Player X vs Y vs Z - 2016

[CotchyPls]

Jpk and pendles v hanners and shiel think I know the obvious answer

Pendles & Shiel

Jpk v priddis v beams v mundy v hanners

Beams

Barlow and Rocky vs. Wines and Bennell/Dahlhaus?

Barlow & Rocky

 

[stevebbb]

Barlow and Rocky vs. Wines and Bennell/Dahlhaus?

Barlow and Rocky

 

[Super Hans]

That was Brian Speaking.

I get your point though.

Oh God. That bloke talks more s**t than anyone on this site. He said 100% we wouldn't get Boyd and if we tried to St Kilda would offer pick one and get him. Complete flog.

 

[Super Hans]

Jpk v priddis v beams v mundy v hanners

Beams.

Neale vs Tom Mitchell.

 

[Unique Name]

Beams.

Neale vs Tom Mitchell.

Both solid options - I've had both at some point.

But I would choose Neale because the only role he will play is as an inside mid whereas Mitchell was used in a run with role once or twice last season and more likely to be rotated out of the guts throughout a game due to the Swans stacked inside mid brigade.

 

[Mitchell54]

R.Bonner(Port), M.Brown(WCE), M.Hibberd(North), C.Smith(Carl)
Which 2?

 

[Mitchell54]

Jpk and pendles v hanners and shiel think I know the obvious answer

JPK and Pendles

 

[Tang]

R.Bonner(Port), M.Brown(WCE), M.Hibberd(North), C.Smith(Carl)
Which 2?

Too tough to say at the moment. Nab will reveal.

I have bonner and hibberd in my team though

 

[Mitchell54]

Too tough to say at the moment. Nab will reveal.

I have bonner and hibberd in my team though

They're the 2 i have atm but some people have taken a liking to M.Brown(WCE) and Clem Smith might get games this year in with Yarrans and Menzel gone.

 

[Winsto]

R.Bonner(Port), M.Brown(WCE), M.Hibberd(North), C.Smith(Carl)
Which 2?

I don't think Brown will be best 22. And even if he is, his previous scoring has been pretty average. Will keep an eye on him during NAB though...

 

[scooter30]

They're the 2 i have atm but some people have taken a liking to M.Brown(WCE) and Clem Smith might get games this year in with Yarrans and Menzel gone.

I wouldn't be surprised if eagles go with three tall defenders McKenzie brown and schofield and three attacking defenders hurn Sheppard and wellingham thus allowing McGovern and yeo too be freed up so I expect brown too be a solid pick early on

 

[croweyrocks]

R.Bonner(Port), M.Brown(WCE), M.Hibberd(North), C.Smith(Carl)
Which 2?

Can't see Bonner playing early on... He's a bit down in the depth charts for mid sized half backs- Pittard, Krakouer, Broadbent, O'Shea, Jonas, Clurey are ahead of him and not all those are best 22 IMO.

 

[Mitchell54]

Sorry. i got another question that will be hard to answer at this stage.

Clem Smith, Ahern, Shane Yarran.
Which 2?

 

[MightyMark]

Sorry. i got another question that will be hard to answer at this stage.

Clem Smith, Ahern, Shane Yarran.
Which 2?

Smith and Ahern, simply because they are the first 2 you listed. About as good as any strategy for picking rookies at this stage.

 

[Hans Lutzman]

Hartung vs Libba
Litherland vs Weitering

 

[NinjaSwan]

Hartung vs Libba
Litherland vs Weitering

Libba easily, and neither.

 

[pill]

Goldy, wines, m. williams vs Martin, jpk, laird. Thanks

 

[kane22]

2

Goldy, wines, m. williams vs Martin, jpk, laird. Thanks

2nd option easily!
Deledio vs chopsticks only got room for one

 

[Dark Sharks]

Now for a question which isn't completely obvious.

"N.Fyfe vs N.Vanberlo + 100k??"

Cripps or Wines?

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Now for a question which isn't completely obvious.

"N.Fyfe vs N.Vanberlo + 100k??"

Cripps or Wines?

That 100k will go along way.

Wines for me.

 

[FAILTOSUCCEED]

R.Bonner(Port), M.Brown(WCE), M.Hibberd(North), C.Smith(Carl)
Which 2?

Brown & Hibberd possibly.

Don't like Smith at all, and Bonner has stack of competition for spot.

 

[King_Steele]

Laird/123k rookie
Vs
Smith/200k rookie

 

[joop]

Oh God. That bloke talks more s**t than anyone on this site. He said 100% we wouldn't get Boyd and if we tried to St Kilda would offer pick one and get him. Complete flog.

Treated like a god on the saints board.

 

[joop]

Goldy, wines, m. williams vs Martin, jpk, laird. Thanks

2nd option.

 

[Here2tellyouwhy]

Laird/123k rookie
Vs
Smith/200k rookie

Depends on the rookie