Discussion 2024 General Discussion / Help

[Chief]

This thread is for Super Coach help.
Go here for general BigFooty help: https://www.bigfooty.com/forum/threads/2024-general-discussion-help.1374536/

 

[Kardinia Boy]

I'm just in the process of trimming my predraft list in preparation for Draft day. Anyone know why injured players aren't flagged in the list like other years?

 

[Geead]

Hi, thought I'd post a thread to see peoples crafty Supercoach Names, I'm working on a Hawthorn themed one, thinking Spaghetti Chol'agnese

 

[Deadly6]

Hi, thought I'd post a thread to see peoples crafty Supercoach Names, I'm working on a Hawthorn themed one, thinking Spaghetti Chol'agnese

Can only have 16 characters including spaces. Perhaps Spag Chol?

 

[Choppers]

I've gone BK River Rats cause it relates to Bueng Kan not far from my hometown of Phon Charoen, and it's on the great Mekong River which is home to plenty of rats, which the locals like to hunt....

 

[Better Loosen Up]

This is just structure:

Who do you currently have at:

D4
M6
R3
F4

Young
McKercher
Naismith
Windsor

 

[54Dogs]

This is just structure:

Who do you currently have at:

D4
M6
R3
F4

Zilliams
Martin
Spud
Billings

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

Zilliams
Martin
Spud
Billings

Will Spud get games? I'd love a playing R3

 

[jdstorm]

Hi, thought I'd post a thread to see peoples crafty Supercoach Names, I'm working on a Hawthorn themed one, thinking Spaghetti Chol'agnese

I’ve Gone with Scott’s Totts

Scott as in Essendon Coach Brad Scott, and Totts referring to it largely being a younger best 22

It’s also an Episode of the Office about mismatched expectations, incompetence and the most bitterly disappointing/hilarious car crash of an episode that just can’t be looked away from.

Feels apt for describing Essendon this season

 

[54Dogs]

Will Spud get games? I'd love a playing R3

A couple of non bye early rounds we'll still need a C loophole

 

[WaynesWorld19]

 

[54Dogs]

If you have a ruck who is listed as a sole Fwd, say Darcy, what do they need to do to get ruck DPP? Is it the reverse of the mids getting fwd DPP so 35% time rucking at CBAs?

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

If you have a ruck who is listed as a sole Fwd, say Darcy, what do they need to do to get ruck DPP? Is it the reverse of the mids getting fwd DPP so 35% time rucking at CBAs?

There has been debate for years here about how exactly the positions are determined, with no official answer I'm aware of.

Positions at CBA's are part, but there is speculation it's also postions at stoppages too.

enobrien Seymour Skinner you guys are good with this stuff, is there an answer?

 

[enobrien]

There has been debate for years here about how exactly the positions are determined, with no official answer I'm aware of.

Positions at CBA's are part, but there is speculation it's also postions at stoppages too.

enobrien Seymour Skinner you guys are good with this stuff, is there an answer?

Yeah its role at stoppage, so would have to be a fairly decent chunk for Darcy to get dpp

Id guess it doesnt happen imo but Dogs supporters probably know more than me.

Are English, Lobb and Darcy all gonna play in the same side?

EDIT: cause if so basically no chance of getting that much ruck time I would've thought

 

[54Dogs]

Yeah its role at stoppage, so would have to be a fairly decent chunk for Darcy to get dpp

Id guess it doesnt happen imo but Dogs supporters probably know more than me.

Are English, Lobb and Darcy all gonna play in the same side?

EDIT: cause if so basically no chance of getting that much ruck time I would've thought

Unlikely if English stands up, but if he goes down for an extended period it prob would happen

 

[Choppers]

Does anyone know if the AFL Tribunal members get paid by the hour.......they've been deliberating for over 1 hour if the suspension should be 3 weeks or 4.....1 hour!
The sitting also began nearly 3 hrs ago....

 

[rocker_oz33]

Does anyone know if the AFL Tribunal members get paid by the hour.......they've been deliberating for over 1 hour if the suspension should be 3 weeks or 4.....1 hour!
The sitting also began nearly 3 hrs ago....

No worse the the government or road workers ..

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Does anyone know if the AFL Tribunal members get paid by the hour.......they've been deliberating for over 1 hour if the suspension should be 3 weeks or 4.....1 hour!
The sitting also began nearly 3 hrs ago....

SPP also pleaded guilty ....imagine if he pleaded not guilty

 

[WaynesWorld19]

Just an issue that sticks in my claw .....the methodology of goal umpires used to be, to get right behind the flight of the ball .....nowdays though, they stand next to the goal post and try and adjudicate a goal/point on the opposite goal post .....impossible

Also noticed last night, David Rodan

David Rodan

Age

40

Ht

173cm

Wt

87kg

Pos.

Mid

Career

Season

Last 5

D

14.1

4star

K

7.1

3star

HB

7.0

4star

M

2.2

2star

T

3.1

5star

CL

3.9

5star

No current season stats available

D

8.6

3star

K

6.0

3star

HB

2.6

3star

M

2.0

3star

T

1.0

3star

standing inside goal post to adjudicate a ball crossing the line, all good .....but last week a female goal umpire stood behind the goal post (point post side) ...and peaked around the goal post to adjudicate

Females obviously being trained differently, for self protection .....in fact all goal umpires being coached, not for the best adjudication, but self protection 1st, decision correctness 2nd

Sp endeth the rant

 

[TempletonTheRat]

Just an issue that sticks in my claw .....the methodology of goal umpires used to be, to get right behind the flight of the ball .....nowdays though, they stand next to the goal post and try and adjudicate a goal/point on the opposite goal post .....impossible

Also noticed last night, David Rodan standing inside goal post to adjudicate a ball crossing the line, all good .....but last week a female goal umpire stood behind the goal post (point post side) ...and peaked around the goal post to adjudicate

Females obviously being trained differently, for self protection .....in fact all goal umpires being coached, not for the best adjudication, but self protection 1st, decision correctness 2nd

Sp endeth the rant

and here is why

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

 

[WaynesWorld19]

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

View attachment 1919087

With 40 trades it may just mean concussion = trade now.

 

[Sherman41]

With 40 trades it may just mean concussion = trade now.

An early in game concussion plus a potential trade, could be brutal if it happens several times a year. Which in the current climate is understandably becoming more likely.

 

[Maybe Tomorrow]

An early in game concussion plus a potential trade, could be brutal if it happens several times a year. Which in the current climate is understandably becoming more likely.

Injury luck has always been part of SC, even more now.

 

[rocker_oz33]

Wow , the Webster family don't much between the ears ..