2016 Rate My Team
- Thread starter FlowersByIrene
- Start date
- Tagged users None
- Sep 7, 2009
- 5,898
- 5,992
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
- Other Teams
- Real Madrid, Man City, GS Warriors
First team of season 2015. HERE IT ISSSSSSSSSS!
Really only interested in winning my league comp not overall that much
Haven't really given it much notice, my pre season starts when i buy my prospectus
but here is my first team for the year, done in probably 1hr
Haven't really given it much notice, my pre season starts when i buy my prospectus
but here is my first team for the year, done in probably 1hr
- Thread starter
- #30
Is anyone going Wells?
magpiearmy19
Draftee
- Feb 3, 2016
- 5
- 1
- AFL Club
- Collingwood
Thoughts are really appreciated on this one, I'm not too sure how I feel about the team at this stage.
Def: K. Kolodjashnij, D. Rich, B. Smith, Aish, M. Hartley, K. Collins (Byrne, Broad)
Mid: Pendlebury, Dangerfield, Rockliff, B. Ellis, B. Crouch, Parish, Hopper, B. Kennedy (R. Davis, Jansen)
Ruck: S. Martin, Lobbe (Currie, Cox)
Fwd: D. Martin, Dahlhaus, Motlop, Greene, Kerridge, Cockatoo (Kommer, Ahern)
I have 30k left at this stage.
Def: K. Kolodjashnij, D. Rich, B. Smith, Aish, M. Hartley, K. Collins (Byrne, Broad)
Mid: Pendlebury, Dangerfield, Rockliff, B. Ellis, B. Crouch, Parish, Hopper, B. Kennedy (R. Davis, Jansen)
Ruck: S. Martin, Lobbe (Currie, Cox)
Fwd: D. Martin, Dahlhaus, Motlop, Greene, Kerridge, Cockatoo (Kommer, Ahern)
I have 30k left at this stage.
- Thread starter
- #32
Rich surely on the never again list after last season (or the season before?)
What makes Dangerfield appealing?
Like the Brandon Ellis call
Hopper will be a wait and see on time on ground stats and role, could be a big waste if he isn't a lock and playing midfield.
on my never again list FBI... too many risk factors...dodgy body + age
I actually don't mind the selection of Rich now, he is lesser known to the taggers these days, providing he rotates through the midfield I think he can up his scoring.
Watch his role and his PPM in the NAB though..
Too overpriced IMO. Better options for 60k cheaper.
Dangerfield is at the peak of his powers...will the cats just give it to him? if so then that's appealing.
And the players around him. Jelwood, Motlop, Duncan etc. He has so much upside. Great POD
- Thread starter
- #38
Nah not a fan of Danger, can never trust him.
every Crows fan agrees with you!
James LeBron
Senior List
- Feb 20, 2015
- 163
- 18
- AFL Club
- Sydney
Thoughts on my team so far?
Def: Shaw - Bartel - Duryea - Seedsman - Aish - Hibberd (Byrne - Hartley)
Mid: Ablett - Rockliff - Ward - O'Meara - B.Crouch - Polec - J.Anderson - Freeman (Gore - Sumner)
Ruck: Lobbe - Mumford (Currie - Cox)
Fwd: Barlow - Greene - Martin - Bird - Hrovat - Petrecca (Kommer - Lowden)
I also have 60k stashed away in the bank, Thanks
Def: Shaw - Bartel - Duryea - Seedsman - Aish - Hibberd (Byrne - Hartley)
Mid: Ablett - Rockliff - Ward - O'Meara - B.Crouch - Polec - J.Anderson - Freeman (Gore - Sumner)
Ruck: Lobbe - Mumford (Currie - Cox)
Fwd: Barlow - Greene - Martin - Bird - Hrovat - Petrecca (Kommer - Lowden)
I also have 60k stashed away in the bank, Thanks
- Thread starter
- #41
Looks good with a couple of very unique option. Personally i'm very much on the hypercharged Ruck Division train and think you will struggle without at least one of Martin or Goldy
- Jun 1, 2010
- 10,148
- 8,135
- AFL Club
- St Kilda
I doubt Freeman will play much in the first half of this season, club will be very patient with him.
It'll be a struggle to trust him, but if Rocky and Hanley can stay on the park it might help him a bit.
I hope that is a auto pick team
Some interesting left field selections there that I hadn't even contemplated like Duryea, Ward and Hrovat.
Not a big fan of Duryea as I think when the Hawks share it around as they do across HB and the wings, he seems to be not always included in that and doesn't get as much free pill as some others.
Ward is a no for mine as I think the younger mids from GWS will start to step up and take more load off him, the likes of of Sheil, Smith, Cogs, Greene etc, plus they will want to be playing Kelly and Steele in there sometimes too.
My team currently;
Def: Shaw, Laird, Yeo, Rosa, Fantasia, Hibberd (Hartley, Brown)
Mid: Ablett, Rocky, Parker, Sheil, Libba, Townsend, Anderson, Francis (Ahern, Jansen)
Rucks: Lobbe, Luey (Gorringe, Currie)
Fwd: Dusty, Z. Merrett, Buddy, Bird, Duggan, Yarren (Lamb, Kommer)
$90k in the bank
Those bolded I'm 80% on at the moment, can trade Francis, Goringe and Lamb in for rookie price players if they pop up and have another $240K to play with, maybe do that and trade Lobbe for Goldy, but currently think Lobbe will do well in the first 4-5 rounds and rise by $50k and Goldy will drop by about the same.
Back yourself in lad, if you trust your decisions, take them into the NAB Cup buddy.
But one thing, you need Ablett and Rocky
First attempt at 2016 team for If the Shuey fits (no doubt it will change) - $119,00 left over
BACKS: Boyd, Laird. Simpson, Salem, M. Brown (ESS), Adams (Josh Wagner, Broad)
MIDFIELDERS: Ablett, Rockliff, Parker, Patrick Cripps, Hopper, Petracca, David Cunningham, Gore (Mathieson, Tom Phillips)
RUCKS: Stefan Martin, Leuenberger (Loersch, Korcheck)
FORWARDS: Dustin Martin, Dahlhaus, Wingard, Shane Edwards, Laverde, Kerridge (Fitzpatrick, Kommer)
BACKS: Boyd, Laird. Simpson, Salem, M. Brown (ESS), Adams (Josh Wagner, Broad)
MIDFIELDERS: Ablett, Rockliff, Parker, Patrick Cripps, Hopper, Petracca, David Cunningham, Gore (Mathieson, Tom Phillips)
RUCKS: Stefan Martin, Leuenberger (Loersch, Korcheck)
FORWARDS: Dustin Martin, Dahlhaus, Wingard, Shane Edwards, Laverde, Kerridge (Fitzpatrick, Kommer)
doona
SMFC
defence: I think your defence is a little week. Salem+Brown+Adams starting I would think would leak a lot of points early in the season. Personally upgrading salem to a KK/Yeo/premo would make it look stronger with your left over cash.
mids: Maybe 1/2 many rookies starting and I wouldn't pick Parker. He is my favourite player (He was my first chosen last year) but he has had some leg issues and is being managed over the pre-season (on going issues that can only be managed). I have a feeling he wont have a lot of midfield time early season. He is one to look out for in the NAB cup.
Rucks: in my opinion Martin is a lock and leuy is a risk some will take. Good set up.
Strong and different forward line. I reckon Dahl/Wingard/Edwards will all be unique. Maybe you can get some cash by downgrading kerridge to strengthen your mids.
