2023 Ladder Predictor

[Munich]

Our task has been complicated by the probable loss of Stanley and Rohan........

I'm so sick of having a paper thin ruckman.

 

[Cataholic]

I'm so sick of having a paper thin ruckman.

Our list of players who've been uninjured this year seems just as paper thin too......

 

[Reg Hickey]

Yes, although extremely unlikely:

• GWS and Essendon draw
• Swans d Crows
• Eagles d Bulldogs

In other words, realistically, no.

 

[cats_09]

Our list of players who've been uninjured this year's seems just as paper thin too......

Am I right in thinking the only players who haven't been injured or required the managed treatment during the season (including VFL) are:

• Tom Atkins
• Ted Clohsey
• Brad Close
• Ollie Dempsey
• Zach Guthrie
• Mitch Knevitt
• Gryan Miers
• Cooper Whyte

Could maybe add Isaac Smith to that list, but he was managed for a match, while O'Connor missed 1 match with an "adductor" injury which may have been more of a rotation but was listed as out injured

 

[Pure_Ownage]

True that.
They are 6 points up on us, that is their advantage.
Catch us and beat us if you can.

Yes but their last game is much harder than ours and its interstate.

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Yep, Lions will be keen to finish #2 at worst for that home final

Exactly and the lions are terrible away so they need 2 home finals so i cant see them letting up against the saints.

One thing in our favour is that we beat Doggies at Marvel, who are probably a better team than Saints?

Yep 100 % and we beat the dogs without danger too we need a huge game from him sat night. I also think we play SS really well to get a team like the dogs.

 

[CHAWKTS]

Am I right in thinking the only players who haven't been injured or required the managed treatment during the season (including VFL) are:

• Tom Atkins
• Ted Clohsey
• Brad Close
• Ollie Dempsey
• Mitch Knevitt
• Gryan Miers
• Brandon Parfitt (?)
• Cooper Whyte

Could maybe add Isaac Smith to that list, but he was managed for a match, while O'Connor missed 1 match with an "adductor" injury which may have been more of a rotation but was listed as out injured

Parfitt missed some with injury (hand I think)

But yes I can’t think of anyone else who has not had treatment.

If you look at the list above 4 of 7 have played less than 10 (non sub) AFL games between them. the other three are very important players so good to have them available (and probably helped to keep Dempsey and Knevitt out given roles)

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Our task has been complicated by the probable loss of Stanley and Rohan........

Stanley will play i think.

And we can cover rohan the form ollie h is in especially if hawk is back.

 

[Play it Sam]

Am I right in thinking the only players who haven't been injured or required the managed treatment during the season (including VFL) are:

• Tom Atkins
• Ted Clohsey
• Brad Close
• Ollie Dempsey
• Mitch Knevitt
• Gryan Miers
• Brandon Parfitt (?)
• Cooper Whyte

Could maybe add Isaac Smith to that list, but he was managed for a match, while O'Connor missed 1 match with an "adductor" injury which may have been more of a rotation but was listed as out injured

Ohhh, block my ears....You're not Irish like me, are you? ++++ #4clover#wood

 

[Vdubs]

Parfitt missed some with injury (hand I think)

But yes I can’t think of anyone else who has not had treatment.

If you look at the list above 4 of 7 have played less than 10 (non sub) AFL games between them. the other three are very important players so good to have them available (and probably helped to keep Dempsey and Knevitt out given roles)

Yes, Parf missed a couple with a hand injury again.

 

[cats_09]

Parfitt missed some with injury (hand I think)

But yes I can’t think of anyone else who has not had treatment.

If you look at the list above 4 of 7 have played less than 10 (non sub) AFL games between them. the other three are very important players so good to have them available (and probably helped to keep Dempsey and Knevitt out given roles)

Cheers on Parfitt - that’s why I added the question mark as I knew he had been in & out of the seniors, but thought something had happened at some stage during the year which impact his VFL continuity

 

[Pure_Ownage]

Grand final rematch anyone...

View attachment 1773411

Given how people were upset that we went conservative in last 2 mins vs swans would be ironic if a) that 2 pts gets us in finals vs 9th and b) gets us a home final against the swans.

 

[Chinacats]

Did the ladder predictor for the first time.. not sure why people do it in May or June but with two games to go I decided to do it.
Cats finish 6th and play crows in first week… could be GMHBA final? Doubt it…
Cats vs saints winner will make the 8 I think with obvious permutations in other fixtures, so still need results to go our way…

 

[Mr Meow]

Did the ladder predictor for the first time.. not sure why people do it in May or June but with two games to go I decided to do it.
Cats finish 6th and play crows in first week… could be GMHBA final? Doubt it…
Cats vs saints winner will make the 8 I think with obvious permutations in other fixtures, so still need results to go our way…

The consensus view over the past two months of ladder predictions has been finishing around 6th.

Win the two games we're favourites in and it will turn out most people were on the money.

 

[you pick one]

Am I right in thinking the only players who haven't been injured or required the managed treatment during the season (including VFL) are:

• Tom Atkins
• Ted Clohsey
• Brad Close
• Ollie Dempsey
• Mitch Knevitt
• Gryan Miers
• Brandon Parfitt (?)
• Cooper Whyte

Could maybe add Isaac Smith to that list, but he was managed for a match, while O'Connor missed 1 match with an "adductor" injury which may have been more of a rotation but was listed as out injured

How about my boy Zuthrie?

 

[Mr Meow]

Given how people were upset that we went conservative in last 2 mins vs swans would be ironic if a) that 2 pts gets us in finals vs 9th and b) gets us a home final against the swans.

Duncan made the right choice because Sydney were surging.

