talk so I admire your optimism.

Kane Johnson or Heath Black? I wouldn't trade Black for KJ, KJ is probably a better player but Blacky's developing still and quickly becoming a star in the midfield.

Adelaide:
Carey

Kangaroos:
Pick 19 + Moyle + Beethem

St.K:
Johnson

If I was a Roos fan, I probably wouldn't take it, but St.Kilda wouldn't want 'in' on the deal given the unrealistic demands asked by Allen Aylett. This is the most we could offer.

North will at the absolute very least want the Crow's pick 14.Forget Moyle and Beetham,they're ok but North have stated that they want draft picks in the deal so if you can get us 14,19 and maybe another second rounder we'll be getting closer to a deal.

 

[Saint4Life]

id raither the young kid b/cause they are the future of the club