Traded #22: Jake Carlisle - Pt.1 - Traded with some other stuff for pick 5, 24 and a Bird (cont in Part 2)

[eth-dog]

just a question- Why do Dons fans think Billings wants to go there? I'm not being a smart ass, im genuinely curious. Did he support them growing up or are there rumours they are a club he wants to go to or something?

Taking the piss from a SEN bullshit report about demanding him before Dodoro and Bains had met regarding Carlisle.

 

[Mercuri Rising]

just a question- Why do Dons fans think Billings wants to go there? I'm not being a smart ass, im genuinely curious. Did he support them growing up or are there rumours they are a club he wants to go to or something?

the amount of people genuinely suggesting Billings, as opposed to those taking the piss, is vanishingly small.

 

[Despair]

just a question- Why do Dons fans think Billings wants to go there? I'm not being a smart ass, im genuinely curious. Did he support them growing up or are there rumours they are a club he wants to go to or something?

Because our club is not going to be dead in 10 years from continuous financial failings

 

[Howard Moon]

Everyone can say he's worth a first rounder and he is but the first round is a wide amount. Difference between 1 and 18 is light years.

 

[DapperDon]

The Goddard poach is going to cone back, isn't it.

They had the opportunity to match

 

[DapperDon]

Everyone can say he's worth a first rounder and he is but the first round is a wide amount. Difference between 1 and 18 is light years.

The perfect trade is the 3 way with Collingwood

We give Carlisle and 23
Saints give 5
Pies give Freeman

everyone wins

 

[Mercuri Rising]

also because we're hard to deal with

 

[jwint43]

Because our club is not going to be dead in 10 years from continuous financial failings

Your name fits your outlook on things

 

[BomberTime]

He will be traded for pick 5. No doubt.

St Kilda fans saying he is worth a second round pick (which is more than we originally got him for, plus years of development) are kidding themselves.

This is all posturing.

 

[Runk]

They had the opportunity to match

This.

They kept their $$$ in their wallet and let him walk. They kept it for this exact scenario.

Nicky Dal the same? Not sure?

 

[Rack Watts]

"I love the boys"

 

[eth-dog]

The perfect trade is the 3 way with Collingwood

We give Carlisle and 23
Saints give 5
Pies give Freeman

everyone wins

Or the 4 way with Collingwood and Melbourne:


Collingwood lose: Nathan Freeman
Collingwood gain: Pick 25

Essendon lose: Jake Carlisle + Jake Melksham
Essendon gain: Pick 5

Melbourne lose: Pick 25
Melbourne gain: Jake Melksham

St. Kilda lose: Pick 5
St. Kilda gain: Nathan Freeman + Jake Carlisle

We don't give up 23 this way.

 

[DapperDon]

Your name fits your outlook on things

So does yours

 

[efcboy]

He will be traded for pick 5. No doubt.

St Kilda fans saying he is worth a second round pick (which is more than we originally got him for, plus years of development) are kidding themselves.

This is all posturing.

And a waste of everybody's time which won't reflect greatly for the saints and in particular ameet. More professional managers just get it done quickly when a logical deal is right before your eyes.

 

[Runk]

Or the 4 way with Collingwood and Melbourne:


Collingwood lose: Nathan Freeman
Collingwood gain: Pick 25

Essendon lose: Jake Carlisle + Jake Melksham
Essendon gain: Pick 5

Melbourne lose: Pick 25
Melbourne gain: Jake Melksham

St. Kilda lose: Pick 5
St. Kilda gain: Nathan Freeman + Jake Carlisle

We don't give up 23 this way.

I like, I like!

 

[efcboy]

Or the 4 way with Collingwood and Melbourne:


Collingwood lose: Nathan Freeman
Collingwood gain: Pick 25

Essendon lose: Jake Carlisle + Jake Melksham
Essendon gain: Pick 5

Melbourne lose: Pick 25
Melbourne gain: Jake Melksham

St. Kilda lose: Pick 5
St. Kilda gain: Nathan Freeman + Jake Carlisle

We don't give up 23 this way.

I'd rather pick 5 for Carlisle and pick 25 for Melksham thanks.

 

[eth-dog]

I'd rather pick 5 for Carlisle and pick 25 for Melksham thanks.

Which Ameet has ruled out.

 

[Rack Watts]

Let him walk to Carlton.

 

[Old Campaigner]

How hard is it to get a player to change their mind once they've nominated a club?

 

[Lord Nicholson]

Or the 4 way with Collingwood and Melbourne:


Collingwood lose: Nathan Freeman
Collingwood gain: Pick 25

Essendon lose: Jake Carlisle + Jake Melksham
Essendon gain: Pick 5

Melbourne lose: Pick 25
Melbourne gain: Jake Melksham

St. Kilda lose: Pick 5
St. Kilda gain: Nathan Freeman + Jake Carlisle

We don't give up 23 this way.

clearly an avid settlers of catan player

 

[DapperJong]

How hard is it to get a player to change their mind once they've nominated a club?

THERE ARE WAYS MUAHAHAHAHAHA

 

[theboxmike]

making stupid and unrealistic demands

I don't think an 8 year potential AA CHB should go for anything less than pick 5.

 

[eth-dog]

THERE ARE WAYS MUAHAHAHAHAHA

Kim, you're showing your megalomaniac side again.

 

[MAAAATTDAAAAMON]

Players have too much power. Would I be right in saying that Nick Stevens Carlton pickup wouldn't happen today? Surely today Stevens would say.. Sorry Carlton and AFL, I want Collingwood and he'd get there. ??

 

[Howard Moon]

Dodoro : I want billings
Ameet: shuttup little boy