2014 Brownlow discussion thread

[Young Gun #6]

Who got the 2 for dockers game? Fyfe may get the 3

3 to wingard/gray
2 to wingard/gray
1 to fyfe

 

[RobbieGray17]

3 to wingard/gray
2 to wingard/gray
1 to fyfe

3 for wce?

 

[JohnnyFontane90]

Man! like i said. Boak wasnt in that list, why i was questioning it. Before you corrected the missed entry.
I had gray 12-17 prior to gcs +6 last 2 games.

18-23

Not even close to locks. Polec should get the 3 against gws (gray 2) and hartlett the 3 against gc (gray 2 or 1 bennell the other vote getter). His only LOCK for 3 is this weekend, however, has many games were he could've/should get 2.

what you guys think of the port v sydney game a couple weeks ago? i thought gray was clear bog, but others dont have him polling.

 

[RobbieGray17]

what you guys think of the port v sydney game a couple weeks ago? i thought gray was clear bog, but others dont have him polling.

Mglynn will get 3. Gray might get 1. Who knows. Hopefully some surprizes.

 

[Bulldocker]

Luke Parker - 3 more votes today..... just sayin'

 

[Hinkley Effect]

I think i had his def 3s in gws, gcs, carlton with 3 other possibilities

Polec was pretty clearly bog against GWS I thought

 

[FastLane]

Luke Parker - 3 more votes today..... just sayin'

interestring- just looked at stats- have seen a few swans games- very impressed with him-but didnt realise how good his numbers are.
love the bloke- would be a worthy winner

 

[TBellicious]

Cant see Rockliff polling most votes, Brissy hasn't won near enough games.


Also this is off 'AFL Talk' on Facebook, apparently they do votes after every game and this is their tally after Round 21.

 

[Engimal]

Cant see Rockliff polling most votes, Brissy hasn't won near enough games.

View attachment 75695
Also this is off 'AFL Talk' on Facebook, apparently they do votes after every game and this is their tally after Round 21.

Trent Cotchin is a bit higher than I expected...

 

[TBellicious]

No Robbie Gray.... Rough

 

[thetradesman]

I have had a running tally and I have

1. Rockliff on 31 votes
2. Ablett on 29 votes
3. Franklin on 28
4. Selwood on 28
5. Cotchin on 28

 

[eaglesfan99]

I have had a running tally and I have

1. Rockliff on 31 votes
2. Ablett on 29 votes
3. Franklin on 28
4. Selwood on 28
5. Cotchin on 28

You are really biased.

 

[thetradesman]

You are really biased.

How so?

In my tally, it's going to be a log jam going into the last round, with The four I mentioned?

Cotch just did enough to get some early votes, and he has had a brilliant second half to the year.

 

[eaglesfan99]

How so?

In my tally, it's going to be a log jam going into the last round, with The four I mentioned?

Cotch just did enough to get some early votes, and he has had a brilliant second half to the year.

Cotch won't get near 28 votes.

 

[Big Sauce 21]

I'll eat my hat if rocky gets 31

 

[The_Big_Ship]

I have had a running tally and I have

1. Rockliff on 31 votes
2. Ablett on 29 votes
3. Franklin on 28
4. Selwood on 28
5. Cotchin on 28

Can't see anyone polling over 25 votes this year.

 

[SterlingArcher]

I have had a running tally and I have

1. Rockliff on 31 votes
2. Ablett on 29 votes
3. Franklin on 28
4. Selwood on 28
5. Cotchin on 28

Be interested to see your Rocky votes? I think Hanley and Zorko have had their fair share of BOGs in wins..

 

[LicoriceAllsorts]

I'll eat my hat if rocky gets 31

Same, he should be on around 57 atm

 

[The GOAT]

Can't see anyone polling over 25 votes this year.

This. Well ablett could if he is lucky, will be around the 25 mark

 

[Blacky]

Luke Parker - 3 more votes today..... just sayin'

I reckon he will poll late teens

 

[Bulldocker]

I reckon he will poll late teens

Well I got 10/1 odds that he'll top the Swans votes. Working on the theory that umpires see mids most but it's not always the mid that the punter expects that's getting the votes...ie JPK get's overlooked in favour of the the newer kid on the block. Blond, no fuss and a ball magnet that rarely wastes a possession.
Also took 3/1 odds on Sloane to top the Crows votes. I think Danger has had better seasons and spent big periods of play sitting up forward. Sloane is as tough as nails, always midfield and had a shitload of the ball.

 

[Roobs321]

Cant see Rockliff polling most votes, Brissy hasn't won near enough games.

View attachment 75695
Also this is off 'AFL Talk' on Facebook, apparently they do votes after every game and this is their tally after Round 21.

That eerily looks like it could be the real thing, or very close to it (although the absence of Gray is interesting).

 

[Roobs321]

I have had a running tally and I have

1. Rockliff on 31 votes
2. Ablett on 29 votes
3. Franklin on 28
4. Selwood on 28
5. Cotchin on 28

5 guys getting 28+ seems highly unlikely.

 

[Bulldocker]

Franklin and Cotchin will be nowhere near it.

BTW there was also a market I noticed at the TAB for "leader after 5 rounds". I did take some of the 8/1 for Nick Riewoldt because the Saints were winning and all I can recall was that the big fella was on fire. Just remember some commentators noting back then that he had probably already banked 9 votes and possibly more. Just can't remember how Gazza was going in the first few rounds. Anyone got some info there?

 

[Jugada]

Franklin and Cotchin will be nowhere near it.

BTW there was also a market I noticed at the TAB for "leader after 5 rounds". I did take some of the 8/1 for Nick Riewoldt because the Saints were winning and all I can recall was that the big fella was on fire. Just remember some commentators noting back then that he had probably already banked 9 votes and possibly more. Just can't remember how Gazza was going in the first few rounds. Anyone got some info there?

3 BOGs