On Friday in the last quarter we were the ones swarming the opposition so aggressive ball movement made more sense. Outside of a few costly moments, that's what we did.

Horses for courses.

 

[Vdubs]

How about my boy Zuthrie?

And my boy OLIIE HENRY?

 

[cats_09]

And my boy OLIIE HENRY?

Except Ollie was injured, with a rather sensitive ouchie...

 

[cats_09]

How about my boy Zuthrie?

*

How did I forget Zach - I think I got to the Guthrie brothers, I looked at my list, saw no Atkins and went to add him and then skipped over the younger brother

I'll edit my list

 

[BigVic]

		W	L	D	%
1.	Collingwood	18	5	0	124.0%
2.	Brisbane Lions	17	6	0	122.9%
3.	Port Adelaide	16	7	0	109.5%
4.	Melbourne	15	8	0	120.8%
5.	Carlton	14	8	1	116.9%
6.	Geelong	12	10	1	120.0%
7.	Sydney	12	10	1	112.2%
8.	Western Bulldogs	12	11	0	111.4%
9.	St Kilda	12	11	0	102.2%
10.	GWS	12	11	0	98.5%
11.	Richmond	11	11	1	96.7%
12.	Adelaide	11	12	0	117.2%
13.	Essendon	11	12	0	98.2%
14.	Gold Coast	10	13	0	94.3%
15.	Fremantle	9	14	0	93.2%
16.	Hawthorn	9	14	0	85.6%
17.	North Melbourne	2	21	0	68.9%
18.	West Coast	2	21	0	49.3%

QF1: Collingwood v MELBOURNE
QF2: BRISBANE LIONS v Port Adelaide
EF1: Carlton v WESTERN BULLDOGS
EF2: GEELONG v Sydney

SF1: COLLINGWOOD v Western Bulldogs
SF2: Port Adelaide v GEELONG

PF1: Melbourne v GEELONG
PF2: BRISBANE LIONS v Collingwood

GF: GEELONG v Brisbane Lions

Best chance for you guys. I have the Cats easily encountering for St Kilda and the Bulldogs en-route to 6th and a home final vs Sydney.

 

[Vdubs]

		W	L	D	%
1.	Collingwood	18	5	0	124.0%
2.	Brisbane Lions	17	6	0	122.9%
3.	Port Adelaide	16	7	0	109.5%
4.	Melbourne	15	8	0	120.8%
5.	Carlton	14	8	1	116.9%
6.	Geelong	12	10	1	120.0%
7.	Sydney	12	10	1	112.2%
8.	Western Bulldogs	12	11	0	111.4%
9.	St Kilda	12	11	0	102.2%
10.	GWS	12	11	0	98.5%
11.	Richmond	11	11	1	96.7%
12.	Adelaide	11	12	0	117.2%
13.	Essendon	11	12	0	98.2%
14.	Gold Coast	10	13	0	94.3%
15.	Fremantle	9	14	0	93.2%
16.	Hawthorn	9	14	0	85.6%
17.	North Melbourne	2	21	0	68.9%
18.	West Coast	2	21	0	49.3%

QF1: Collingwood v MELBOURNE
QF2: BRISBANE LIONS v Port Adelaide
EF1: Carlton v WESTERN BULLDOGS
EF2: GEELONG v Sydney

SF1: COLLINGWOOD v Western Bulldogs
SF2: Port Adelaide v GEELONG

PF1: Melbourne v GEELONG
PF2: BRISBANE LIONS v Collingwood

GF: GEELONG v Brisbane Lions

Best chance for you guys. I have the Cats easily encountering for St Kilda and the Bulldogs en-route to 6th and a home final vs Sydney.

Whatever you're on, sounds too good to be true, unless you're just stating best possible outcomes for Geelong

 

[Cataholic]

Whatever you're on, sounds too good to be true, unless you're just stating best possible outcomes for Geelong

I think that was the premise of the post - best possible outcome.

 

[Pollywaffle]

I'm so sick of having a paper thin ruckman.

I reckon Stanley is pretty thick

 

[Turbocat]

Done the predictor ..and really we could land in about 6 different spots depending on results

 

[Munich]

		W	L	D	%
1.	Collingwood	18	5	0	124.0%
2.	Brisbane Lions	17	6	0	122.9%
3.	Port Adelaide	16	7	0	109.5%
4.	Melbourne	15	8	0	120.8%
5.	Carlton	14	8	1	116.9%
6.	Geelong	12	10	1	120.0%
7.	Sydney	12	10	1	112.2%
8.	Western Bulldogs	12	11	0	111.4%
9.	St Kilda	12	11	0	102.2%
10.	GWS	12	11	0	98.5%
11.	Richmond	11	11	1	96.7%
12.	Adelaide	11	12	0	117.2%
13.	Essendon	11	12	0	98.2%
14.	Gold Coast	10	13	0	94.3%
15.	Fremantle	9	14	0	93.2%
16.	Hawthorn	9	14	0	85.6%
17.	North Melbourne	2	21	0	68.9%
18.	West Coast	2	21	0	49.3%

QF1: Collingwood v MELBOURNE
QF2: BRISBANE LIONS v Port Adelaide
EF1: Carlton v WESTERN BULLDOGS
EF2: GEELONG v Sydney

SF1: COLLINGWOOD v Western Bulldogs
SF2: Port Adelaide v GEELONG

PF1: Melbourne v GEELONG
PF2: BRISBANE LIONS v Collingwood

GF: GEELONG v Brisbane Lions

Best chance for you guys. I have the Cats easily encountering for St Kilda and the Bulldogs en-route to 6th and a home final vs Sydney.

Playing in Adelaide isn't our best chance we'd do better in Brissy.