2012 'Which rookie do I start on the field?' thread

[Seppo]

Had to make a call between Coniglio and Shiel for the last Mid spot and got the girlfriend to flip a coin for who starts on the field.

Shiel won and if he gets subbed or a s*** score i can blame not only my missus but the coin as well...

Not looking good for the coin toss decision... Currently its Coniglio 46 VS Shiel 13

 

[Satan]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Played shiel and not cognilo , milera and not adams , at least both reserves go up in value

 

[V_23]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

Switched Ellis on the field over Morris 30 minutes before lockout...fml

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Re: 2012 Which rookie do i start on the field thread

How was I to know Ellis would be sub?

He's clearly the least of Hardwicks favs

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

Toss a coin for the first lot.

I'd go Adams...just. But he's played 3 and is near certain for sub/rest

I'd be careful with him

 

[footyfan_25]

Who to start this week:

Coniglio (vs Lions) or Horsley (vs Dogs)

Leaning towards Coniglio.

 

[Satan]

spurr or smedts (in for scarlo)?

dont know subs yet tonight

stringer is, and buckley

 

[TheBuzz]

spurr or smedts (in for scarlo)?

dont know subs yet tonight

stringer is, and buckley

Stringer sub, Smedts late in 4 Scarlett.

Now not sure if to play Smedts or Geary. HELP!!!

 

[GOAUS!]

That little moment of win when you were going to cop a donut and Smedts comes in, YESSS.

 

[BuddysBuddy23]

Who to start between Milera and treloar?

 

[G-Mo77]

spurr or smedts (in for scarlo)?

I'm starting Smedts only because I know he won't be sub. Would like to know others opinions on it before lockout.

 

[OneEyedHawk]

Morris vs Ellis vs Spurr for D7?

And who of the other 2 should I put the E on?

 

[Super Hans]

Morris vs Ellis vs Spurr for D7?

And who of the other 2 should I put the E on?

I went Smedts after Ellis being there all week, let's hope it pays off!!

 

[Satan]

I went Smedts after Ellis being there all week, let's hope it pays off!!

17 and not at the moment

played spurr

 

[IDIG]

I'm starting Smedts only because I know he won't be sub. Would like to know others opinions on it before lockout.

Ouch, not green but red which is impossible to predict


I've gone with the following setup which would be pretty standard i think?
Morris, Mohr (Delaney*, Ellis)
Treloar (Milera)

In hindsight maybe Delaney was a better option thatn Mohr.

 

[footyfan_25]

Who to start:

Zorko/Adams/Smith/Pfieffer

Smith least likely to be the sub I would say out of that lot. Adams due for a vest (or expect a "rest" next week) and Zorko who knows.

Thoughts?

 

[Jessbek]

Magner v Zorko?

 

[hawka187]

Pfeiffer (GCS) + Milera (SYD) + Treloar (ESS) who should be on the bench?

 

[toxic]

Pfeiffer (GCS) + Milera (SYD) + Treloar (ESS) who should be on the bench?

had a very similar issue and malaria to the bench (might be the sub this week i think)

 

[Propagandhi]

I need to play two of...

Zorko, D. Smith, Treloar, T. Adams, Dickson

Thinking Zorko and D. Smith

 

[SHAKESPEARE]

I need to play two of...

Zorko, D. Smith, Treloar, T. Adams, Dickson

Thinking Zorko and D. Smith

Treloar, Adams, Smith, Zorko, Dickson. That order

 

[Adz]

Cameron v Hampton V Saad?!

 

[nabmeg]

ellis vs spurr?
kennedy(gws) vs milera?

yet to make a trade this round as well

 

[Adz]

ellis vs spurr?
kennedy(gws) vs milera?

yet to make a trade this round as well

Ellis likely to start sub and will be wet game.

 

[footyfan_25]

I need to play two of...

Zorko, D. Smith, Treloar, T. Adams, Dickson

Thinking Zorko and D. Smith

Treloar, Adams, Smith, Zorko, Dickson. That order

Adams and Zorko more of a chance to get a vest.

Smith probably safest option to play a full game