Could this have been the winning formula?

[nobulltiger]

FF: Arnot Reiwoldt Lloyd
HF: A. Edwards SHULZ Martin
Wing: MATT WHITE

 

[Cevap_Roll]

People really need to get over those players leaving. Especially Schultz it happened years ago.

 

[nobulltiger]

I feel like having a cry about it alright

 

[Gentlemen]

"what if's" are dumb

 

[WATiger86]

FF: TAMBLING Reiwoldt RAINES
HF: McGUANE Vickery RODAN
RUCK: DERICKX

Fixed

 

[sante]

What if we drafted Franklin over Tambling?

 

[TigerAndy]

FF: Arnot Reiwoldt Lloyd
HF: A. Edwards SHULZ Martin
Wing: MATT WHITE

So what you are saying is that we should have held on to Schultz for 5 seasons waiting for him to hit his straps (we traded him end of 2009)? Are you saying that we should have paid overs for Matt White based on what he did at Richmond at the time that he was with us to keep him?

We are all Nostradamus with the advantage of hindsight. Tigers were right to let both of these players go at the time they let them go

 

[TigerAndy]

What if we drafted Franklin over Tambling?

Tambling would have been traded to Adelaide and Franklin would have been traded to Sydney. Hawthorn losing Franklin helps tiger supporters justify things.

 

[Cevap_Roll]

If only we had the COLA

FF: S.Edwards Riewoldt Llyod
HF: Tippett Franklin Martin

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

FF: Arnot Reiwoldt Lloyd
HF: A. Edwards SHULZ Martin
Wing: MATT WHITE

So who is our back up ruck? Or do you expect one of Hampson/Maric to ruck the entire game?

 

[nobulltiger]

So who is our back up ruck? Or do you expect one of Hampson/Maric to ruck the entire game?

Griffiths of course

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

Griffiths of course

You didn't list him. Where does he start? On the wing? CHB?

 

[nobulltiger]

So what you are saying is that we should have held on to Schultz for 5 seasons waiting for him to hit his straps (we traded him end of 2009)? Are you saying that we should have paid overs for Matt White based on what he did at Richmond at the time that he was with us to keep him?

We are all Nostradamus with the advantage of hindsight. Tigers were right to let both of these players go at the time they let them go

1. We wouldn't have been paying overs for white, I think he was asking for a reasonable price.
2. Shultz didn't take another 5 years, he had an instant impact at port (If i remember correctly)

 

[nobulltiger]

You didn't list him. Where does he start? On the wing? CHB?

Bench

 

[Rodney Dangerfield]

Don't forget Fiora over Pav.
And Cloke picked the wrong team....
HF- Martin Riewoldt Pavlich
F- Cloke Franklin Schulz
Lol

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

And big Derricxx in the ruck to please every one...

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

Don't forget Fiora over Pav.
And Cloke picked the wrong team....
HF- Martin Riewoldt Pavlich
F- Cloke Franklin Schulz
Lol

That line up wouldn't function at ground level. Better chuck McBean in to rove the crumbs.

 

[Rich01]

Bench

Nah. Some Tiger posters here were so furious he was playing VFL last week they think he will be off to Port at the end of the year.

Based on this, I don't think he'd be happy on the bench.

 

[nobulltiger]

Nah. Some Tiger posters here were so furious he was playing VFL last week they think he will be off to Port at the end of the year.

Based on this, I don't think he'd be happy on the bench.

There's nothing wrong with bench

 

[nobulltiger]

Maybe people would like this better

F: A. Edwards Reiwoldt Lloyd
HF: Griffiths Shultz Vickery
Wing: Matt White

 

[Barry_Badrinath]

Maybe people would like this better

F: A. Edwards Reiwoldt Lloyd
HF: Griffiths Shultz Vickery
Wing: Matt White

4 talls plus another play who plays tall? Nah.

 

[JAKLAUGHING]

Oh yeah...Nahas...

 

[TigerAndy]

1. We wouldn't have been paying overs for white, I think he was asking for a reasonable price.
2. Shultz didn't take another 5 years, he had an instant impact at port (If i remember correctly)

Point taken on Schultz Nobulltiger.
I just find it amusing that it is only when P.A are up and absolutely firing that the Schultz name gets thrown up in our forward line.

As far as White goes we will have to agree to disagree. There is no way we should have matched the P.A offer via free agency. According to an article in the Age last year White was told he was a required played but not on top dollar or on a 3 year contact - which I agree was the right decision

 

[Rodney Dangerfield]

I love whitey but happy to reserve judgement until the business end.
Odds are he will at some stage begin to stink it up and/or get injured.
I'm happy for him but it's a long season.

 

[Groupie_]

A.Edwardes should never play another RFC game.

Hopeless