Determinant
Moderator
- Jan 9, 2012
- 7,454
- 6,807
- AFL Club
- GWS
- Other Teams
- St Kilda
- Moderator
- #901
Gee I hope we are only rumoured..
Follow along with the video below to see how to install our site as a web app on your home screen.
Note: This feature may not be available in some browsers.
Gee I hope we are only rumoured..
Gee I hope we are only rumoured..
Personally I think he will be at least as good as Lachie Henderson at the same age
Sorry to intrude guys and I'm not sure if this has been covered would like to know what Buntine would be worth in a straight swap
Interesting question. Last year I would have said Horlin-Smith but the Hyphen has cracked the big time this year and it would have to be Buntine + something more than steak knives to equal his worth.
There's not a lot, to be honest, that would be a straight swap. Why is Taylor Hunt on the outer? Was very good for a while and improving all the time, but has only played 7 this season. I'd maybe look at that depending on the answer.
Jed Bews? Father son so I doubt it. Also haven't seen enough of him, but have liked what I have seen.
What's the story with Schroder? - won the Liston but has only played 5 games and none this year. He'd probably be the only other one I'd talk about - again depending on the answers as to why he can't get a game at the Cats and what his VFL form is like.
Anyone else and the equation is imbalanced one way or the other.
Interesting question. Last year I would have said Horlin-Smith but the Hyphen has cracked the big time this year and it would have to be Buntine + something more than steak knives to equal his worth.
There's not a lot, to be honest, that would be a straight swap. Why is Taylor Hunt on the outer? Was very good for a while and improving all the time, but has only played 7 this season. I'd maybe look at that depending on the answer.
Jed Bews? Father son so I doubt it. Also haven't seen enough of him, but have liked what I have seen.
What's the story with Schroder? - won the Liston but has only played 5 games and none this year. He'd probably be the only other one I'd talk about - again depending on the answers as to why he can't get a game at the Cats and what his VFL form is like.
Anyone else and the equation is imbalanced one way or the other.
I'm thinking Jaksch & Sumner for pick 6.What kind of player do you guys think SOS and Cameron will target? A lot of talk being bandied around about Jaksch or Boyd being targeted (heavily) by the Blues... what kind of player (save for the obvious and ungettable Gibbs, Murph, Kreuz etc) would GWS take/want in a deal?
Names that may be offered/considered in a deal (from Carlton's view):
Andrew Walker
Jeffy Garlett
Robbie Warnock
Kane Lucas
Mitch Robinson
Brock McLean
Whether GWS even pick up the phone is another question all together, and it would seem most likely that any deal involving Boyd would need our first (~6) for it be considered.
NORM Smith medallist Ryan O’Keefe has revealed his desire to continue his AFL career at another club next year.
The Sydney Swans veteran, an unrestricted free agent at season’s end, has played just four games this year after being dropped in round four.
O’Keefe’s management confirmed to The Footy Show the dual premiership player was set to look elsewhere for 2015.
“Ryan will be exercising his right as a free agent. His body is sound, he loves footy and he's not ready to hang up the boots,” Darian Lobb of MVP Management said. “He wants the opportunity to play at another club.”
just too old i think. IMO if we chase an established body in the midfield they need to be someone that can hold up a three yr contract minimum and be around when the team is playing finals rather than a one- two yr appearance before retirement
But fourth year players are different to second and third year players... And those senior bodies on one yr contracts have been backmen like hunt.Well OKeefe suits recent drafting Giants have done. Age means experience.
Based on what?Gee I hope we are only rumoured..
Interesting question. Last year I would have said Horlin-Smith but the Hyphen has cracked the big time this year and it would have to be Buntine + something more than steak knives to equal his worth.
There's not a lot, to be honest, that would be a straight swap. Why is Taylor Hunt on the outer? Was very good for a while and improving all the time, but has only played 7 this season. I'd maybe look at that depending on the answer.
Jed Bews? Father son so I doubt it. Also haven't seen enough of him, but have liked what I have seen.
What's the story with Schroder? - won the Liston but has only played 5 games and none this year. He'd probably be the only other one I'd talk about - again depending on the answers as to why he can't get a game at the Cats and what his VFL form is like.
Anyone else and the equation is imbalanced one way or the other.
Based on his health record.Based on what?
Higgins as a player?
Or just wanting to keep list spots open for kids?
I think your club is still very interested in spreading the age profile of your list like it or not.
Higgins is a very good player, don't believe the bf misconceptions.
Doubt he'll be at the Giants next year anyway so rest easy.
Hoping we are past being fossil's pension fund.Even though he's apparently lost some pace, I think his professionalism and experience would be a valuable addition. Play him as a small forward to provide the young players the benefits of an experienced head.
He did look to move to Victoria a few years ago so he's probably more likely to end up down there.
Yeah there is that.Based on his health record.
No doubting his potential, but I see him as an unnecessary risk for us.